The Tony Cingrani dilemma

Tony Cingrani has been a real head-scratcher for Fantasy owners this season. (USATSI)
Tony Cingrani has been a real head-scratcher for Fantasy owners this season. (USATSI)

When the Braves moved Alex Wood to the bullpen in early May, the prevailing thought was he would return to starting sooner than later. And even now, I advise stashing him in standard 12-team leagues.

So with word that Tony Cingrani may also be destined for the bullpen whenever Mat Latos comes off the DL, presumably later this week, is stashing him as much of a priority in Fantasy?

It's a situation made all the more complicated by the fact Cingrani hasn't lived up to his end of the bargain so far. As a rookie last year, he was next to unhittable, allowing fewer hits per nine innings (6.2) and recording more strikeouts per nine innings (10.3) than both Max Scherzer and Clayton Kershaw, the two reigning Cy Young winners. And while he hasn't gotten lambasted, he also hasn't thrown strikes consistently, resulting in higher pitch counts, earlier hooks and, consequently, a 2-6 record.

Wood, meanwhile, did everything in his power to convince the Braves he belongs in the rotation long-term. In his first five starts especially, he dominated, going seven innings or more in four of them while compiling a 1.54 ERA. The Braves didn't remove him because of ineffectiveness. They came into a surplus and saw it as an opportunity to save up his innings for future use while also fortifying their bullpen in the short-term. 

When the time comes to replace Aaron Harang or Gavin Floyd, the Braves know they can count on Wood. When the time comes to replace Alfredo Simon or anyone else who happens to go down, the Reds may not be so quick to turn to Cingrani.

After all, he wasn't supposed to be a starter in the first place. His inability to develop a third pitch had most teams projecting him for a bullpen role in the 2011 draft. But then when he dominated in 45 appearances, including 44 starts, in the Reds' minor-league system, compiling a 1.65 ERA, 0.95 WHIP and 11.8 strikeouts per nine innings, and followed it up with last year's performance, he looked like he might be able to survive without a true breaking ball. Only when he began forcing the issue, throwing his "slider" about 15 percent of the time this year, did he lose his effectiveness.

Maybe shifting to the bullpen will get him back to the basics. Maybe he'll ditch the slider and become so dominant the Reds will have no choice but to give him another look. But I'm thinking you'll have plenty of warning before that happens.

With his long-term role very much in question, Cingrani's short-term value is practically nonexistent.

Senior Fantasy Writer

Raised in Atlanta by a board game-loving family during the dawn of the '90s Braves dynasty, Scott White was easy prey for the Fantasy Sports, in particular Fantasy Baseball, and has devoted his adulthood... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
CBS Sports Shop
MLB Opening Day
Our Latest Stories
    Jonah Keri Podcast