MLB Stock Watch: No appeal needed, Ortiz leads the Bulls
David Ortiz gains an extra hit by appeal, but it's his four HRs that make him the clear choice to lead the Bulls. Elsewhere, the game's best pitcher is a rare Bear.
The great David Ortiz had such a strong week that he even gained a hit for the previous week.
So, counting the extra single he picked up in protest, his 10-for-23 week was really tantamount to an 11-for-23 week. Which, with his continuing consistent power, qualifies him to lead the Stock Watch yet again.
No appeal is needed here. Ortiz's four homers were an MLB best for the week.
Ortiz, who seems to defy logic at age 38, apparently also has sway over the league, which awarded him a hit after he appealed on his pop fly he hit that could have broken up Yu Darvish 's no-hit bid but was originally ruled an error in the Texas Rangers ' 8-0 victory back on May 9.
Ortiz broke up the bid for sure anyway with a hit in the ninth inning, but while his appeal had no effect on the no-hit history it seemed from here wholly unnecessary to challenge the initial ruling. Ortiz is one of the best clutch hitters -- and one of the best hitters period -- of this generation, whether he gets credited with a hit for that pop fly or not.
It's true that very ball is called a hit the vast majority of the time (say 98 percent) but it really shouldn't be. It was a pop fly that could have easily been caught by right fielder Alex Rios (who was originally charged with the error) or rookie second baseman Rougned Odor -- though to be fair, it's true the drastic shifts can make things a bit more confusing considering Odor started out in right field on the play, too.
While most scorers call a pop fly that falls between two confused would-be fielders a hit, there was said to be a movement from league higher-ups going into this season to understand that it doesn't necessarily have to be a hit. That would-be change makes great sense, in that the pitcher doesn't deserve a hit on his ledger for such a popup, the hitter doesn't deserve a hit, and at least one of the fielders deserves an error, if not both of them.
Anyway, it was a great week either way for Ortiz, whose winning personality doesn't hurt when appealing to sportswriters, the league, whomever. Anyway, his hitting skills remain overwhelming either way.
Here are all the members of the Bull and Bear markets for this week's Stock Watch.
1. David Ortiz, DH, Boston Red Sox : Not only did he add that cheap single, for the week his four home runs gave him a neat .500 on-base percentage, 1.000 slugging percentage and 1.500 OPS. Not sure when he's going to slow down, but no sign it's anytime soon for the 38-year-old. Ortiz's batting average went from .267 to .299 for the year (thanks to the extra hit), and his OPS is now .939, fourth best in the American League and the very same figure Ortiz had last season.
Detroit Tigers manager Brad Ausmus knows the score, intentionally walking Big Papi as the potential tying runner (with only one out, no less) Sunday night. Ausmus perhaps went to school during the ALCS when the legendary Jim Leyland, Ausmus' predecessor, made the mistake of letting Ortiz hit the grand slam that turned the series. Maybe Leyland temporarily forgot that things always seem to work out for Ortiz.
2. Johnny Cueto , SP, Cincinnati Reds : If it seems like opposing batters are hitting nothing against him, that's close to the truth. In 72 innings, he has allowed 33 hits, which adds up to an MLB-best .135 opponents' batting average. He used to be a hard thrower with a nice slider, but now he's a terrific pitcher -- one of the best and most underrated in baseball. For the month, he has a 0.60 WHIP after his 5-0 complete-game shutout of the San Diego Padres , and for the year he leads all pitchers in ERA (1.25), WAR (3.5) and everything else that's important.
Of course the Reds pick up the $10 million option for 2015 (as opposed to buying him out for $800,000), but after that it gets interesting. They spent $105 million on the less-accomplished (but slightly younger) Homer Bailey , which may leave little room in the budget of the small-market team for the fellow who's pitching better than anyone in the game. Little chance a chant of "Cue-to" could derail him now.
3. Yasiel Puig , OF, Los Angeles Dodgers : His new discipline at the plate makes him even tougher. For the week, he had three more home runs and a 1.334 OPS. He also isn't making the previous mistakes on the base paths. For all the ridicule he has taken, he seems like he might be a very fast learner.
Honorable Mention: Rickie Weeks , 2B, Milwaukee Brewers ; Miguel Cabrera , 1B, Tigers; Victor Martinez , DH, Tigers; Jose Altuve , 2B, Houston Astros ; Brandon Moss , 1B, A's; Pablo Sandoval , 3B, San Francisco Giants ; Yadier Molina , C, St. Louis Cardinals ; A.J. Pollock , OF, Arizona Diamondbacks ; Daniel Murphy , 2B, New York Mets ; Seth Smith , OF, Padres; Brian Dozier , 2B, Minnesota Twins ; Josh Donaldson , 3B, A's; Freddie Freeman , 1B, Atlanta Braves ; David Murphy , OF, Cleveland Indians ; Brett Gardner , OF, New York Yankees ; Hunter Pence , OF, Giants; Juan Francisco , 3B, Jays; Brandon League , RP, Dodgers; Ubaldo Jimenez , SP, Baltimore Orioles ; Sean Doolittle , RP, A's; Drew Pomeranz , SP, A's; Bronson Arroyo , SP, Diamondbacks; Joe Nathan , RP, Tigers; Jeff Samardzija , SP, Chicago Cubs ; Danny Duffy , SP, Kansas City Royals ; Tyson Ross , SP, Padres; Max Scherzer , SP, Tigers; Phil Hughes , SP, Twins; Tom Koehler , SP, Miami Marlins ; Hisashi Iwakuma , SP, Seattle Mariners ; Jered Weaver , SP, Los Angeles Angels ; Edwin Jackson , SP, Cubs; Jon Lester , SP, Red Sox; Zack Greinke , SP, Dodgers; Masahiro Tanaka , SP, Yankees; Mark Buehrle , SP, jays; Shelby Miller , SP, Cardinals; Corey Kluber , SP, Indians; Garret Richards, SP, Angels; Jorge de la Rosa, SP, Colorado Rockies ; Dallas Keuchel , SP, Astros; Drew Pomeranz, SP, A's; Robbie Erlin , SP, Padres; Rick Porcello , SP, Tigers.
1. Justin Masterson , SP, Indians: For the week, he had an 11.17 ERA. Neither start was great but the last one, Sunday's 13-3 defeat to the A's in which he allowed seven hits, five walks and seven earned runs in 4 1/3 innings, was especially bad (though to be fair, the A's have tormented a lot of pitchers lately). It was written here that it was hard to believe the Indians turned down some seemingly reasonable short-term offers to stay with Masterson, but based on the way he has started, the team doesn't look quite so foolish, at least not at the time. Though for the record, I would still consider this an aberration and try to keep him.
2. Clayton Kershaw , SP, Dodgers: One off game doesn't normally qualify one for the Bear Market. But when the best pitcher in the game allows three run-scoring triples in the same inning to anyone, much less the last-place Diamondbacks, he makes it based on the grading curve. Kershaw lasted just 1 2/3 innings in the 18-7 Dodgers defeat; his second game back turned out to be the second-shortest outing of his career.
3. Ruben Tejada , SS, Mets: The callup of Wilmer Flores seemed to spur Tejada to better play for a couple days, but it's still a 3-for-21 (.143) week and 5-for-40 (.125) month. For the year, he has a .185 batting average and .524 OPS.
Dishonorable Mention: Kyle Seager , 3B, Mariners; Mark Reynolds , 3B, Brewers; Evan Longoria , 3B, Tampa Bay Rays ; Matt Carpenter , 3B, Cardinals; Eric Hosmer , 1B, Royals; A.J. Pierzynski , C, Red Sox; Justin Upton , OF, Braves; Desmond Jennings , OF, Rays; Danny Espinosa , 2B, Washington Nationals ; Jedd Gyorko , 3B, Padres; Jackie Bradley Jr., OF, Red Sox; Brad Miller , SS, Mariners; Mike Moustakas , 3B, Royals; Jake Peavy , SP, Red Sox; Zack Wheeler , SP, Mets; Scott Carroll , SP, Chicago White Sox ; Brian Wilson , RP, Dodgers; Edinson Volquez , SP, Pittsburgh Pirates ; Gio Gionzalez, SP, Nats; Zach McAllister , SP, Indians; Henry Rodriguez, RP, Marlins; Jim Henderson , RP, Brewers; Nick Maronde, RP, Angels.
Our Latest Stories
This is by far the most important thing you'll read about the World Series
Once again, Lindor did it all for the Indians in Game 1
Everyone's getting in on the act
Cleveland may never see another day as glorious as Tuesday
How a pitch that was already nasty back in May became downright illegal in October
The Indians are looking to take a 2-0 series lead Wednesday