USWNT draw against Colombia: Alex Morgan's penalty miss the difference as Jaedyn Shaw makes USA debut

Columbia v United States
Chris Gardner / Getty Images

The U.S. women's national team tied 0-0 with Colombia on Thursday at America First Field, as their indifferent form continued. This time it was Alex Morgan's first-half penalty miss that loomed large over the result.

The four-time Women's World Cup winners started the game slowly. Still, the story of the first half eventually became about their attacking effort, frequently stymied by an organized Colombia defense. The USWNT struggled to find the space to make meaningful attacking plays, but got close in the 25th minute when Lindsey Horan combined with Morgan, whose shot from close range was easily handled by goalkeeper Natalia Giraldo.

The USWNT's best chance of the game came just before halftime when Daniela Arias was called for a foul for grabbing Lynn Williams in the box, conceding a penalty. Morgan stepped up to take the shot, but sent the ball to the post and then missed the rebound. Her goalless streak in a USWNT jersey has now hit 10 games, with her last goal for the national team coming in February of this year.

The hosts put plenty of pressure on Colombia's defense to start the second half and earned a bunch of set pieces to back it up, but between shots in open play and those on freekicks and corners, they had little to show for it. USWNT interim head coach Twila Kilgore made several attacking substitutes in order to find a goal, including Sophia Smith, but the game winner never came.

The USWNT return to the pitch on Sunday, when they face Colombia again at San Diego's Snapdragon Stadium.

Here's some takeaways from the match:

Stagnant form continues

Going up against World Cup quarterfinalist Colombia wouldn't be a cakewalk for the USWNT. The group was coming off two wins against South Africa, and interim manager Kilgore said during pregame the group would be more focused on being clinical in the final third.

Kilgore took over the team in August and wanted the group to build on their final World Cup game against Sweden. The ultimate match featured the USWNT in a 4-2-3-1, with dual defensive midfielders in a pivot, with better opportunities to progress the ball. We saw a repeat performance against Colombia, with minor changes to the lineup after the retirements of Megan Rapinoe and Julie Ertz. 

The end product against Colombia was more lackluster than the September wins. The game was mostly even in possession and overall attack. It left more questions around the stagnant form of the team, hardly testing the Colombia defense, level with Las Cafeteras with two shots on target. 

With the head coaching search ongoing and the Olympics around the corner,  there will likely be little changes –  or new ideas –  to close out the calendar year. 

Don't miss CBS Sports Golazo Network's Morning Footy, now in podcast form! Our crew brings you all the news, views, highlights and laughs you need to follow the Beautiful Game in every corner of the globe, every Monday-Friday all year long.

Morgan still snakebit, Shaw makes debut

A penalty awarded to USNWT late in the first half was the first clear chance on goal for the team, but Morgan's attempt was off the post, adding to her scoreless drought with the team since February. She recently broke her streak for club (since June) with San Diego Wave FC, but that luck didn't follow her to the national team. 

Her NWSL teammate, Jaedyn Shaw, made her national team debut. The 18-year-old has had a productive 2023 NWSL season, with six goals and an even better ability to connect attackers with a final pass. She played four minutes in her national team debut. 

Sauerbrunn returns, Smith builds minutes

Other silver linings for the team as they're nine months out from the Olympics with no head coach were the return of Becky Sauerbrunn and Sophia Smith. Both are back in the mix after dealing with lower leg injuries. 

Smith is still building her minutes back up from a mild MCL sprain but subbed in with 15 minutes of regulation and nearly executed a game-winning opportunity late in the game. 

Sauerbrunn subbed in at halftime and contributed to the team's more urgent play out of the gate in the second half. The longtime veteran provided a more positive spin forward for the team on Sunday, touching on the ongoing coaching search.

"I've been around. I've been playing for this team for about 13 years now. So I've seen a lot of things, and I think as you transition to a new coach with new tactics, it might be good to have someone veteran, who's been through a coaching change before," she said after the game.

"You can kind of settle some nerves, and really, like this is an exciting time for players. They shouldn't see it as a looming thing on the horizon. It should be a chance to be like, 'Hey, we're all being evaluated at ground zero now and everyone's getting a free chance' is actually a really exciting time."

Updates
(26)
 
Pinned
Link copied

FT: USA 0-0 COL

The USWNT's attack got into a groove at the start of this second half, but Colombia found a way to keep them at bay and managed a couple of opportunities of their own. Still, neither side was able to find a goal which is to the credit of Colombia's sturdy defense. The performance leaves plenty of food for though for the USWNT ahead of their rematch on Sunday, and after their first scoreless game since the World Cup.

See New Posts
 
Pinned
Link copied

Smith with a last-ditch effort

90'+5 Things are frantic in the box but Smith is right in front of goal and has the shot, but Giraldo is able to send the ball out for a corner, which the USWNT does little with.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Shaw makes her debut

88' Shaw comes on for Williams for her first national team cap off the back of an impressive season for the San Diego Wave. Shaw was part of the September camp, but did not see the pitch during her first call-up to the national team.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Smith comes on

77' Smith comes on for Rodman for her first national team minutes since the World Cup, and with her first touch takes a shot that goes out for a corner. The USWNT is upping the intensity as they search for a goal.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Change of pace

75' After spending much of the second half absorbing the USWNT's pressure, Colombia have a few looks at goal themselves, Despite the encouraging plays, they are not able to make much of it. On the other end, Hatch seems to be in on goal but drifts too far wide and sends a shot into the side netting.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Changes for the USWNT

67' The USWNT will make three changes - Krueger, DeMelo and Hatch are on, Dunn, Sullivan, and Morgan come off.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Colombia with a shot

65' The visitors take their first shot in roughly 50 minutes in a rare attacking move for them in the second half, but Naeher is not challenged much and makes the stop.

 
Pinned
Link copied

A batch of set pieces

59' The USWNT earn a pair of freekicks on opposite sides of goal and then a corner, but not much comes of it. Though the USWNT seems to be lacking precision on set pieces, usually an area of strength, they are showing signs of optimism in this second half. They're having a much easier time getting through Colombia's defense and have built some serious momentum going forward.

 
Pinned
Link copied

USWNT rush toward goal

50' In the first meaningful shot of the second half, Williams makes a dash down the left flank and sends it over to Morgan who is making her own run towards goal, but she sends the ball over the goal with her quick touch.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Second half underway

The USWNT make one sub at the half - Sauerbrunn comes on for Girma. This will be Sauerbrunn's first appearance for the national team since April. The veteran center back missed time with a foot injury that also kept her off the World Cup squad.

 
Pinned
Link copied

HT: USA 0-0 COL

A very competitive first half comes to a close. The USWNT may have started slow but they spent much of the first half looking for ways to get forward, but Colombia's strong defensive organization truly limited the hosts. The USWNT got as close to scoring as it gets with a late penalty, but Morgan's miss means the game remains scoreless.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Morgan misses!

45' Morgan's powerful strike comes off the post and though the ball lands right at her feet, she sends it over the bar. Still 0-0 in Utah.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Penalty for the USWNT

43' The USWNT go through a series of corner with limited success, but Arias gets called for holding Williams in the box and the USWNT earn a penalty. Morgan to take.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Colombia get forward

39' The last few minutes have been all about the USWNT's attempts to get forward, but Colombia get a look as their attackers inch forward. The USWNT's defense is up for the task, with Dunn coming in clutch and sending the ball out for a throw in, allowing the hosts to restructure and kill the play.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Horan with a freekick

31' The USWNT earns a freekick and though there's plenty of distance in between the ball and the goal, Horan goes straight for goal with her strike. It sails over the goal, though.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Morgan shoots

25' The USWNT has showed promising signs in attack, most recently with a nice quick play that eventually sees Horan pass to Morgan in the center of the box. Morgan shoots right at goalkeeper Giraldo, though, so she is easily able to make the stop.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Patient start to the game

15' Both sides have made some promising runs, but if one side looks a touch more encouraging than the other, it's Colombia. Caicedo has been bright so far and the visitors have the first shot of the game, though it flew way over the goal.

 
Pinned
Link copied

First half underway

Colombia kicks things off and the game has officially begun.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Caicedo starts for Colombia

The teen sensation who broke out at the World Cup is in the lineup tonight. Here's the rest of the Colombia team that will face the USWNT.

Colombia starting XI: Giraldo, Arias, Carabali, Arias, Vanegas, Montoya, Bedoya Durango, Restrepo, Santos, Caicedo, Chacon

 
Pinned
Link copied

What they're saying 

The two-game series will serve as the final games for interim head coach Twila Kilgore as U.S. Soccer continues its search for the next head coach. Here's what she had to say about the training camp and upcoming matches:

USWNT interim head coach, Twila Kilgore -- "Well, I'm really excited to be back with the team. I always share with the team when we come back into camps, that the best part of coaching is actually being on the pitch and being with players. As a coach, it's a dream anytime you wear this crest. It's really, really, meaningful. And I love this team. I love this program. We're excited to be together. We're excited to build on where we left off and also take some next steps towards our style of play and being a little bit more clinical in the things that we're doing. But everybody came into camp ready to go and it's been a real joy so far."

 
Pinned
Link copied

Storylines: USWNT

The squad has been on a winning trend since their 2023 FIFA Women's World Cup elimination with interim coach Kilgore. They said farewell to Megan Rapinoe and Julie Ertz in their retirement games, defeated South Africa in the two September friendlies and will now face another World Cup opponent. The USWNT have nine wins and one draw against Colombia with their two most recent wins coming in 2022 ahead of the Concacaf W Championships.  

Becky Sauerbrunn and Sophia Smith are back with the squad after missing the September games with injuries. Kilgore and the group will likely build upon the 4-2-3-1 formation they found success with against South Africa.

 
Pinned
Link copied

Storylines: Colombia

The two-game event is the first for head coach Angela Marsiglia since taking over for former manager Nelson Abadia. She named a 23-player roster with 19 athletes who participated in the 2023 World Cup. Las Chicas Superpoderosas made a tournament run to the quarterfinals but were eliminated by England.  

They will play their first set of matches since the global tournament. The roster has some notable absences with Catalina Usme due to injury, and Mayra Ramirez, but features some key players from their cup run. Linda Caicedo and Leicy Santos are available so look for them to be mainstays in attacking sequences. 

 
Pinned
Link copied

The usuals start again

A lineup exclusively made up of players who competed at this year's World Cup get the start tonight. Here's a look at the USWNT lineup and substitutes.

USWNT starting XI: Naeher, Cook, Williams, Rodman, Horan, Morgan, Sonnett, Girma, Sullivan, Dunn, Fox

Substitutes: Huerta, Sauerbrunn, Hatch, Thompson, Smith, Vignola, Purce, Krueger, Kingsbury, DeMelo, Shaw, Coffey

Did not dress: Mia Fishel, Olivia Moultrie, Casey Murphy, Ashley Sanchez

 
Pinned
Link copied

Head-to-head series

The U.S. has a winning record against Las Cafeteras in their previous ten meetings as the two sides prep for a pair of friendlies during the October international window. The USWNT has nine wins and one draw against Las Cafeteras. The most recent win against Colombia came in 2022, just ahead of the World Cup qualifying Concacaf W Championship. 

 
Pinned
Link copied

Viewing information

Here's all the info you need for the upcoming game! 

  • Date: Thursday, Oct. 26
  • Time: 9 p.m. ET
  • Place: American First Field -- Sandy, Utah
  • TV: TBS 
  • Odds: USWNT -1000; Draw +625; Colombia +1700
 
Pinned
Link copied

Welcome to USA vs Colombia

Hello and welcome to our Live Blog of UWSNT vs Colombia! I'm Sandra Herrera and I'll be providing pregame coverage of tonight's game. Make sure to follow along with Pardeep Cattry for more in-game analysis and live updates.