Browns grab Carlos Hyde in free agency; does it take Saquon Barkley off their board?

The Cleveland Browns have been busy little bees this offseason and they have managed to throw a lot of wrenches in a lot of mock drafts with their various maneuvers in both the trade and free-agency markets. John Dorsey did it again on Wednesday morning, with the Browns reportedly agreeing to terms with running back Carlos Hyde.

The deal is worth three years and $15 million, according to Ian Rapoport of NFL Media

Hyde is a nice fit in Cleveland, too. They tried to draft and develop Isaiah Crowell but it never panned out (although Crowell is still fairly young). Duke Johnson has looked like a very talented playmaker, even if his usage hasn't been perfect, but he's not a feature back. Pairing a power back like Hyde with a home-run/pass-catching threat like Johnson is the ideal situation for a team like the Browns.

Cleveland now has Tyrod Taylor under center, Hyde/Johnson in the backfield, Jarvis Landry/Corey Coleman/Josh Gordon at wide receiver -- we'll see how long that trio lasts though -- and a pretty impressive group of offensive linemen up front. Joe Thomas possibly retiring should be a concern; Nate Solder was thought to be a replacement but he's headed to the Giants in free agency now. Either way, the Browns are at least interesting on offense. 

As for the financials of the deal, it illustrates the running-back market pretty well: Hyde is going to be a top-10 back in terms of average annual value of his contract per year. 

His deal gives him $5 million per year, which puts him tied with Dion Lewis, who agreed to a four-year, $20 million deal with the Titans on Tuesday, and Latavius Murray, who signed with the Vikings last offseason, at ninth overall. Here are the top nine contracts in average annual value: Le'Veon Bell (franchise tag), Devonta Freeman, LeSean McCoy, Jerick McKinnon, Leonard Fournette (rookie deal), Lamar Miller, Ezekiel Elliott (rookie deal), Giovani Bernard (!), Murray, Lewis and Hyde. 

McKinnon, of course, was just signed by the 49ers on Wednesday, another toy John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan snagged for Jimmy Garoppolo in free agency.

You can expect Saquon Barkley to be drafted early enough in the 2018 NFL Draft that he will enter that group as well, pushing Lewis/Murray/Hyde out of the top 10. 

And this is where the Hyde thing gets really interesting, because the Browns have been tied a lot to Barkley in the draft. There are a lot of scenarios out there where the Browns take Barkley first overall, including in my most recent 2018 NFL mock draft.

One would think with Hyde in the fold and Johnson on the roster it would take Barkley out of play. Not so fast, according to Aditi Kinkhabwala of NFL Network, who reported Wednesday from the Browns facility that Cleveland still very much has Barkley on its board.

"[I'm told] signing Carlos Hyde does not disqualify Barkley. That does not mean Barkley comes off the board here," Kinkhabwala said. "Remember, Hue Jackson has worked with multiple backs. He likes a platoon of backs. And look, we saw these two Super Bowl teams both use three backs apiece."

All of those are good points, and let's not forget the lesson from the Bengals, who paid Bernard a lot of money (see list above), had Jeremy Hill on the roster and still drafted Joe Mixon last year. That was after Hue Jackson left, but Rex Burkhead was also in the fold back when Jackson was there. There's a case to be made the Browns could use lots of running backs.

But there's also a case to be made that signing Hyde and developing/extending Johnson is a MUCH better use of resources than using a top-five pick on Barkley. Instead, the Browns can take their quarterback (Josh Allen, Sam Darnold, whoever) at No. 1 and then utilize the No. 4 pick to do a number of different things.

Grab Bradley Chubb or Minkah Fitzpatrick. Auction the pick and trade down. Take a second quarterback just in case the first one doesn't mess up. I mean, not really, but is that worse than taking a running back when you already have two of them on the roster?

The point being the Browns continue to make big moves and we can't guarantee which way they go. Maybe they'll take two running backs in the top five. Anything is on the table.

CBS Sports Senior Writer

Will Brinson joined CBS Sports in 2010 and enters his seventh season covering the NFL for CBS. He previously wrote for FanHouse along with myriad other Internet sites. A North Carolina native who lives... Full Bio

Our Latest Stories
    24/7 Scores, News, Highlights
    FREE ON ALL YOUR DEVICES