| Yankees 1st | |
| A.J. Burnett pitching: | |
| Brett Gardner: | Strike looking, Gardner singled to left, Gardner out at second. |
| Robinson Cano: | Strike looking, Foul, Cano grounded out to shortstop. |
| Bobby Abreu: | Ball, Abreu popped out to shortstop. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 1st | |
| Phil Hughes pitching: | |
| Joe Inglett: | Ball, Foul, Inglett doubled to left. |
| Marco Scutaro: | Foul, Foul, Scutaro grounded out to second, Inglett to third. |
| Alex Rios: | Ball, Ball, Rios hit sacrifice fly to left, Inglett scored. |
| Vernon Wells: | Ball, Wells singled to center. |
| Adam Lind: | Strike looking, Foul, Lind popped out to first. |
| End of Inning (1 Run, 2 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Yankees 2nd | |
| A.J. Burnett pitching: | |
| Xavier Nady: | Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Foul, Nady struck out swinging. |
| Jason Giambi: | Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Giambi struck out swinging. |
| Wilson Betemit: | Ball, Strike looking, Betemit reached on an infield single. |
| Cody Ransom: | Foul, Ball, Ball, Foul, Ball, Foul, Ransom walked, Betemit to second. |
| Juan Miranda: | Strike swinging, Ball, Miranda flied out to left. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 2nd | |
| Phil Hughes pitching: | |
| Lyle Overbay: | Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Strike looking, Overbay grounded out to second. |
| Scott Rolen: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Foul, Rolen struck out swinging. |
| Travis Snider: | Ball, Ball, Strike looking, Strike swinging, Snider struck out swinging. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Yankees 3rd | |
| A.J. Burnett pitching: | |
| Chad Moeller: | Strike looking, Moeller singled to right. |
| Brett Gardner: | Strike looking, Gardner reached on fielder's choice to second, Moeller out at second. |
| Robinson Cano: | Ball, Foul, Ball, Cano reached on an infield single, Gardner to second, Gardner to third, Cano to second on Scutaro's throwing error. |
| Bobby Abreu: | Ball, Foul, Strike looking, Ball, Abreu struck out swinging. |
| Xavier Nady: | Ball, Foul, Strike swinging, Foul, Nady singled to center, Gardner and Cano scored. |
| Jason Giambi: | Strike looking, Ball, Foul, Giambi grounded out to right. |
| End of Inning (2 Runs, 3 Hits, 1 Error) | |
| Blue Jays 3rd | |
| Phil Hughes pitching: | |
| Gregg Zaun: | Ball, Foul, Zaun flied out to left. |
| Joe Inglett: | Strike looking, Inglett flied out to center. |
| Marco Scutaro: | Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Scutaro grounded out to pitcher. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Yankees 4th | |
| A.J. Burnett pitching: | |
| Wilson Betemit: | Ball, Betemit doubled to left. |
| Cody Ransom: | Strike looking, Strike swinging, Ball, Ball, Foul, Ransom grounded out to shortstop. |
| Juan Miranda: | Miranda singled to center, Betemit to third. |
| Chad Moeller: | Ball, Foul, Ball, Foul, Moeller struck out swinging. |
| Brett Gardner: | Ball, Strike looking, Ball, Foul, Gardner struck out swinging. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 2 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 4th | |
| Phil Hughes pitching: | |
| Alex Rios: | Strike looking, Ball, Rios doubled to deep left. |
| Vernon Wells: | Ball, Strike looking, Ball, Foul, Wells grounded out to third. |
| Adam Lind: | Strike looking, Ball, Foul, Lind struck out swinging. |
| Lyle Overbay: | Strike looking, Foul, Foul, Overbay lined out to shortstop. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Yankees 5th | |
| A.J. Burnett pitching: | |
| Robinson Cano: | Strike looking, Ball, Cano grounded out to second. |
| Bobby Abreu: | Ball, Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Foul, Abreu struck out looking. |
| Xavier Nady: | Strike looking, Ball, Nady flied out to right. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 5th | |
| Phil Hughes pitching: | |
| Scott Rolen: | Rolen grounded out to second. |
| Travis Snider: | Strike looking, Ball, Snider grounded out to pitcher. |
| Gregg Zaun: | Ball, Zaun singled to center. |
| Joe Inglett: | Ball, Ball, Ball, Strike looking, Strike looking, Inglett lined out to left. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Yankees 6th | |
| A.J. Burnett pitching: | |
| Jason Giambi: | Ball, Ball, Ball, Giambi walked. |
| Wilson Betemit: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Betemit grounded into double play second to shortstop to first, Giambi out at second. |
| Cody Ransom: | Strike looking, Ball, Strike looking, Foul, Foul, Ball, Ball, Ransom struck out looking. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 6th | |
| Phil Hughes pitching: | |
| Marco Scutaro: | Strike looking, Foul, Scutaro flied out to right. |
| Alex Rios: | Ball, Ball, Strike looking, Rios grounded out to second. |
| Vernon Wells: | Wells flied out to center. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Yankees 7th | |
| A.J. Burnett pitching: | |
| Juan Miranda: | Ball, Foul, Strike swinging, Ball, Miranda struck out swinging. |
| Chad Moeller: | Moeller flied out to center. |
| Brett Gardner: | Strike looking, Ball, Strike looking, Ball, Gardner struck out swinging. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 7th | |
| Phil Hughes pitching: | |
| Adam Lind: | Strike looking, Lind flied out to center. |
| Lyle Overbay: | Strike swinging, Foul, Foul, Foul, Ball, Overbay struck out swinging. |
| Scott Rolen: | Foul, Ball, Rolen homered to left. |
| Travis Snider: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Snider struck out looking. |
| End of Inning (1 Run, 1 Hit, 0 Errors) | |
| Yankees 8th | |
| A.J. Burnett pitching: | |
| Robinson Cano: | Strike swinging, Foul, Cano struck out swinging. |
| Bobby Abreu: | Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Abreu struck out swinging. |
| Xavier Nady: | Ball, Ball, Nady flied out to center. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 8th | |
| Phil Hughes pitching: | |
| Gregg Zaun: | Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Foul, Zaun struck out looking. |
| Joe Inglett: | Ball, Inglett grounded out to second. |
| Marco Scutaro: | Scutaro flied out to center. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Yankees 9th | |
| Jesse Carlson pitching: | |
| Jason Giambi: | Strike looking, Strike looking, Giambi hit by pitch. |
| Wilson Betemit: | Johnny Damon ran for Jason Giambi, Strike looking, Strike (missed bunt), Betemit popped out to second. |
| Cody Ransom: | Foul, Damon caught stealing, catcher to shortstop, Ball, Ball, Ball, Foul, Ransom struck out swinging. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 9th | |
| Phil Hughes pitching: | |
| Alex Rios: | Ball, Foul, Rios grounded out to shortstop. |
| Vernon Wells: | Wells flied out to center. |
| Adam Lind: | Strike swinging, Foul, Ball, Foul, Ball, Lind struck out looking. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Yankees 10th | |
| Jesse Carlson pitching: | |
| Juan Miranda: | Ball, Miranda doubled to deep right. |
| Chad Moeller: | Melky Cabrera ran for Juan Miranda, Bunt foul, Ball, Bunt foul, Ball, Ball, Foul, Foul, Moeller walked. |
| Brett Gardner: | Gardner sacrificed to third, Cabrera to third, Moeller to second. |
| Robinson Cano: | Cano hit by pitch. |
| Bobby Abreu: | Ball, Abreu homered to right, Cabrera, Moeller and Cano scored. |
| Xavier Nady: | Nady grounded out to first. |
| Johnny Damon: | Strike looking, Strike swinging, Ball, Foul, Damon singled to right. |
| Wilson Betemit: | Strike swinging, Foul, Betemit flied out to shallow shortstop. |
| End of Inning (4 Runs, 3 Hits, 0 Errors) | |
| Blue Jays 10th | |
| Jose Veras pitching: | |
| Lyle Overbay: | Sidney Ponson relieved Jose Veras, Ball, Strike looking, Foul, Overbay grounded out to first. |
| Scott Rolen: | Ball, Ball, Strike looking, Rolen grounded out to pitcher. |
| Travis Snider: | Strike looking, Foul, Ball, Snider flied out to left. |
| End of Inning (0 Runs, 0 Hits, 0 Errors) | |