Bucs taking major risk with Revis

Darrelle Revis missed 13 games after tearing an ACL last season. (Getty Images)
Darrelle Revis missed 13 games after tearing an ACL last season. (USATSI)

The pending Darrelle Revis trade from the New York Jets to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers can be reduced to this: young, healthy, cheap, inexperienced but talented vs. older, super talented, wildly expensive and injured.

I know which way I would lean.

The Bucs leaned the other way.

More on Darrelle Revis trade
Related links
More NFL coverage

Tampa Bay is sending the 13th pick in the first round of this week's draft -- the young talent -- plus a conditional fourth-round pick (probably a third) in 2014 for the rights to sign Revis. They also signed him to a deal that will pay him $16 million a year for this season and for the next five. All this for a guy who turns 28 in July and is coming off ACL surgery.

Are you kidding me? 

When I asked five general managers if they would make the deal, they all replied with an emphatic no. They pointed at the risk of paying and trading to get a player coming off an ACL. Revis is in Tampa Sunday to take a physical, but a doctor's check of a knee won't tell them if he can plant and cut and do the things corners need to do.

"You have to trust your doctors," one Tampa Bay source said.

When healthy, Revis is special. But he's not healthy. No matter how the spin doctors -- see agents -- spin it, they can't for certain say he will be the same player.

He might be -- but no guarantee.

If Revis becomes a shutdown corner again, the Bucs will have a nice secondary with safeties Dashon Goldson and Mark Barron and fellow corner Eric Wright. But the Ravens won a Super Bowl with Cary Williams and Corey Graham starting at the corners.

It's a passing-pass rush league.

That's why even with Revis the Bucs will go nowhere if quarterback Josh Freeman and young defensive ends Da'Quan Bowers and Adrian Clayborn -- also coming off an ACL -- don't improve.

I just don't like the idea of paying and giving up picks for a guy coming off an ACL. Medicine has improved a ton, and Adrian Peterson showed you could come back, but there are other guys who have struggled to come back from ACL injuries.

The Bucs should have held on to the No. 13 pick and taken a corner, maybe Xavier Rhodes from Florida State or Desmond Trufant of D.J. Hayden. That would have been cheap labor for a while.

That's what this trade boils down to for Tampa Bay: Revis vs. a young corner. For the Jets, it means they are getting rid of a player who could leave with no compensation next year, a player seemingly always unhappy with his contract. Oh, and he's also coming off a torn ACL.

So it's a win for the Jets -- who are in rebuilding mode. 

Even with Revis, the Bucs are the third team at best in their division. Is it worth it? 

CBS Sports Senior Writer

Pete Prisco has covered the NFL for three decades, including working as a beat reporter in Jacksonville for the Jaguars. When he's not watching game tape, you can find Pete on Twitter or dreaming of an... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
Our Latest Stories
    CBS Sports Shop