darren-waller-1400.jpg

How should you approach a position where every team needs to have one starting, but there might only be enough players worth starting for half the league. That's the position we find ourselves in every year with tight end, it seems. 

Oh sure, there will come a point in every draft season where someone will write a, "Maybe this is the year tight end won't be terrible!" piece. That might even become the consensus or something close to it, but it's always wishful thinking. Over the last five seasons, only 14 tight ends have reached 700 receiving yards in a season; 48 wide receivers did in 2020 alone. 

We've got plenty of time to talk ourselves into this year's tight end class before the season starts, but I make this promise right here: You won't hear it from me in this spot. I've got updated post-NFL draft tight ends rankings from Jamey Eisenberg, Dave Richard, Heath Cummings and myself, and while we've got 38 tight ends ranked total, I really only have interest in drafting eight of them. If I don't get one of those eight? It's stream city, baby. 

You can see our consensus TE rankings along with some of my thoughts below, and if you want to see the rest of our post-draft rankings, I covered quarterbacks, running backs and wide receivers last week. But before I get to tight end, I've got some thoughts about the rookie class from this year's draft now that the dust has settled and drafts are starting. 

If you have any questions or comments about rookie drafts, tight ends, or anything else, send them to Chris.Towers@CBSInteractive.com and I'll feature them in a future newsletter. And now, here's what the rookie class looks like to me two weeks out from the draft:

Some rookie draft thoughts ... 

South Carolina v Florida
Getty Images

I had my first rookie draft start this weekend, so I figured this was a good opportunity to talk a little more about strategies and my general thoughts on this class. Obviously, there isn't just one kind of rookie draft out there. For example, I'm in two leagues that are more traditional keeper leagues that also include a rookie draft, which creates a shorter-term window for shopping, making immediate impact even more important. I'm in a few other leagues that are just rookie-only drafts within a Dynasty league, and another that is also a Dynasty league but features IDP and non-rookie free agents. There will be plenty of similarities between all of those drafts, but certainly some key differences as well. 

I'm aiming for just some general strategy for how I'm approaching my rookie drafts and how I think things look now that the dust has settled and drafts are starting. And, while I'll have my rookie rankings down at the bottom for the 2021 season, if you want more of a Dynasty perspective from someone who spends more of their time thinking about this stuff, Heath Cummings' Dynasty Rookie Rankings are right here. Plus, you can find his updated overall Dynasty rankings below:

My first rookie draft was for a SuperFlex league, which adds an additional wrinkle to the proceedings, and though we're not done with all five rounds yet, here's what the first two rounds looked like:

1.1 - Trevor Lawrence, QB, JAC
1.2 - Justin Fields, QB, CHI
1.3 - Trey Lance, QB, SF
1.4 -  Ja'Marr Chase, WR, CIN (Me)
1.5 - Zach Wilson, QB, NYJ
1.6 - Najee Harris, RB, PIT
1.7 - Kyle Pitts, TE, ATL
1.8 - Travis Etienne, RB, JAC
1.9 - Javonte Williams, RB, DEN
1.10 - Devonta Smith, WR, PHI
1.11 - Mac Jones, QB, NE
1.12 - Jaylen Waddle, WR, MIA

2.1 - Rashod Bateman, WR, BAL
2.2 - Elijah Moore, WR, NYJ
2.3 - Rondale Moore, WR, ARI
2.4 - Trey Sermon, RB, SF (Me)
2.5 - Michael Carter, RB, NYJ
2.6 - Terrace Marshall, WR, CAR
2.7 - Kadarius Toney, WR, NYG
2.8 - Amon-Ra St. Brown, WR, DET
2.9 - Pat Freiermuth, TE, PIT
2.10 - Kenneth Gainwell, RB, PHI
2.11 - D'Wayne Eskridge, WR, SEA
2.12 - Dyami Brown, WR, WAS

One thing stands out to me immediately, and I wonder if you can see it and agree: I'm not sure this rookie class is going to be great for Fantasy in 2021. The first picks of the second round are a wide receiver who will be playing in a low volume Baltimore passing game that hasn't produced much WR value to date and a another who will be playing with an unproven rookie QB and a first-time head coach. Both Bateman and Elijah Moore could end up the No. 1 WR on their team, but neither is guaranteed. And even if they did, I'm not sure they'd be must start options in those situations. 

And that's in a SuperFlex league, where five QBs went in the first round. In a standard league, Bateman and Moore might be top-eight picks, ahead of all of the QBs except for Lawrence. That doesn't leave me feeling great about my picks in the second half of the first round -- again, for 2021, at least. Among this rookie class, I think the only players I would draft expecting to be a Fantasy starter early in 2021 are Lawrence, Fields, Chase, Harris, Pitts, Etienne, and maybe Smith. 

I'm not saying you should only draft the rookies in that order, and I think Waddle and Williams especially have the potential to emerge as starting Fantasy options before long. But I am saying this could be a pretty quiet rookie class, especially early on -- though, it goes without saying there will be multiple rookies who surprise us and become starters, because it happens every year.

I do love who I ended up with in that second round, because I think he could be that kind of player. Sermon finds himself in a crowded backfield to start the season, behind Raheem Mostert and Jeff Wilson, and as a late third-round pick, it's not like Sermon has the draft capital to guarantee an early opportunity. However, San Francisco's offense generates a ton of value for running backs and both Wilson and Mostert have had trouble staying healthy. This offense has made less talented backs than Sermon look great, but you'll probably have to be pretty patient for him to get his chance. 

Of course, these short-term concerns do matter less in a true Dynasty league, so you don't want to be too short-sighted. Situations tend to change very quickly in the NFL -- just think back to a year ago, when many thought Stefon Diggs' move to Buffalo was a killer for his Fantasy appeal or when we thought Ke'Shawn Vaughn might be in for a significant and valuable role as Tom Brady's pass-catching RB. Drafting for talent and value rather than fit makes more sense there.

But, I think some players may still eschew the short-term view a bit too much in Dynasty leagues. Precisely because so much can change so fast in the NFL, your realistic window when evaluating most players should be around three years -- though longer for a QB. Immediate impact should arguably be your primary goal, and if you could get an established player for the near term for one of those late-firsts this year, I would do it. I'm thinking someone like Deebo Samuel or Curtis Samuel -- young players who have established a high baseline skill level even if they aren't the shiny new thing-- or a sure-fire 2021 starter with a cloudy future like Chris Carson or Julio Jones would be worth pursuing. 

Rookie picks can depreciate in value like a new car the second they step on the field and go from hypothetical superstars to actual, concrete players. 

Want some proof? Here were the top 12 picks in 2018 rookie drafts, per FantasyData.com: Saquon Barkley, Royce Freeman, Kerryon Johnson, Rashaad Penny, Sony Michel, Ronald Jones, Calvin Ridley, Nick Chubb, Courtland Sutton, Baker Mayfield, Anthony Miller, D.J. Moore. You could argue the success of the second half of that group is an argument for holding on to those late firsts -- and that's a reasonable counter! But I would argue the group on a whole is a good reminder of how quickly value can evaporate. 

Of course, you need to do your own research, figure out which players you like, and figure out who in your league might be looking to deal. Heath's Dynasty Central will be a key resource, but you can also email us at FantasyFootball@CBSi.com to get some help -- Heath will be doing regular mailbags with a Dynasty focus all offseason. 

Here are my rankings for this rookie class focusing on 2021:

  1. Najee Harris
  2. Ja'Marr Chase
  3. Kyle Pitts
  4. Travis Etienne
  5. Javonte Williams
  6. DeVonta Smith
  7. Trevor Lawrence
  8. Jaylen Waddle
  9. Rondale Moore
  10. Michael Carter
  11. Justin Fields
  12. Elijah Moore
  13. Rashod Bateman
  14. Trey Sermon
  15. Terrace Marshall
  16. Dez Fitzpatrick
  17. Kadarius Toney
  18. Zach Wilson
  19. Nico Collins
  20. Trey Lance
  21. D'Wayne Eskridge
  22. Kenneth Gainwell
  23. Chuba Hubbard
  24. Amon-Ra St. Brown
  25. Amari Rodgers
  26. Pat Freiermuth
  27. Tutu Atwell
  28. Brevin Jordan
  29. Josh Palmer
  30. Mac Jones

Updated TE Rankings

In all honesty, I could probably just break down the top 12 at this position and that would be enough -- and even that might overstate how many viable tight ends there actually are. There's a lot of disagreement among our staff after you get to around No. 9 at tight end, because ... well, there just aren't many tight ends worth agreeing on after that. 

Your best bet at this position? Grab one early or wait. Either get the edge here or get the edge everywhere else, because the middle class tends to get pushed up boards and historically end up pretty poor investments.

TE Rankings, 1-12

screenshot-2021-05-04-231027.png
  • One problem with ordinal rankings -- 1, 2, 3, 4, etc. -- is that it doesn't quite capture how much distance might be between two points. In my projections, there's a 22-PPR point gap between No. 1 and No. 2 and then a 4.5 gap between 2 and 3; No. 4 is a full 64.1 points behind No. 3. No. 17 (Rob Gronkowski) is closer to No. 4 than No. 4 (Mark Andrews) is to No. 3. 
  • Travis Kelce stands above the pack even among the elite options, having averaged 102 catches, 1,327 yards and nine touchdowns over the last three seasons while missing just one game -- a game where the Chiefs rested their starters. The last time he wasn't the No. 1 tight end at the end of a season was 2015. He'll turn 32 in October, so the bottom could fall out at any point, but seeing as 2020 was his best season -- career-highs across the board in those 15 games -- it's not time to fade him. 
  • Take your pick between Darren Waller and George Kittle at No. 2. I tend to think Kittle is the better player, but he's only averaged 0.5 points per game more than Waller over the past two seasons while missing 10 games -- Waller hasn't missed one. It comes down to how risk averse you are, ultimately. Normally, I would say just pick the last of the tier, but that's harder to do with a tier of two. If you want to build your strategy around having one of the big three tight ends, you probably can't afford to let someone else take the second one in a snake draft, because then you're just one pick away from missing out entirely.  
  • Of course, there's always the chance one (or more) of that top three disappoints or one of the remaining tight ends joins them. Mark Andrews is the consensus No. 4, and I think there's a chance he makes that leap, because doesn't turn 26 until September and has already displayed the skills to do it. The problem is the offense he plays in. Andrews ranked second among all tight ends in 2020 in target share at 25% and third in air yards at 912, so he clearly has a comparable role to Kelce, Waller, and Kittle. However, the Ravens threw the ball just 406 times in 2020, 145 times fewer than the Raiders, 164 fewer times than the 49ers, and a whopping 224 times fewer than the Chiefs. Those gaps should shrink in 2021, but Andrews' target share may as well with the additions of Sammy Watkins and Rashod Bateman. I have Andrews No. 4, but I don't think he necessarily has the best chance of joining that elite tier.
  • That would probably be Kyle Pitts. It would require an unprecedented feat for a rookie tight end, as none have ever scored more than 200.9 PPR points in a season (Keith Jackson in 1988), but Pitts may just be an unprecedented talent at the position. I think his chances of actually turning it into a big four as a rookie are pretty slim -- the other two tight ends drafted in the top 10 in the last decade combined for 136.5 PPR points in their rookie seasons -- but he's got the talent and the opportunity as Atlanta's likely No. 3 target to become a true difference maker. If I'm aiming for upside outside of the top three, he's the pick.
  • T.J. Hockenson is another popular breakout candidate, and while you can see I'm a bit lower on him than everyone else, I do think he represents the end of a tier at No. 6. Hockenson took a step forward in his second season, improving on his rookie season in every respect except for yards per reception. I don't imagine that'll improve much with Jared Goff replacing Matthew Stafford, but I do think he'll see an increase from 101 targets, and it's possible he takes a big step forward in his age-24 season -- that's when we saw Andrews' breakout. I'm just skeptical that the increase in targets is going to be enough to get him to that next level in an offense that could be quite bad, overall.
  • There are other tight ends worth getting excited about here, but I would argue that list ends at No. 10 overall, Logan Thomas -- and even he might not be that exciting given Washington's additions to the passing game, who could take targets from him. Dallas Goedert is in a bit of a holding pattern for me until Zach Ertz's status is resolved, but I would probably rank him fourth or fifth if Ertz were traded. And Noah Fant is one of my favorite talents at the position -- I think he's a better receiver Hockenson, for one -- but he plays in a crowded offense with a big question mark at QB. 

TE Rankings, 13-24

screenshot-2021-05-09-211013.png
  • You started to see some pretty significant disagreements toward the end of the top 12, and that's natural when the position starts to thin out. At a certain point, it just becomes about personal preference over which long-shot tight end you think will hit. That point was between No. 9, Irv Smith, and No. 10, Thomas. Smith was the last player ranked in the top 12 for all of us. Everyone after that should be considered a pretty fringe starter.
  • I didn't mention Jonnu Smith in the first group because I figured I would wait until I could include Hunter Henry, too. The new Patriots teammates headlined the rebuilding of the receiving corps, and Jamey, Heath and myself all have them ranked right next to each other. That reflects how little clarity there is about their roles in this new-look Pats offense. I am the only one of the group with Henry ranked higher than Smith, and that's because Henry has been able to earn bigger target shares than Smith throughout their careers, and I would guess that continues to be the case. However, I would prefer not to have either as my starter and I won't be reaching for them in drafts. And I'm saying that about my No. 10 and 11 options at the position, to continue driving that point home.
  • It will be interesting to see where Ertz lands, if he does get traded. He looked pretty washed up in 2020 but still earned a higher target share than Goedert despite his injuries. There might be more left in the tank than he gets credit for and if he lands in a good spot, he could get back into the top 12.
  • My ranking of Gerald Everett sticks out like a sore thumb, and I'm not entirely sure I can explain it all that well except to say that it highlights how little I expect from this range of tight ends. Everett got a decent deal at $6 million and has experience with the Seahawks coaching staff, so if I'm waiting until the end of the draft to fill the tight end spot, I'll take my chances on the guy getting the Jared Goff-to-Russell Wilson QB upgrade. 

The rest of the consensus rankings

25. Adam Trautman
26. Anthony Firkser
27. O.J. Howard
28. Dawson Knox
29. Chris Herndon
30. Hayden Hurst
31. Will Dissly
32. Jack Doyle
33. Dan Arnold
34. Josh Oliver
35. C.J. Uzomah
36. Noah Gray
37. Jordan Akins
38. Pat Freiermuth