Sometimes I read how important it is for a young quarterback to have the same offensive coordinator from his rookie year to his second season in the NFL. Other times I read how vital it is for a given team to make a change at offensive coordinator for its quarterback from Year 1 to Year 2 as a pro.
Those two conflicting thoughts got me thinking.
What's recently been more beneficial for young quarterbacks? Having the same offensive coordinator from Year 1 to Year 2, or a new offensive coordinator from Year 1 to Year 2?
The first school of thought of course centers around the idea of continuity. The second aligns with an idea that a new offensive coordinator was hired as -- hopefully -- an upgrade from the offensive coordinator the quarterback had as a rookie. I conducted some research.
Here were the requirements for quarterbacks to be included in the study:
- Drafted between 2008 and 2017
- Attempted at least 200 passes as a rookie and 100-plus passes in Year 2.
There were 30 quarterbacks who met the criteria.
These 18 quarterbacks who hit the pass attempt thresholds did not have an offensive coordinator change after their rookie season:
- Carson Wentz, Jameis Winston, Dak Prescott, Teddy Bridgewater, C.J. Beathard, Deshaun Watson, Russell Wilson, Cam Newton, Andy Dalton, Robert Griffin III, Matt Ryan, Joe Flacco, Christian Ponder, Mark Sanchez, Geno Smith, Ryan Tannehill, EJ Manuel, Josh Freeman
12 quarterbacks who hit the pass attempt thresholds experienced an offensive coordinator change after their rookie season:
- Derek Carr, Blake Bortles, Marcus Mariota, Mitchell Trubisky, Jared Goff, Andrew Luck, Mike Glennon, Sam Bradford, Brandon Weeden, Blaine Gabbert, Nick Foles, Colt McCoy
Obviously not the largest sample size in either category, but there's a good mix of quality and lackluster quarterbacks.
Here are the findings. What you'll see below are the statistical differences in Year 1 and Year 2 for the two groups of quarterbacks. To keep it a level playing field, I used TD % and INT % instead of totals. Total QBR is a statistic created by ESPN that incorporates much more into a quarterback's play in a given game or season than passer rating, such as rushing, penalties, and the length of each pass thrown, among many other things.
|Comp %||TD %||INT %||Yards Per Attempt||Passer Rating||Total QBR|
No OC Change
No OC Change
No OC Change
As you probably guessed, on average, stats improved across the board for the quarterbacks in both groups.
Quarterbacks who experienced the biggest statistical jumps from Year 1 to Year 2 with a new offensive coordinator were Mitchell Trubisky, Jared Goff, Andrew Luck, Blaine Gabbert, and especially Nick Foles. Those who had the opposite results? Sam Bradford, Brandon Weeden, and Colt McCoy.
Of those who had the same offensive coordinator in Year 1 and Year 2, Carson Wentz, C.J. Beathard, Joe Flacco, Matt Ryan, Christian Ponder, Mark Sanchez, and especially Josh Freeman had the largest improvements as sophomores in the NFL. Dak Prescott and Robert Griffin III saw the biggest, most noteworthy dips in efficiency.
As a whole, the stats of the group of quarterbacks who were given continuity by having the same offensive coordinator in their first two NFL seasons were less volatile than the other group with collectively smaller improvements.
For context, seven of the 18 quarterbacks with the same offensive coordinator in both years averaged a 2.64 improvement in QBR, and just two had a 20-plus point boost in QBR (Wentz and Freeman).
However, just three quarterbacks of the 12 in the changed offensive coordinator group bettered their QBR by fewer than 10 points, while four saw skyrocketed QBRs in Year 2 of more than 20 points. That means, 33% of those quarterbacks got significantly better in Year 2 with a new offensive coordinator compared to just 11.1% of the other group that experienced massive QBR jumps.
Looking at each stat individually, quarterbacks without an offensive coordinator change saw a bigger improvement in completion percentage and threw interceptions at a lower rate on average. The 1.99 difference in completion percentage might seem small. It's not really. Based solely on last season's figures, it's slightly more than the difference between fourth-place finisher Matt Ryan (69.4%) and 11th-place finisher Andrew Luck (67.4%). Decreasing the interception rate by 0.7 on average is rather sizable too. It's the same difference as 12th-place finisher Tom Brady (1.9%) and the 21st-best interception % last year held by Case Keenum (2.6%).
The new offensive coordinator group had the advantage in every other stat category (TD %, YPA, Passer Rating, and Total QBR) on average. The 9.3-point difference in Total QBR is rather large. It represents nearly the same difference from Jared Goff in 2018, who finished in 10th with a Total QBR of 65.1 and Nick Mullens, who had the 21st-highest Total QBR at 56.2. The YPA improvement of 0.73 yards equates to basically the same difference between 2018 Ben Roethlisberger (7.6, 13th place), and Sam Darnold (6.92, 26th place).
The new offensive coordinator group averaged a 12.1-point improvement in that statistic, which is like going from 2018 Deshaun Watson -- who finished 6th with a 103.1 passer rating -- to Mullens in 23rd-place at 90.8.
Here's how 2018's famed draft class of quarterbacks fared as rookies:
|Rookie Stats||Comp %||TD %||INT %||YPA||Passer Rating||Total QBR|
And here's how their 2019 seasons look after giving them the average statistical boosts based on whether or not they'll have the same offensive coordinator (play caller) or not in their second seasons:
|2019 Projection Using Averages||Comp %||TD %||INT %||YPA||Passer Rating||QBR|
Baker Mayfield (Same OC)
Sam Darnold (New OC)
Josh Rosen (New OC)
Josh Allen (Same OC)
Lamar Jackson (New OC)
*Mayfield will have a new offensive coordinator in 2019, but head coach Freddie Kitchens, who called plays last season, will hang onto the play-caller role in Cleveland.
Of course, much more goes into the play of a quarterback than solely the offensive coordinator. The supporting cast plays a major role as do the defenses each quarterback has to face.
But now you know how, over the past decade, quarterbacks have fared with and without a new offensive coordinator in Year 1 and Year 2.