Kansas City at Detroit

Kansas City
W: R. Hernandez (7-9) L: M. Maroth (7-10)
HR: KC - M. Sweeney (13), M. Teahen (3)   DET - None

Royals take down Tigers following bench-clearing brawl

CBS SportsLine.com wire reports

DETROIT -- Runelvys Hernandez said he was not trying to hit anybody. The Detroit Tigers did not believe him.

Hernandez allowed two hits through five innings before he was ejected after triggering a bench-clearing brawl in the sixth, and the Kansas City Royals beat Detroit 5-0 Sunday.

Three relievers finished the six-hitter for the Royals, who had three players and manager Buddy Bell ejected in the melee that started after Hernandez beaned Detroit's Carlos Guillen in the helmet, his third hit batter of the game.

"What he did is not acceptable," Tigers catcher Ivan Rodriguez said. "A pitcher cannot throw at a player's head. It's not a good thing to do."

Mike Sweeney hit a two-run homer and Mark Teahen added a solo shot.

The Royals led 4-0 when Hernandez (7-9) threw a low and inside pitch that Guillen thought hit him. Guillen argued with plate umpire Marty Foster, and Detroit manager Alan Trammell came out to plead the case. The next pitch hit Guillen in the helmet.

"I didn't try to hit nobody," Hernandez said. "I feel sorry about that (hitting Guillen in the head). But I didn't try to hit him on purpose."

Guillen yelled at Hernandez when he got up and the two charged each other. The dugouts and bullpens then cleared, with Hernandez and Guillen being kept away from each other.

"I think that's absolutely wrong, throwing at somebody's head," Detroit pitcher Jeremy Bonderman said. "If I hit somebody in the head, I expect someone to do the same thing. You stand up for your teammates because you can end a guy's career throwing at somebody's head.

"He might say he did it on accident, but he still did it. In my opinion, it was totally intentional and you just don't throw at somebody's head."

The scuffle appeared to be over with no punches thrown, but more pushing and shoving began. Detroit reliever Kyle Farnsworth then charged Kansas City relief pitcher Jeremy Affeldt, picked him up and slammed him to the ground.

"It was nothing that I said," Affeldt said. "He must've felt like we were going at it."

Farnsworth said he had nothing to say.

Tigers manager Alan Trammell said Guillen was in the hospital for observation.

"It's just a typical baseball fight," Royals manager Buddy Bell said. "I just hope Guillen is OK. We've all been hit in the head at one time or another."

Hernandez, Bell, Emil Brown and Alberto Castillo were ejected for the Royals. Guillen, Farnsworth and Bonderman also were tossed.

"A lot of pitchers hit guys in the head, I don't do that," Hernandez said. "I'm not that kind of a pitcher. I always throw inside."

Too far inside, according to the Tigers.

"When you throw at a guy's head, it's no accident," Craig Monroe said. "When you go after guys' livelihoods, it's personal."

Brandon Inge agreed.

"When you're a big league pitcher, you should be able to throw below the shoulder," he said. "When you throw above the shoulder, it's no accident."

Leo Nunez relieved Hernandez and got Chris Shelton to hit into a double play and Magglio Ordonez to ground out to end the sixth. He pitched a perfect seventh before Affeldt allowed a single to Nook Logan in the eighth.

Mike MacDougal allowed three hits in the ninth before getting pinch-hitter Rodriguez to ground to short with the bases loaded.

"Runelvys started off real well and the guys came in from the pen and did a good job," Teahen said.

Hernandez hit two of the first three Detroit batters of the game, Brandon Inge and Shelton. Hernandez said he was rusty after not pitching for nine days.

Detroit starter Mike Maroth (7-10) hit David DeJesus in the second inning and home plate umpire Marty Foster warned both dugouts.

DeJesus led off the game with a single and scored on Sweeney's one-out homer. Brown followed with a lined single to center that Logan misplayed for a two-base error, which allowed Brown to go to third. Terrence Long then singled to right through a drawn-in infield for a 3-0 lead.

"It killed us when I gave up three runs in the first inning," Maroth said. "I left a lot of pitches up out over the plate."

Teahen homered with one out in the fourth.

Detroit had runners on the corners with one out in the third, but Hernandez got Shelton to hit into a double play on a 3-2 pitch to end the inning.

"We didn't play a very good ballgame," Trammell said. "When we came out today, it didn't appear that we were ready."

Maroth allowed three earned runs and nine hits in 6 1/3 innings.


  • Sweeney is 14-for-31 (.452) in his last seven games with four home runs and 11 RBI.
  • The Tigers were without 2B Placido Polanco (strained hamstring) for the fourth straight game and 1B-DH Dmitri Young (sore calf) for the second consecutive contest.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Kyle Farnsworth picks up the Royals' Jeremy Affeldt and slams him to the ground during the melee. (AP)
Kyle Farnsworth picks up the Royals' Jeremy Affeldt and slams him to the ground during the melee. (AP)

Players of the Game
Kansas City

D. DeJesus
AB 3
R 1
H 2
HR 0
Kansas City

M. Sweeney
AB 4
R 1
H 1
HR 1

Related Video

Kansas City Royals
David DeJesus, CF3121010 .297
Tony Graffanino, 1B5000004 .296
Mike Sweeney, DH4112001 .310
Emil Brown, RF3130000 .293
    Shane Costa, LF1000010 .235
Terrence Long, LF-RF4021011 .265
Angel Berroa, SS4000003 .264
John Buck, C3000110 .227
Mark Teahen, 3B3211112 .251
Joe McEwing, 2B4010000 .273
2B - David DeJesus (18, Maroth)
HR - Mike Sweeney (13, Maroth), Mark Teahen (3, Maroth)
SF - David DeJesus (3)
RBI - David DeJesus (42), Mike Sweeney 2 (48), Terrence Long (27), Mark Teahen (27)
SB - Mark Teahen (4, 2nd base off German/V. Wilson)
CS - Joe McEwing (4, 2nd base by Maroth/V. Wilson)
Team LOB - 6
DP - Ru. Hernandez-Berroa-Graffanino, Teahen-McEwing-Graffanino, Berroa-McEwing-Graffanino, Berroa-Graffanino
Kansas City Royals
Runelvys Hernandez (W,7-9) 5200120 4.33
Leo Nunez 2000010 6.34
Jeremy Affeldt 1100100 2.93
Mike MacDougal 1300010 3.59
HBP - Inge (by Runelvys Hernandez), Shelton (by Runelvys Hernandez), Guillen (by Runelvys Hernandez)
WP - Jeremy Affeldt 2 (3)
Pitches-Strikes - Runelvys Hernandez 65-36, Leo Nunez 16-11, Jeremy Affeldt 12-13, Mike MacDougal 17-14
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Runelvys Hernandez 6-6, Leo Nunez 3-1, Jeremy Affeldt 1-1, Mike MacDougal 2-0
Batters Faced - Runelvys Hernandez 20, Leo Nunez 5, Jeremy Affeldt 4, Mike MacDougal 6
Detroit Tigers
Brandon Inge, 3B2000110 .282
Carlos Guillen, SS2000002 .342
    Kevin Hooper, PR-SS1000002 .000
Chris Shelton, 1B3010002 .356
Magglio Ordonez, RF4010022 .254
Rondell White, DH4010001 .309
Craig Monroe, LF4000003 .283
Omar Infante, 2B4020011 .229
Vance Wilson, C3000001 .154
   a- Ivan Rodriguez, PH1000003 .295
Nook Logan, CF2010100 .271
a-grounded out for V. Wilson in the 9th
DP - Guillen-Infante-Shelton, Inge-Infante-Shelton
E - Carlos Guillen (6, misplayed grounder), Nook Logan (5, misplayed ball)
Detroit Tigers
Mike Maroth (L,7-10) 6.1943142 4.20
Chris Spurling 0.2000000 2.10
Jamie Walker 1000010 2.61
Franklyn German 1111100 2.60
HBP - DeJesus (by Mike Maroth)
Pitches-Strikes - Mike Maroth 99-66, Chris Spurling 6-4, Jamie Walker 11-9, Franklyn German 17-10
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Mike Maroth 6-7, Chris Spurling 1-1, Franklyn German 1-2
Batters Faced - Mike Maroth 28, Chris Spurling 2, Jamie Walker 3, Franklyn German 5
Game Information
Attendance - 24166
Game Time - 2:48
Temperature - 83
Umpires - Home - Marty Foster, First Base - Lazaro Diaz, Second Base - Dana DeMuth, Third Base - Troy Fullwood