As of early Friday morning -- hacked Instagram posts notwithstanding -- Jimmy Garoppolo remains an employee of the New England Patriots, and only the most exorbitant of trade proposals will pry him from Bill Belichickâs hands.
The Browns are -- and have been -- Garoppoloâs biggest suitor, and for good reason: Cleveland doesnât have the best track record when it comes to drafting quarterbacks in the first round -- Johnny Manziel, Brandon Weeden and Brady Quinn are the three most recent examples -- and armed with two first-rounders (the first overall pick and No. 12), the team could instead trade some of those picks for their next franchise QB.
Except that the Patriots reportedly want the Brownsâ No. 1 in the 2017 NFL Draft, and maybe even their 2018 first-round pick too. If that seems extreme, it is. Garoppolo has thrown a grand total of 94 passes since coming into the league in 2014. And you stare at the tape from his preseason play -- or the two starts he had to begin the 2016 regular season -- all you want, but thereâs scant evidence that heâs worth what the Patriots are reportedly asking.
So whatâs Belichick up to?
According to ESPNâs Adam Schefter, itâs simple. âYou could ask [Belichick], and I am sure he will speak for himself, but I have spoken to enough people who have given me enough answers like yesterday, someone else texted me and said, âDoes Cleveland know weâre not trading Jimmy Garoppolo?ââ Schefter told WEEIâs Kirk and Callahan on Friday morning. âWeâre going back to what we said before. I am basing my answers in what I believe is factual information. I know people want to take it in a different way. I am telling you thatâs not right.â
Schefter continued: âIf they traded Jimmy Garoppolo and something were to happen to Tom Brady next season, the year after, they would be the Cleveland Browns. What would they be doing at quarterback? What was it like for that franchise before Tom Brady came along.â
So there you have it. Belichick, at least to hear Schefter tell it, is afraid of becoming the Browns. Thatâs a legitimate fear, but a lot of people donât believe it. Hereâs what CBSSports.comâs Pete Prisco wrote last week from the NFL combine:
This, to me, smells of a calculated play by Patriots coach and general manager Bill Belichick. He is trying to drive up the price for Garoppolo. What would be the point to keeping him?
There is none. Tom Brady has continually said he will play another four years or more, and whoâs to say he canât? He turns 40 this year, but he was sensational rallying the Patriots from 25 points down to claim a Super Bowl victory over the Falcons last month. Did he look old? Washed up? Breaking down?
So why keep Garoppolo around? Some will say itâs insurance for next season. Let me tell you something: If Brady were to go down for any length of time, the Patriots are done.
As it stands, Garoppolo heads into the final year of his rookie deal and heâs set to make close to $900,000 in 2017. The Patriots could hold onto him as insurance against a 40-year-old Brady staying healthy. But with Brady expecting to play at least another 2-3 years, what do the Patriots do a year from now? Garoppolo, who wants to play, isnât going to sign a team-friendly deal. And New England wouldnât franchise a backup, right?
Which is why Prisco is rightly skeptical.
Again, the question of the day: Why in the world would the Patriots hold onto Jimmy Garoppolo if Brady plays three more years? Rationale?
— Pete Prisco (@PriscoCBS) March 10, 2017
If Pats love Jimmy Garoppolo so much, why not give him an extension now for $15-20 million a year.
— Pete Prisco (@PriscoCBS) March 10, 2017
For now, Garoppolo remains on the Patriotsâ depth chart behind Brady, who appears as if heâll play forever. Perhaps Belichick has other ideas about Bradyâs future. Or perhaps heâs only trying to drive up Garoppoloâs price before ultimately shipping him out of town -- and heâll take his chances at not morphing into the Cleveland Browns.