| Blue Jays 1st | |
| Cliff Lee pitching: | |
| Shannon Stewart: | Ball, Strike looking, Ball, Foul, Foul, Stewart grounded out to third. |
| Aaron Hill: | Ball, Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Hill walked. |
| Alex Rios: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Rios grounded into double play shortstop to second to first, Hill out at second. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Indians 1st | |
| Shaun Marcum pitching: | |
| Grady Sizemore: | Ball, Ball, Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Sizemore fouled out to catcher. |
| Asdrubal Cabrera: | Ball, Cabrera flied out to right. |
| Jhonny Peralta: | Peralta flied out to center. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 2nd | |
| Cliff Lee pitching: | |
| Scott Rolen: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Rolen grounded out to second. |
| Kevin Mench: | Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Mench grounded out to shortstop. |
| Marco Scutaro: | Scutaro fouled out to right. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Indians 2nd | |
| Shaun Marcum pitching: | |
| Victor Martinez: | Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Ball, Strike looking, Martinez struck out swinging. |
| Franklin Gutierrez: | Ball, Strike looking, Strike looking, Ball, Foul, Gutierrez doubled to deep left center. |
| Travis Hafner: | Strike looking, Ball, Foul, Ball, Foul, Ball, Hafner reached on catcher's interference. |
| Kelly Shoppach: | Shoppach flied out to left. |
| Jason Tyner: | Ball, Strike looking, Foul, Foul, Foul, Foul, Ball, Gutierrez to third on passed ball, Ball, Tyner hit by pitch, Hafner to second. |
| Andy Marte: | Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Marte flied out to center. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 3rd | |
| Cliff Lee pitching: | |
| Lyle Overbay: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Ball, Overbay lined out to shortstop. |
| Gregg Zaun: | Ball, Foul, Ball, Zaun reached on an infield single. |
| Jorge Velandia: | Ball, Strike looking, Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Foul, Velandia struck out swinging. |
| Shannon Stewart: | Stewart grounded into double play second, Zaun out at second. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Indians 3rd | |
| Shaun Marcum pitching: | |
| Grady Sizemore: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Sizemore struck out swinging. |
| Asdrubal Cabrera: | Cabrera popped out to first. |
| Jhonny Peralta: | Peralta flied out to center. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 4th | |
| Cliff Lee pitching: | |
| Aaron Hill: | Foul, Ball, Hill reached on an infield single. |
| Alex Rios: | Rios grounded into double play shortstop to second to first, Hill out at second. |
| Scott Rolen: | Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Foul, Rolen struck out looking. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Indians 4th | |
| Shaun Marcum pitching: | |
| Victor Martinez: | Strike looking, Foul, Foul, Martinez doubled to right. |
| Franklin Gutierrez: | Strike swinging, Gutierrez grounded out to shortstop. |
| Travis Hafner: | Ball, Strike looking, Foul, Foul, Ball, Foul, Ball, Hafner grounded out to first, Martinez to third. |
| Kelly Shoppach: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Shoppach struck out swinging. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 5th | |
| Cliff Lee pitching: | |
| Kevin Mench: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Mench singled to left. |
| Marco Scutaro: | Ball, Scutaro singled to center, Mench to second. |
| Lyle Overbay: | Ball, Overbay lined into triple play second, Mench out at second, Scutaro out at second. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 2 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Indians 5th | |
| Shaun Marcum pitching: | |
| Jason Tyner: | Ball, Ball, Strike looking, Tyner flied out to center. |
| Andy Marte: | Strike swinging, Ball, Foul, Ball, Marte flied out to center. |
| Grady Sizemore: | Ball, Ball, Sizemore flied out to center. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 6th | |
| Cliff Lee pitching: | |
| Gregg Zaun: | Ball, Zaun flied out to right. |
| Jorge Velandia: | Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Velandia grounded out to third. |
| Shannon Stewart: | Strike looking, Ball, Stewart singled to left center. |
| Aaron Hill: | Foul, Ball, Foul, Ball, Hill struck out looking. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Indians 6th | |
| Shaun Marcum pitching: | |
| Asdrubal Cabrera: | Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Ball, Cabrera grounded out to first. |
| Jhonny Peralta: | Ball, Strike looking, Strike looking, Ball, Peralta flied out to center. |
| Victor Martinez: | Strike looking, Strike swinging, Ball, Ball, Martinez grounded out to first. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 1 Error) | |
| Blue Jays 7th | |
| Cliff Lee pitching: | |
| Alex Rios: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Rios grounded out to shortstop. |
| Scott Rolen: | Rolen ground-rule doubled to left. |
| Kevin Mench: | Strike looking, Foul, Mench struck out swinging. |
| Marco Scutaro: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Ball, Foul, Foul, Foul, Ball, Ball, Scutaro struck out swinging. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Indians 7th | |
| Shaun Marcum pitching: | |
| Franklin Gutierrez: | Ball, Gutierrez fouled out to catcher. |
| Travis Hafner: | Foul, Strike looking, Ball, Hafner grounded out to second. |
| Kelly Shoppach: | Strike swinging, Foul, Ball, Ball, Ball, Shoppach struck out looking. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 8th | |
| Cliff Lee pitching: | |
| Lyle Overbay: | Foul, Ball, Overbay flied out to center. |
| Gregg Zaun: | Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Foul, Zaun grounded out to second. |
| Jorge Velandia: | Velandia grounded out to shortstop. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Indians 8th | |
| Shaun Marcum pitching: | |
| Jason Tyner: | Strike looking, Ball, Tyner grounded out to first |
| Casey Blake hit for Andy Marte. | |
| Casey Blake: | Ball, Strike looking, Strike swinging, Blake struck out swinging. |
| Grady Sizemore: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Ball, Sizemore grounded out to second. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 9th | |
| Cliff Lee pitching: | |
| Shannon Stewart: | Strike looking, Ball, Strike swinging, Ball, Foul, Foul, Ball, Stewart walked. |
| Aaron Hill: | Strike looking, Ball, Hill sacrificed to catcher, Stewart to second. |
| Alex Rios: | Foul, Rios lined out to first. |
| Scott Rolen: | Strike looking, Ball, Strike looking, Ball, Rolen reached on an infield single, Stewart to third. |
| Kevin Mench: | Strike looking, Foul, Mench lined out to right. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Indians 9th | |
| B.J. Ryan pitching: | |
| Asdrubal Cabrera: | B.J. Ryan relieved Shaun Marcum, Strike looking, Strike swinging, Ball, Cabrera struck out swinging. |
| Jhonny Peralta: | Peralta popped out to shortstop. |
| Victor Martinez: | Ball, Martinez fouled out to catcher. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 10th | |
| Matt Stairs hit for Marco Scutaro | |
| Rafael Betancourt pitching: | |
| Matt Stairs: | Foul, Ball, Foul, Stairs singled to right. |
| Lyle Overbay: | Strike looking, Ball, Pickoff attempt, Ball, Overbay reached on an infield single, Stairs to second. |
| Gregg Zaun: | Zaun sacrificed to third, Stairs to third, Overbay to second |
| Brad B. Wilkerson hit for Jorge Velandia. | |
| Brad B. Wilkerson: | Ball, Ball, Ball, Wilkerson walked. |
| Shannon Stewart: | Stewart hit sacrifice fly to center, Stairs scored, Overbay to third, Wilkerson to second. |
| Aaron Hill: | Hill singled to center, Overbay and Wilkerson scored. |
| Alex Rios: | Strike looking, Ball, Foul, Rios popped out to second. |
| End of Inning (3 Runs, 3 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Indians 10th | |
| Joe Inglett at shortstop | |
| Scott Downs pitching: | |
| Franklin Gutierrez: | Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Foul, Foul, Gutierrez struck out swinging. |
| Travis Hafner: | Strike looking, Ball, Strike swinging, Ball, Hafner ground-rule doubled to left. |
| Kelly Shoppach: | Strike looking, Shoppach grounded out to second, Hafner to third |
| Ben Francisco hit for Jason Tyner. | |
| Ben Francisco: | Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Foul, Francisco struck out swinging. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |