Coaching hires: Do we really know if they are good or not?

New Redskins coach Jay Gruden ran the Bengals offense the past three seasons. (USATSI)
New Redskins coach Jay Gruden ran the Bengals offense the past three seasons. (USATSI)

More NFL: Coaching change tracker | Latest coaching news

We sit here each year when new NFL coaches are hired and immediately this guy will be good and that guy won’t be any good.

I am guilty of it as well.

The hot coordinators are always the sexy picks, but are they good because they have good players? Are the name coaches who get second chances still willing to put in the work or are they looking for a check? We've seen many who weren't as driven and many who were far more disorganized than what their reputation truly said about them. Many players have told me over the years how disappointed they were in some of these "reputation" coaches. Some assistants who have worked for them have as well. 

So as Jay Gruden takes over as the coach of the Washington Redskins after running the Bengals offense the past three seasons, we really have no idea what kind of job he will do.

Running an offense, which I didn't think he did well, and running a team are two different skill-sets.

When Mike Smith was named the head coach of the Atlanta Falcons, it was a move that was ripped by all. Who was he? What had he ever done?

In his first five seasons in Atlanta, the Falcons went to the playoffs four times and were the top seed in two of those years. They haven't won a Super Bowl, and Smith is clearly on the hot seat heading into 2014, but his tenure has been a good one.

So as these hires are announced, just remember we really have no idea if a guy will be a good head coach.

Is Gruden getting hired for his name? Some may say that. I would hope that's not the case and it's not fair to him. I thought he was far too predicatable as a coordinator in Cincinnati, but that doesn't mean he can't be a good head coach. 

Then again, maybe he won't be.

But didn't Mike Shanahan take over the Redskins with two Super Bowl rings in his back pocket and a reputation almost as big as his kid's ego? How did that work out?

CBS Sports Senior Writer

Pete Prisco has covered the NFL for three decades, including working as a beat reporter in Jacksonville for the Jaguars. When he's not watching game tape, you can find Pete on Twitter or dreaming of an... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
Our Latest Stories