Detroit at Oakland

W: F. Rodney (1-0) L: J. Duchscherer (1-1)
HR: DET - None   OAK - None

Tigers rally past Oakland, then hold on in bottom of ninth

CBS wire reports

OAKLAND, Calif. -- Brandon Inge kept hacking away, trying to show fill-in closer Justin Duchscherer he would not back down or be an easy out.

Inge walked after a 15-pitch plate appearance, then Curtis Granderson drew a free pass with the bases loaded to bring home the go-ahead run in the ninth inning, and the Detroit Tigers rallied to beat the Oakland Athletics 4-3 on Thursday.

Inge was determined to wear down Duchscherer (1-1), who pitched in place of Huston Street because the A's regular closer has a mild strain of a muscle in his chest.

"I was battling absolutely as hard as I could," Inge said. "A pitcher would rather have a rocket hit off him than have someone stand up there and keep fouling off pitches. That's frustrating for a pitcher. He thinks this is the pitch and you foul it off. I know as a catcher I got frustrated. ... I think it was a great opportunity for a hit, a walk, anything. Once I was three, four minutes into the at bat, I'm thinking 'I have to get on base some way."'

Tigers skipper Jim Leyland joked that Inge stood in there so long he had enough time to smoke more than one cigarette.

"One-and-a-half Marlboros," Leyland said. "That was a tremendous at-bat. He showed great discipline up there. When people see that, they see the way it can be done."

A's manager Ken Macha opted to stick with Duchscherer rather than immediately turn to reliever Kirk Saarloos, who had already been warming up for several minutes.

"I felt like I was in control," Duchscherer said. "I made some pitches and he kept getting a little piece of them. I tried to battle and they just beat me today."

Fernando Rodney (1-0) pitched two innings, working out of a bases-loaded jam in the ninth to extend his scoreless streak at the season's start to 7 2/3 innings. He struck out pinch-hitter Adam Melhuse to end it.

Magglio Ordonez led off the ninth with a single, pinch-hitter Alexis Gomez doubled and Chris Shelton singled to make it 3-2 with no outs before Carlos Guillen's tying single.

Barry Zito showed the dominant form he's had in past seasons with seven strong innings but had nothing to show for it at the end after Duchscherer lost the lead in the ninth.

Mark Kotsay tripled, while Bobby Crosby, Eric Chavez and Milton Bradley all drove in runs to stake Zito to a 3-1 lead in the first inning.

Zito, who appears to be finding his groove again, allowed two first-inning hits, including an RBI double to Ordonez. He didn't allow another until Granderson's single to start the sixth.

Inge's effort earned him some serious points with his teammates. Duchscherer hadn't allowed a run in 14 innings dating to last season.

"Games like this are very good for us and will be a key for us," Ivan Rodriguez said. "That was the game right there: Brandon Inge."

Nick Swisher had his career-best 10-game hitting streak snapped after an 0-for-2 day that featured two walks, but Oakland's sputtering offense couldn't do enough to get the A's (7-9) back to the .500 mark.

The A's batted only 10-for-61 (.164) in the first two games of the series -- the five hits in each contest matching the club's season low. Oakland managed six hits Thursday.

Kotsay tripled in the first and scored on Crosby's single, and Chavez followed with his double.

Zito allowed one run on three hits, walked four, struck out three and plunked two batters in a 100-pitch performance after losing to Texas last Friday.

Zito, the 2002 AL Cy Young Award winner, has traditionally had a hard time in the season's first month. He has his highest ERA in April and it's the only month in which he doesn't have a winning record.

Shelton went 1-for-3 with a walk and a strikeout and didn't hit a home run during the series, remaining at nine homers for the season.

Jeremy Bonderman was saved from losing his third straight start. He didn't give up a run after the first inning, allowing three runs and five hits.


  • After the game, the Tigers optioned RHP Chris Spurling to Triple-A Toledo and activated closer Todd Jones, who had been on the 15-day disabled list with a pulled left hamstring.
  • Zito reached 100 pitches for the third straight start.
  • After committing four errors in the first two games of the series, Guillen worked a clean game at shortstop.
  • The A's dropped to 1-5 against the AL Central.
  • Struggling Dan Johnson -- 1-for-32 (.031) with one RBI to start the season coming into Thursday's game -- returned to the A's lineup at 1B after getting several days to work on his swing. He still had problems, going hitless in three at-bats.
  • Johnson and SS Crosby teamed up for inning-ending double plays in the fourth and fifth.
  • Frank Thomas got his first career hit off Bonderman with a fourth-inning single after going 0-for-7.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Fernando Rodney lives on the edge, but records enough outs to get the victory.  (Getty Images)
Fernando Rodney lives on the edge, but records enough outs to get the victory. (Getty Images)

Players of the Game

B. Zito
IP 7.0
H 3
ER 1
BB 4
K 3

M. Ordonez
AB 4
R 1
H 2
HR 0

Related Video

Detroit Tigers
Curtis Granderson, CF3011200 .295
Placido Polanco, 2B4110004 .339
Ivan Rodriguez, C5000005 .259
Magglio Ordonez, RF4121002 .263
Marcus Thames, DH3000013 .231
   a- Alexis Gomez, PH-DH1110000 .286
Chris Shelton, 1B3011111 .426
    Ramon Santiago, PR-SS0000000 .125
Carlos Guillen, SS-1B3111001 .310
Craig Monroe, LF3000104 .224
Brandon Inge, 3B2000212 .250
a-doubled for Thames in the 9th
2B - Magglio Ordonez (2, Zito), Alexis Gomez (2, Duchscherer)
RBI - Curtis Granderson (6), Magglio Ordonez (9), Chris Shelton (18), Carlos Guillen (8)
2-OUT RBI - Magglio Ordonez (4)
CS - Brandon Inge (2, 2nd base by Zito/Kendall)
Team LOB - 8
DP - Inge-Polanco-Shelton
Detroit Tigers
Jeremy Bonderman 7533210 5.55
Fernando Rodney (W,1-0) 2100220 0.00
Pitches-Strikes - Jeremy Bonderman 99-0, Fernando Rodney 37-0
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Jeremy Bonderman 7-12, Fernando Rodney 3-1
Batters Faced - Jeremy Bonderman 27, Fernando Rodney 9
Oakland Athletics
Mark Ellis, 2B4000000 .188
Mark Kotsay, CF4110010 .278
Bobby Crosby, SS4111010 .213
Eric Chavez, 3B2111200 .296
Frank Thomas, DH4010003 .192
Milton Bradley, RF4021002 .291
Nick Swisher, LF2000201 .321
Jason Kendall, C4000004 .225
Dan Johnson, 1B3000000 .029
   a- Adam Melhuse, PH1000013 .364
a-struck out for Johnson in the 9th
2B - Eric Chavez (4, Bonderman)
3B - Mark Kotsay (2, Bonderman)
RBI - Bobby Crosby (3), Eric Chavez (14), Milton Bradley (6)
2-OUT RBI - Milton Bradley (2)
Team LOB - 6
DP - Chavez-Ellis-Johnson, Johnson-Crosby, Crosby-Johnson
E - Bobby Crosby (4, Misplayed grounder)
Oakland Athletics
Barry Zito 7311430 5.48
Joe Kennedy (H,4) 0.1000000 0.00
Kiko Calero (H,2) 0.2000000 0.00
Justin Duchscherer (BS,1; L,1-1) 0.1433200 3.24
Kirk Saarloos 0.2000000 8.22
HBP - Polanco (by Barry Zito), Guillen (by Barry Zito)
Pitches-Strikes - Barry Zito 100-0, Joe Kennedy 6-0, Kiko Calero 9-0, Justin Duchscherer 36-0, Kirk Saarloos 7-0
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Barry Zito 7-8, Justin Duchscherer 1-0, Kirk Saarloos 1-1
Batters Faced - Barry Zito 27, Joe Kennedy 1, Kiko Calero 2, Justin Duchscherer 7, Kirk Saarloos 2
Game Information
Attendance - 15489
Game Time - 2:41
Temperature - 62
Umpires - Home - Ramon Armendariz, First Base - Angel Hernandez, Second Base - Hunter Wendelstedt, Third Base - Randy Marsh