Patriots ran Seahawks' pass play in practice and Malcolm Butler got beat
Malcolm Butler knew Russell Wilson was going to throw on that 2nd-down play from the 1-yard line -- and he certainly made the most of his opportunity.
This won't make the Seahawks or their fans feel any better: In the days leading up the Super Bowl -- and The Interception -- the Patriots' scout team ran the same pass play we saw from Seattle's offense late in the fourth quarter that made cornerback Malcolm Butler the unlikeliest of heroes.
And Butler was beaten.
“I was at practice, and the scout team ran the same exact play,” Butler told Dan Patrick on Wednesday, via PFT.com. “And I got beat on it at practice because I gave ground. ... Bill Belichick, he came and said to me, ‘Malcolm, you’ve gotta be on that.’”

Butler clearly took those words to heart; he broke on the ball like a grizzled Pro Bowler and made the impossible play look relatively easy.
Here was our view of The Interception from the press box (click on any image to enlarge):
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
"I knew they were going to throw it," Butler said shortly after the game. "Our defensive coordinator is real smart and with a goal line, three-cornerback formation we knew they were going to throw the ball."
Super Bowl MVP Tom Brady added: "It's an incredible play, and not only that, that's the type of plays Malcolm makes for our team. A guy like Malcolm who makes that type of quick, instinctive plays, that's one of his strong suits. I don't think it surprised any of us players because that's what his skill set is."
For what it's worth -- and we imagine not much -- Bill Belichick said Tuesday that Pete Carroll didn't deserve criticism for the decision to let Russell Wilson throw in that situation instead of giving the ball to Marshawn Lynch.
We talked about those final, fateful moments in the latest Eye on Football Podcast, embedded below (you can subscribe to the podcast via iTunes right here).
Pick Six Newsletter
Get the day's big stories + fun stuff you love like mock drafts, picks and power rankings.
Thanks for signing up!
Keep an eye on your inbox for the latest sports news.
Sorry!
There was an error processing your subscription.
-
Sanders won't redo deal with Broncos
Sanders could be cut by the Broncos in salary-cap saving move
-
C.J. Anderson addresses Gurley's injury
Gurley barely saw the field in the playoffs, but the Rams have insisted that he was completely...
-
Allen asks Ramsey if he's still 'trash'
Allen helped the Bills beat the Jaguars last season, but Ramsey hasn't changed his mind about...
-
Gronk could make decision in 2-3 weeks
The Patriots' tight end has yet to decide if he'll return for his 10th NFL season
-
Pick Six: Franchise tags, AAF takeaways
Ben Kercheval joins Will Brinson to break down the latest news and notes
-
Kyler Murray may not throw at combine
Murray has the tools of a first-round quarterback, but he may have more to prove