Prisco's What Teams 'Should' Do 2018 NFL Mock Draft: Browns take Josh Allen, then trade back

Is the following mock draft proof that I did a really good job this year with my mocks?

I think it is, and the reason I say that is because what follows here is my annual what-they-should-do mock, which means how the mock should go, not how I think it will go. Surprisingly, this what-they-should-do mock is eerily similar to some of my prediction mocks.

Looking for a hot new NFL podcast that's your home for NFL Draft coverage? Look no further. The Pick 6 Podcast with Will Brinson has you covered each day of the draft with new episodes around 30 minutes each. Subscribe: via iTunes | via Stitcher | via TuneIn | via Google Play.

So is what I think is going to happen actually synching up with what should happen? Or did I over-think the entire process?

Like in most of my mocks, I have the Cleveland Browns taking Wyoming quarterback Josh Allen with the first pick in this one. He has the highest ceiling of any of the quarterbacks, which is why the Browns should take him.

I have two mock trades in this one. I have the Buffalo Bills going up to the fourth spot – Cleveland's second first-round pick – to land USC quarterback Sam Darnold. They would give up the 12th pick, the 22nd pick and a second and fourth next year to make the deal.

The other trade is the Arizona Cardinals trading up to the 10th spot to take Oklahoma quarterback Baker Mayfield. They would give Oakland the 15th pick in the first round and a second-round pick next year.

The Cardinals have Sam Bradford, but they need a young quarterback to develop and Mayfield would be that guy.

Just remember, this is a mock of what I think teams should do, not what they will do.

1. Cleveland Browns

Josh Allen, QB, Wyoming. He is the passer with the most upside. I swing for the fences here and take Allen, who I think can be a home run pick.


2. New York Giants

Bradley Chubb, DE, NC State. The Giants won Super Bowls with their pass rush. Chubb is the best pass rusher in this class. Take him. Eli Manning is fine for a few more years.


3. New York Jets (from Colts)

Josh Rosen, QB, UCLA. They made the move up to get a quarterback, so they should take the second-best quarterback on my list. Rosen is NFL ready. 


4. Buffalo Bills (CLE mock trade)

Sam Darnold, QB, USC. They should make this move up to land their quarterback. Give up their two first-round picks and a second and fourth next year to land Darnold.


5. Denver Broncos

Denzel Ward, CB, Ohio State. They pass on Baker Mayfield here to take the draft's best cover corner. They need to replace Aqib Talib.


6. Indianapolis Colts (from Jets)

Roquan Smith, LB, Georgia. They would land the draft's best play-making linebacker in this spot. Smith will be a Ray Lewis-type player. They need a game-changing player on defense. With Chubb gone, they take the three-down linebacker. 


7. Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Derwin James, S, Florida State. They need a playmaker on the back end. James is a big-play safety who can do a lot of things.


8. Chicago Bears

Quenton Nelson, G, Notre Dame. They need a left guard and Nelson is the cleanest player in this draft. His college line coach is also now with the Bears.


9. San Francisco 49ers

Tremaine Edmunds, LB, Virginia Tech. With all the issues they have regarding Rueben Foster, this makes too much sense. At 19, this kid has a ton of upside. 


10. Arizona Cardinals (OAK mock trade)

Baker Mayfield, QB, Oklahoma. The Cardinals make the move up to take Mayfield to get their quarterback of the future. They have to do something after not taking one last year. 


11. Miami Dolphins

Vita Vea, DT, WashingtonThe middle of their line needs upgrading, so take the power player from Washington. He would take over for Ndamukong Suh.


12. Cleveland Browns (BUF mock trade)

Saquon Barkley, RB, Penn State. They move down and land the best back in the draft. Barkley will help the young quarterback when Allen eventually plays.    


13. Washington Redskins

Minkah Fitzpatrick, CB, Alabama. They need to take a game-changer on the back end. Fitzpatrick would give them a Malcolm Jenkins-type player. 


14. Green Bay Packers

Marcus Davenport, DE, UTSAThey should take the chance on a pass rusher with a lot of upside. Davenport has rare skills, but needs seasoning.


15. Oakland Raiders (ARI mock trade)

Leighton Vander Esch, LB, Boise State. They need to get better at linebacker. This kid would give them a player some scouts have compared to Luke Kuechly.


16. Baltimore Ravens

James Daniels, C, Iowa. They have to get better inside and the loss of Ryan Jensen to the Bucs leaves big hole. Daniels could also play guard. 


17. Los Angeles Chargers

Da'Ron Payne, DT, Alabama. They were second worst in rushing yards against last season and Corey Ligiut is facing a four-game suspension. Payne would be a nice fill-in and then eventual starter.


18. Seattle Seahawks

Josh Jackson, CB, Iowa. They let Richard Sherman go, so they have a big hole on the corner. Jackson has a lot of the same qualities Sherman has.


19. Dallas Cowboys

D.J. Moore, WR, Maryland. They have to get better outside in the passing game. They just don't have enough speed, and Moore would help fix that.


20. Detroit Lions

Harold Landry, DE, Boston College. They need to get more help for Ziggy Ansah and their pass rush. Landry had a down year in 2017, but he was really impressive in 2016.


21. Cincinnati Bengals (from Bills)

Frank Ragnow, C-G, Arkansas. Center has been a trouble spot for this team for a long time. Ragnow is a tough, physical player who could also play guard.


22. Cleveland Browns (BUF mock trade)

Kolton Miller, T, UCLA. They would land the replacement for Joe Thomas. He needs some seasoning, but the tools are there.  


23. New England Patriots (from Rams)

Mike McGlinchey, T, Notre Dame. He could step in for Nate Solder, who left as a free agent and signed with the Giants. He could be a plug-and-play depending on the health of Antonio Garcia


24. Carolina Panthers

Calvin Ridley, WR, Alabama. They have to get more outside for Cam Newton. Ridley would be a nice complement to what they already have. 


25. Tennessee Titans

Rashaan Evans, ILB, AlabamaThey lost Avery Williamson, their leading tackler last year, in free agency. Landing Evans would give them a nice three-down linebacker.


26. Atlanta Falcons

Taven Bryan, DT, Florida. They have been linked to Bryan for a while, and I think he would be a nice addition next to Grady Jarrett. Bryan will be better in the NFL than he was at Florida.


27. New Orleans Saints

Hayden Hurst, TE, South Carolina. They need to get a threat in the middle of the field. Hurst would be that guy with Coby Fleener not living up to expectations. 


28. Pittsburgh Steelers

Lamar Jackson, QB, Louisville. At some point they have to get a replacement for Ben Roethlisberger, who is always talking about retiring. This might be the time. 


29. Jacksonville Jaguars

Will Hernandez, G, UTEP. They are building a big, tough, physical line. Hernandez would be a nice addition to that group and would push right guard A.J. Cann.


30. Minnesota Vikings

Isaiah Wynn, G, Georgia. He is a mauler who played tackle in college but will likely move inside in the NFL. He could play guard and they could move Mike Remmers back to tackle. 


31. New England Patriots

Jaire Alexander, CB, Louisville. The Pats have a big hole on the corner and Alexander would step in and push for time right away. They could also move out of this spot to get more picks. 


32. Philadelphia Eagles

Dallas Goedert, TE, South Dakota State. They lost Trey Burton in free agency, so they need another tight end to pair with Zach Ertz. Goedert is the best pass-catching tight end in the draft.

CBS Sports Senior Writer

Pete Prisco has covered the NFL for three decades, including working as a beat reporter in Jacksonville for the Jaguars. When he's not watching game tape, you can find Pete on Twitter or dreaming of an... Full Bio

Our Latest Stories