NEW YORK -- Bob Wickman was in trouble.
The Cleveland Indians' lead was down to one in the ninth inning, and the New York Yankees had the tying and winning runs on base with nobody out. Scott Elarton's second consecutive win was in jeopardy, but he wasn't all that nervous.
"You kind of get used to it with Wicky," Elarton said after the Indians' 8-7 victory Saturday. "He's done it so many times. He knows how to get out of those situations and it's really not as stressful as it might seem."
Cleveland, which had dropped 10 of 12 to the Yankees and 11 of 12 to them on the road, ended New York's six-game winning streak. The Yankees fell back into third place in the AL East, behind Boston and Baltimore, after passing the Orioles on Friday.
Elarton (6-3) followed his complete-game victory on Monday over Detroit with a seven-inning effort.
"He has been as consistent as any starter we have, if not more so," Indians manager Eric Wedge said. "He's a true example of what we talk about in terms of just giving the team a chance to win the ballgame."
Wickman allowed Ruben Sierra's third homer leading off the ninth, but managed to get his 23rd save in 26 chances.
Hernandez broke out of a slump to provide the offense.
In 37 games since April 21, Hernandez was hitting just .218. He homered twice against Cincinnati on June 24, but entered with only three home runs and 16 RBI on the year.
"I think I always don't have a good start," Hernandez said. "I usually pick it up later on, like June and July."
Elarton gave up back-to-back homers in the first inning to Gary Sheffield and Rodriguez before settling down and winning for the fourth time in five decisions.
"I didn't really feel very good the first inning," Elarton said. "I made two bad pitches to those guys. It's pretty much a guaranteed hard-hit ball if you miss over the plate."
He gave up three runs and six hits in matching his second longest outing of the season. Keeping a low pitch count was the difference.
"He did everything you could ask him to do," Wedge said.
May (0-1) lasted only 4 1/3 innings in his Yankees debut that came a day after he was brought up from Triple-A Columbus and one week following his acquisition from San Diego.
Pitching in place of injured Carl Pavano, May allowed seven runs, eight hits and a season-high three home runs. He was 1-3 with a 5.61 ERA with the Padres working in and out of the bullpen.
"I wasn't able to hit my spots when I wanted," May said. "When I tried to go away, I left the pitches up and that's what hurt me."
After a 1-2-3 first inning, including a three-pitch strikeout of leadoff hitter Grady Sizemore, May fell apart in the second.
Casey Blake led off with an infield single, and Hernandez ripped a 2-1 pitch over the left-field wall to tie it at 2-2. Jhonny Peralta followed with another shot to left, this time after May fell behind 3-1.
May retired the first two hitters in the third, but Blake doubled just over the outstretched glove of center fielder Melky Cabrera, who had a rough day defensively in his third major-league start.
"It's an experience he's going to have to go through," Yankees manager Joe Torre said. "Unfortunately, it was a one-run game so it sticks out like a sore thumb."
Hernandez followed with another drive to left on a 3-1 pitch for his ninth career multihomer game, giving Cleveland a 5-2 lead.
"He did a great job in getting us kick-started," Wedge said of Hernandez.
New York cut the deficit to 7-3 in its half of the fifth as Sierra led off with a double and scored on Cano's two-out single.
Matsui reached base for the 36th consecutive game, tops in the majors this season.
- Hernandez drove in a career-best seven runs on April 12, 2001, with Milwaukee.
- Sheffield tied Cal Ripken Jr. for 33rd place on baseball's list with his 431st homer.
- Yankees 1B Jason Giambi returned to the lineup after leaving Friday's game in the sixth inning because of tightness in his left leg.
- The Indians recalled INF Brandon Phillips from Triple-A Buffalo and optioned LHP Brian Tallet. Phillips started at second base and went 0-for-4. He filled in for Ronnie Belliard, who was bothered by leg cramps.
- The Yankees' old-timers game was cut to 1 1/3 innings by a brief rain shower.