Skip to Main Content

USA vs. Canada hockey takeaways: Connor McDavid nets winner in overtime for 4 Nations Face-Off championship

Canada has beaten Team USA in the 4 Nations Face-Off in an overtime thriller, 3-2, Thursday night in Boston. Connor McDavid scored the game winner to become a national hero and hockey legend.

After dropping the first meeting against Team USA on Saturday in Montreal, Canada asserted itself as the premier hockey powerhouse in the world. This win was also eerily similar to Sidney Crosby's "Golden Goal" at the 2010 Vancouver Olympics with Canada's biggest star plunging the dagger into the Americans.

Team USA's defense was exceptional for nearly the entire tournament, but it made a critical error in overtime. The Americans let McDavid find some quiet ice in the slot, and Mitch Marner knew exactly where to go with the puck when he got it on his stick.

Marner slipped a pass just out of the reach of Toronto Maple Leafs teammate Auston Matthews, and McDavid buried a shot over the shoulder of Connor Hellebuyck to win the game.

Up until his overtime goal, McDavid had a relatively quiet night by his standards. He had two shots on goal, and the Americans were able to hold him in check off the rush. In an on-ice interview with ESPN, McDavid admitted he wasn't at his best, but he just kept looking forward to the next play.

"I was not very good all night," McDavid said. "All that was going through my mind was just, 'Keep going.' I struggled all night, but these guys played great, and we just found a way."

The other hero of overtime was Canadian goaltender Jordan Binnington, who was much-maligned through the first three games. In the first few minutes of overtime, the Americans peppered Canada's netminder. Binnington denied Matthews on a chance in the low slot, and he flashed the glove to rob Brady Tkachuk of what appeared to be a wide open cage.

Binnington finished the night with 31 saves on 33 shots, which will go down as one of the best performances of his career given the stage.

Nathan MacKinnon, who registered Canada's first goal, was named the tournament MVP.  He finished the 4 Nations Face-Off with four goals in four games.

Same Bennett had the second goal for Canada, which knotted the score late in the second period.

Brady Tkachuk, who played well in the most meaningful game of his career, had the first tally for Team USA. That goal tied the game at 1. His Ottawa Senators teammate, Jake Sanderson, was the next player to light the lamp, giving the Americans a 2-1 lead.

This highly-anticipated rematch of the round robin clash delivered on the hype with back-and-forth action that extended past 60 minutes. Canada and the United States both held a lead at some point in this game, and the pace was outstanding. Now we just have to wait 356 days until the 2026 Winter Olympics in Italy.

4 Nations Face-Off winners & losers: United States-Canada rivalry revived, All-Star weekend concept pales
Chris Bengel
4 Nations Face-Off winners & losers: United States-Canada rivalry revived, All-Star weekend concept pales

Connor McDavid's moment

Even Connor McDavid himself acknowledged that he wasn't at his best for most of that game. Pucks were bouncing off his stick, and he wasn't generating as much offense as you'd expect from the best player in the world. However, when the game was on the line, he made the biggest play.

Despite his issues earlier in the game, there was no question about McDavid's ability to perform in high-leverage situations. All he did last postseason was lead the Edmonton Oilers to within one win of a Stanley Cup while rewriting the record books and winning the Conn Smythe Trophy while on the losing side. Still, it was a nice feather in his cap to score what will now be an iconic goal in Canadian hockey history.

McDavid just hasn't had many of those opportunities since entering the NHL. The only time we've seen him in major international competition since he was drafted was in the 2016 World Cup of Hockey. At that time, he was just 19 years old on Team North America, an exciting but inexperienced team that got bounced in round-robin play.

With the NHL back in the Olympics and putting on international tournaments like this, McDavid will get to showcase his talents in best-on-best competitions. That's where other Canadian legends (see: Sidney Crosby) have enhanced the legacy they built in the NHL.

Redemption for Jordan Binnington

When the Canadian goaltending trio was announced for this tournament, that position was immediately flagged as a possible concern. There wasn't even any guarantee that Jordan Binnington would start. In fact, there were questions about whether Binnington would start on a game-to-game basis in this tournament after allowing some relatively soft goals.

Through it all, Canadian coach Jon Cooper stuck by Binnington, and that confidence paid off in a huge way on Thursday night. Binnington saved 31 of the 33 shots he faced, and he saved his biggest stops for overtime. In a matter of moments, Auston Matthews and Brady Tkachuk both had the game on their stick, and Binnington slammed the door.

If it weren't for Binnington, who went toe-to-toe with the best goalie in the world at the other end, the game would have been over long before McDavid got open in the American zone. There were plenty of Binnington doubters, of which I was one, but he returned to his 2019 Stanley Cup Final form in Boston.

Olympic rematch?

We now have exactly 356 days until men's ice hockey begins at the 2026 Olympics in Italy. As much as I'd hate to wish away a full year, I'm already itching for more of this.

The NHL sat out of international hockey competitions for almost a decade, and it's clear now that it was detrimental to the league. This small mid-season tournament produced the best hockey I've seen in years, and it completely reignited the rivalry between the United States and Canada -- while also dumping a barrel of gasoline on it.

Going into next year's Olympics, the Canadians will be looking to defend their place atop the hockey world, but that's not necessarily new for them. What is new is that other countries are closing the gap, and Team USA in particular will be looking to avenge this loss. Imagine this matchup again, except with iconic Olympic gold medals being on the line as opposed to a new trophy that people don't know.

On top of the United States-Canada dynamic, there will also be a bigger collection of NHL superstars. Assuming Russia is given the green light, Alex Ovechkin will play in what may very well be his last Olympics. David Pastrnak and Czechia will want a shot to prove themselves. Leon Draisaitl will lead Germany. Roman Josi and Nico Hischier will do the same for Switzerland.

International best-on-best hockey is back in a major way. If we got this level of drama from what most thought would be an afterthought of an event, just imagine what the biggest and most important international hockey tournament will produce.

Updates
(24)
See New Posts
 
Pinned
Link copied

FINAL: Canada 3, USA 2 (OT)

Team USA made one major defensive mistake all tournament, and it couldn't have come at a worse time. Connor McDavid was left all alone in the slot, and Mitch Marner found him for the game-winning goal. McDavid had a relatively quiet night until that moment, but he made his mark and then some with one shot.

The Americans played a great game -- and an excellent tournament overall -- but they fell just short of a championship win over Canada. At least they don't have to wait very long for their next shot. The 2026 Olympics start in just under a year.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Who has the OT edge?

Well, let's start here. The last time these two teams met in the championship of a best-on-best international tournament, Sidney Crosby scored in overtime to beat the United States in the gold medal game at the 2010 Vancouver Olympics. Having that experience matters, and Crosby lives for moments like these.

Having said that, I do think goaltending plays a big role here. I would already prefer to have Hellebuyck in goal, but that's especially the case when the next shot could the last. Binnington has let a couple squeakers by him in this tournament already, and every puck that gets thrown toward the Canadian net is a little more dangerous. In that regard, the scales are tilted in the Americans' favor.

 
Pinned
Link copied

End of 3rd: USA 2, Canada 2

Was there any other way for this game to end? I think not. That was a tense third period filled with close calls for both teams. Team USA was better in the early part of the final frame, but Canada came within inches of taking the lead on multiple occasions. Now, just one shot will end this game.

While the round robin games used 3-on-3 overtime for 10 minutes, the championship will use NHL playoff overtime rules. It will be five-on-five until someone scores for 20-minute periods. How long will we have to wait for a winner to be decided?

 
Pinned
Link copied

Shutdown Slavin

Jaccob Slavin has been one of the best players in this game. Anytime it looks like Canada is about to finish off a glorious scoring chance, Slavin steps in the way to snuff out the play. His latest effort was on an odd-man rush when he laid out for a perfectly timed block on fellow Carolina Hurricane Seth Jarvis. Slavin has prevented at least a couple of shot on goal already tonight.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Tense start to third period

Both teams have had excellent chances to take the lead, but clutch saves or bad bounces have prevented either side from scoring the all-important next goal. None of the chances were as close as Brandon Hagel's deflection in front of Connor Hellebuyck. The puck trickled just wide of the net and bounced off the post. That one stopped more than a few hearts in TD Garden.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Matthew Tkachuk tests injury

Matthew Tkachuk was injured coming into this game, and it's clearly been affecting him. Tkachuk spent a lot of time on the bench in the second period. Late in the frame, he took a quick five-second spin on the ice before jumping right back over the boards and sitting next to Jake Oettinger. If Tkachuk is out, it will be a massive loss for the Americans, but his brother Brady has been picking up a lot of the slack tonight.

 
Pinned
Link copied

End of 2nd Period: USA 2, Canada 2

It's only appropriate that this heavyweight battle will go to the third period tied. It's what this rivalry deserves.

The second period was another eventful ones with some unlikely scorers doing the damage. Jake Sanderson, who wasn't originally supposed to be in the lineup until Charlie McAvoy got hurt, gave Team USA a 2-1 lead when he crashed the slot looking for a rebound.

Grinder Sam Bennett evened the score for Canada as he executed a perfect 3-on-2 play with Mitch Marner and roofed a shot over the shoulder of Connor Hellebuyck.

Who will emerge as the hero in this third period (or maybe overtime)?

 
Pinned
Link copied

2nd Period: USA 2, Canada 2

A missed connection by new New York Rangers teammates Adam Fox and JT Miller leads to an odd-man rush the other way for Canada. Mitch Marner slid a pass for Sam Bennett as the two swapped places, and that allowed Bennett to waltz down Main Street. Bennett finished the play with a perfect shot just under the crossbar to beat Hellebuyck.

This was a good response from the Canadians as Team USA seemed to be taking some degree of control. We're back to even once again.

 
Pinned
Link copied

2nd Period: USA 2, Canada 1

Jake Sanderson, inserted into the lineup for the injured Charlie McAvoy, has given Team USA the lead. Once again, the line of Auston Matthews between the Tkachuk brothers got the play started. Brady Tkachuk and Matthews were in on the forecheck when Matthews' attempt kicked off bodies in front and bounced to a crashing Sanderson, who deposited it into the net.

For the second straight period, a push from the Canadians has been answered with an American goal.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Canada controlling pace in the second

Team USA has had some real issues with puck management in the early portion of the second period. Canada wanted to play a more north-south game in this rematch, and it has done just that so far. The Canadian forecheck is giving the American defense some issues, and errant passes have resulted in excellent scoring chances for the team sporting the maple leaf. Only Connor Hellebuyck and some near misses have kept this game tied.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Americans' dominance in final 40 minutes

Getting out of the first period tied was a win for an American team that has been excellent after the first period. In its first three games of the tournament, Team USA has outscored opponents 7-0 in the final two periods. As the second period begins, we're about to find out whether that trend will continue against the Canadians. Although I suspect the second and third periods in this championship game will be an absolute slugfest.

 
Pinned
Link copied

1st Period: USA 1, Canada 1

Brady Tkachuk has evened the score for the United States. An attempted wraparound by Auston Matthews kicked out in front of Jordan Binnington, and Tkachuk chipped the loose puck past the Canadian netminder. Tkachuk is battling through injury, but you couldn't tell on that play as he fought to the slot to get inside positioning.

For much of this period, Canada has controlled the game, but one big play from the Americans has leveled the score.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Canada pushing early

Canada has already had more success getting to the U.S. net than it did in the first meeting. There have been a few scrambles in front of Connor Hellebuyck, and while the American goaltender has stood tall, it's concerning for Team USA that Canada has been able to get to the prime scoring areas so frequently. The Americans have had a few decent scoring chances, but the Canadians have controlled the opening period to this point.

 
Pinned
Link copied

1st Period: Canada 1, USA 0

After what was a strong start for Team USA, Canada draws first blood. Nathan MacKinnon was circling the offensive zone, and the puck traveled through four or five bodies before beating Connor Hellebuyck over his right shoulder. That's a deflating goal given the start for the U.S., but the Americans also trailed 1-0 in the first meeting.

 
Pinned
Link copied

First period underway

The puck is down, and the biggest game between Team USA and Canada in 15 years is underway. Who will be crowned the 4 Nations Face-Off champion and sit atop the international hockey hierarchy? Follow along for the next 60 minutes as we watch what should be terrific hockey.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Electric atmosphere on deck

Warmups just concluded at TD Garden, and the place was already nearing full capacity. It was also quite loud. The Canadians were audibly booed when they hit the ice, but there is clearly a decent contingent of road fans in the building. The Americans were cheered as chants of "U-S-A" broke out. You don't see atmospheres like this in mid-February very often.

 
Pinned
Link copied

4 Nations injury updates

Both teams are dealing with injury and illness, and a few players on each side were questionable coming into tonight. Now, with the game about to get underway, we have a little more clarity. The Tkachuk brothers and Auston Matthews are all expected to play for the Americans, and the Canadians are dealing with an illness to Josh Morrissey on the other side.

United States

Auston Matthews (IN)
Matthew Tkachuk (IN)
Brady Tkachuk (IN)
Charlie McAvoy (OUT)

Canada

Shea Theodore (OUT)
Josh Morrissey (OUT)

Right now, it looks like Thomas Harley will replace Morrissey for Canada. He replaced Cale Makar in the first game between these two teams. It also appears as though Chris Kreider will be in the U.S. lineup, taking the place of Kyle Connor.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Which penalty kill blinks first?

Throughout this tournament, Team USA and Canada have been perfect on the penalty kill, going a combined 10-for-10. The American penalty kill unit has been busier with seven opportunities, but both teams have been great while shorthanded. Will that continue or will one side blink? In a winner-take-all game like this one, special teams can have major impacts, and both teams have an embarrassment of riches on the power play.

 
Pinned
Link copied

McAvoy out for Team USA

There will be no Charlie McAvoy for Team USA after a shoulder injury he suffered against Finland got infected following the game against Canada. McAvoy was outstanding on Saturday night, and he laid a bone-rattling hit on Connor McDavid.

Filling the void left by McAvoy won't be easy for the U.S. but the depth of its blue line is certainly a strength. It helps to have Jaccob Slavin, one of the premier shutdown defenders in the NHL today. Slavin is fully capable of holding his own with Canada's most dangerous offensive weapons.

 
Pinned
Link copied

One hour til puck drop

Okay, so probably more like 80 minutes, but the official start time for this one is 8 p.m. ET, and it can't get here soon enough. This is the biggest game the U.S. and Canada have played since 2010, when Sidney Crosby cemented himself as a Canadian legend and broke American hearts with his "Golden Goal" to win the Vancouver Olympics. The difference this time around is that Team USA is much more talented, and the game is on American soil.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Hellebuyck vs. Binnington

If you're looking for Team USA's biggest advantage in this game, look no further than the blue ice at each end of the rink. Connor Hellebuyck against Jordan Binnington is as big a goaltending mismatch as you'll see in a tournament like this.

Hellebuyck looks poised to capture his third career Vezina Trophy with 27.8 goals saved above average (1st) and a .925 save percentage. Binnington, on the other had, has posted -5.59 goals saved above average and a .896 save percentage.

That disparity has carried over into the 4 Nations Face-Off. Hellebuyck has a 1.00 GAA and a .957 save percentage. Binnington has a 2.60 GAA and a .892 save percentage. If Canada wants to win this game, it either needs to solve Hellebuyck or Binnington needs to find another gear. Otherwise, the Americans will be celebrating on the ice at TD Garden.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Canada's fast starts, Team USA's strong finishes

These two teams couldn't be more different in the ways they've started and finished games this tournament. Canada has come out guns blazing in the first period, outscoring opponents 6-1 in the opening 20 minutes. The United States, on the other hand, has gotten better as the game progresses. Team USA has outscored its opponents 7-0 after the first period.

Will the Canadians' get off to another fast start? If so, can the Americans take over the game in final 40 minutes?

 
Pinned
Link copied

Another legacy game for Sidney Crosby?

Sidney Crosby will already go down as one of the best players in NHL history. With three Stanley Cups and a pair of Hart Trophy wins, Crosby's place in the Hockey Hall of Fame is already secured. But don't sleep on his legacy as on the biggest stages internationally.

He has a World Junior gold medal and a pair of Olympic gold medals, one of which came as a result of his "Golden Goal" to beat the U.S. in 2010. Crosby has been in these types of games countless times throughout his career, and that experience will prove valuable in a charged atmosphere like the one we'll see tonigt.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Another chapter in the US-Canada rivalry

This will be the fifth gold medal or championship matchup between these two countries in an NHL-sanctioned international event or the Olympics. Canada has a 3-1 edge in the prior meetings, with the 1996 World Cup of Hockey being the only win for the Americans.

  • 2010 | Vancouver Olympics | 3-2 Canada (OT)
  • 2002 | Salt Lake City Olympics | 5-2 Canada
  • 1996 | World Cup of Hockey | USA wins series 3-2
  • 1991 | Canada Cup | Canada wins series 2-0