powered by Google  
CBSSports.com Power Rankings: Manning, Brady remind us how great they are - NFL Sports News   Track your favorite teams and players.
Free membership, Register Now
Already a member, Log In
 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  Home   Fantasy     NFL  |  MLB  |  NBA  |  NHL  |  College FB  |  College BK  |  Golf  |  More CBS College | MaxPreps | Mobile | Shop  
NFL Home | Scoreboard | Standings | Schedules | Stats | Teams | Players | Transactions | Injuries | Video | Fantasy News | NFL Today | Inside the NFL | NFL Draft | Super Bowl
 

Power Rankings: Manning, Brady remind us how great they are

Updated Nov. 17

It's too bad Bill Belichick made the Fourth-and-Stupid call.

It took away from the main focus of Sunday night's New England Patriots-Indianapolis Colts game, which was seeing Peyton Manning against Tom Brady again.

Seeing those two play quarterback in the same game is like hearing Mozart and Beethoven compose music on opposite ends of a room, soothing your ears with every note.

We had the quarterback version of greatness Sunday night, and somehow it was overshadowed in a big way by Fourth-and-Idiotic.

We say they are 1 and 1A as it relates to ranking passers now. Who's who in that debate remains undecided and might be one we're fighting years from now, when we're having trouble keeping the dentures in place.

Where they rank against each other is too tough to decide. This isn't: They are two of the five best quarterbacks ever.

There, I said it.

Go ahead. Make your list. Fire up the debate.

Johnny Unitas. Joe Montana. Dan Marino. John Elway. Otto Graham. On and on it goes, but you would be hard-pressed to keep either Manning or Brady off of my top-five list.

When those two take the field, most of the time it's a quarterback clinic. They read coverage as well as any passers who've played the game. Their accuracy is deadly. Their toughness is that of a linebacker. They slide in the pocket at the feel of pressure like Marino did in his prime. It's composure.

Marino had Elway as a rival, but they met only three times in their careers (Marino had a 2-1 edge, with Elway winning their only postseason meeting). Manning and Brady have faced each other 11 times now and Brady is 7-4 after Sunday's 35-34 loss. Manning has won five of the past six against the Patriots, although Brady missed the 2008 game with a knee injury. Brady is 2-1 in the playoffs against Manning.

Brady also has three rings. Manning has one. That's where Brady gets the big edge.

Elway had two rings and Marino had none, but I still think Marino was better. Hey, Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson have rings, for whatever that's worth, and they wouldn't be allowed to play a pickup game with Marino based on their passing ability.

Both Brady and Manning had huge games Sunday night. Brady threw for 375 yards and three touchdowns. Manning had 327 yards and four touchdowns, including the game-winner with 16 seconds left.

These two quarterbacks are why their teams are expected to meet again down the road in the playoffs. It's also why the Colts are ranked first in the CBSSports.com Power Rankings and the Patriots are still ranked in the top five.

We are getting a real treat watching these two playing in the same era. It's Bird vs. Magic, football style.

The Power Rankings after Week 10:

Power Rankings
CurrentTeamPrevious
Colts1Colts · Trends1
They should send Belichick a Christmas card. What a gift. They face a tough road game this week at Baltimore.
Saints2Saints · Trends2
They probably learned a valuable lesson against the Rams: Anybody can challenge you on any Sunday. They need to be careful when playing lesser teams.
Vikings3Vikings · Trends3
Get ready for the playoffs. The NFC North belongs to the Vikings. It's obvious nobody else in that division is in their class.
Bengals4Bengals · Trends5
You believe? You have to now. They've beaten both Baltimore and Pittsburgh twice. That's a statement right there.
Patriots5Patriots · Trends4
They are still in control of the AFC East, but don't lose this week against the Jets. Then it's another story.
Steelers6Steelers · Trends6
The champs have a wild-card look about them after being swept by the Bengals. That's OK. They won a Super Bowl a few years back taking that route.
Cowboys7Cowboys · Trends7
Just when they start feeling good about the way they're playing, they go and lay an egg in Green Bay. Who was that in Tony Romo's jersey?
Broncos8Broncos · Trends8
It's amazing how quickly their season has turned around. Now they play the Chargers with a gimpy Kyle Orton and first place on the line.
Chargers9Chargers · Trends12
They have a chance to take over first place in the AFC West this week if they can win at Denver. That's hard to believe after their start.
Cardinals10Cardinals · Trends10
The division title is theirs unless they have a disaster. Now they have to work on playing better at home because they will have a home playoff game.
Eagles11Eagles · Trends9
They might want to stay away from the West Coast. That is two bad games out there after losing to the Chargers on Sunday. Was that their defense we saw against San Diego?
Giants12Giants · Trends13
They come off the bye with a huge game against Atlanta, trying to end a four-game losing streak. Did they dispose of the bad karma during the break? If not, they'll be watching come playoff time.
Texans13Texans · Trends14
They come off their bye with a chance to earn their first playoff berth with a good second half. The key will be how well they play on defense.
Falcons14Falcons · Trends11
With Michael Turner down with an ankle sprain, it's time Matt Ryan truly takes over the offense. He has been struggling, and that has to stop.
Ravens15Ravens · Trends15
They have a huge game with Indianapolis this week. I can tell the Ravens defense this: The Colts offense doesn't look anything like the Browns' unit.
Jaguars16Jaguars · Trends17
Don't look now, but they really are in the playoff hunt. The schedule is really soft, which will help their chances.
Packers17Packers · Trends18
They will look back on that loss to Tampa Bay in Week 9 the rest of the season. How did it happen? They still have major issues on their offensive line.
Jets18Jets · Trends16
If they don't win this week at New England, which won't be easy, they can kiss the playoffs goodbye. Were they overrated at 3-0? Yes.
Panthers19Panthers · Trends21
They have life. They've done a nice job of turning things around. Now they have to do it without Jordan Gross, which won't be easy.
Bears20Bears · Trends19
You have to start to wonder about Jay Cutler. He's trying to do too much. Where's Matt Forte? They are a playoff long shot now.
Dolphins21Dolphins · Trends20
Chad Henne time is here. His game-winning drive was impressive. Now they have a quick turnaround against Carolina.
Titans22Titans · Trends24
Don't look now, but Vince Young is 3-0. Can they make a run? Is it possible?
49ers2349ers · Trends25
Moral of their season: If you can't throw it consistently, you can't win. Alex Smith had a regress game against the Bears.
Seahawks24Seahawks · Trends22
Their disappointing season gets worse every week. They will not be a playoff team with the injuries they've had. Bad first year for Jim Mora Jr.
Bills25Bills · Trends23
Dick Jauron is gone. The Bills aren't playing very well and now must go to Jacksonville.
Chiefs26Chiefs · Trends27
OK, so it came against the Raiders. But winning on the road is big for this young team. Jamaal Charles might be the real deal at running back.
Redskins27Redskins · Trends28
They have life. The Redskins won a game, but does that matter for coach Jim Zorn? Not really.
Raiders28Raiders · Trends26
Tom Cable should be looking for a realtor. There is no way he comes back next season. When does somebody fire Al Davis?
Rams29Rams · Trends29
Steve Spagnuolo has to feel good about his team's effort. They are getting better. Just ask the Saints.
Buccaneers30Buccaneers · Trends30
They have to be thrilled with the way they are playing with Josh Freeman at quarterback. That bodes well for the future. Now it's time to fix the defense.
Lions31Lions · Trends31
They picked Matthew Stafford last spring to help fix the offense. Now they are another team that needs to fix its defense next spring. Good news: The Browns are coming to Detroit.
Browns32Browns · Trends32
That offense is as bad as I've seen. I mean ever. They can't even attempt passes down the field. What an eyesore.
 
For more from Pete Prisco, check him out on Twitter: @PriscoCBS
 

Talk Back
Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Dec 6, 2007

November 19, 2009 1:36 am

1. Saints - Week in week out, they keep winning. The Rams gave them a scare last week and the declining scoring trend continue ...(more)

Reputation:65
Level:Pro
Since:Aug 29, 2006

November 19, 2009 12:53 pm

The Colts travel to Baltimore this weekend for a huge AFC matchup, however, much of the attention will be focused on the Colts returning to Baltimore rather than the game itself. Everytime ...(more)

Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Mar 3, 2007

November 17, 2009 11:01 pm
First, the Broncos...although I love 'em, are not a top ten team right now. They need to man up and win at Washington, who is a bad team. Belichick should be slapping himself all over the face ...(more)
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Oct 27, 2006

November 18, 2009 5:44 pm
Anyone notice how quiet Prisco has been about Favre the past two weeks?  Either he's tired of all the feedback (well deserved) by us on thes message boards...or he can't find anything negative to say about Favre without obviously looking like a ...(more)
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Jun 4, 2008

November 18, 2009 10:46 am
How come no one seems to have Bart Starr on their top lists? He might not have put up as big as numbers as Jihnny U. or Fran Tarkenton but for his era he was a very accurate passer and led the Green Bay ...(more)
 
 
 
 
Headlines
 
 
 
CBS Sports Store
Reebok Minnesota Vikings Brett Favre Youth Replica Team Color Jersey
Get your Favorite Player Jersey
for the rest of the season Shop Now
 
 
 
 
 
Check Your Credit Score Today - $0