• My Scores
  • MLB
  • NHL
  • NBA

Toronto at New York

N.Y. Yankees
W: M. Mussina (4-1) L: G. Chacin (4-1)
S: M. Rivera (4)
HR: TOR - None   NYY - A. Phillips (1), J. Giambi (9)

Yankees close homestand with efficient victory over Jays

CBS SportsLine.com wire reports

NEW YORK -- The riled-up New York Yankees spent all afternoon barking at the plate umpire, and an angry Joe Torre charged out of the dugout to argue a rare ejection.

Looks as though the Bronx Bombers are ready for their first trip to Boston.

Jason Giambi hit a two-run homer and Mike Mussina shut down the Toronto Blue Jays again, leading New York to a 4-1 victory Sunday. Andy Phillips also homered for the Yankees, who took two of three in the series and finished 6-3 on their first long homestand of the season.

The normally even-tempered Torre wasn't around for the end -- he and Toronto skipper John Gibbons were both ejected for arguing balls and strikes with umpire Adam Dowdy.

"He shows emotion in big situations," Giambi said. "It definitely, I think, gave us a lift."

Johnny Damon had three hits for the second day in a row as he prepares for his much-anticipated return to Fenway Park. He and the Yankees lead the AL East by percentage points over Boston, where they begin a two-game series Monday night.

"It feels like my bat speed, I'm quick. It feels like my balance is there," Damon said. "So hopefully, I can keep on belting out hits and hopefully, the guys keep driving me in."

Mussina (4-1) outpitched Gustavo Chacin, allowing one run and seven hits in six innings for his sixth solid start in six outings this year.

Featuring what Damon calls his "Bugs Bunny changeup," the right-hander struck out seven and walked two. He also beat the Blue Jays 3-1 on April 19 in Toronto.

"I thought I made some pitches that didn't get called. I fought through it," Mussina said.

Kyle Farnsworth fanned three in 1 2/3 scoreless innings, and Mariano Rivera got four quick outs for his fourth save. New York improved to 10-0 in day games.

Trying to become the AL's first five-game winner, Chacin (4-1) gave up two runs and six hits in six innings. He failed in his bid to become the first Blue Jays starter to win five times in April, according to the Elias Sports Bureau.

"I think he's our MVP so far. Every time he's on the mound, he gives us a chance to win," Toronto's Vernon Wells said.

Both teams took issue with Dowdy's strike zone. Dowdy, a Triple-A umpire filling in for Mike DiMuro, has worked major league games since 2002.

Dowdy ejected Torre in the middle of the fifth after Mussina struck out Shea Hillenbrand (for the third time) with the bases loaded.

As Chacin was warming up for the bottom half, Torre said he caught Dowdy's attention and held up three fingers.

"He asked me what it meant," Torre said. "I told him it meant he missed three pitches. He threw me out after that."

Gibbons was tossed in the bottom of the fifth after three consecutive walks by Chacin forced in a run, his only three walks of the game.

"Tough place to play," Gibbons said three separate times, with a slight smirk on his face.

Yankees owner George Steinbrenner took exception to the ejections -- and the fact Dowdy was even behind the plate, the New York Daily News reported Monday.

"I think it's a crime that the league would assign a rookie umpire to a crucial series like this," Steinbrenner said. "I'm really P.O.'d at the league for sending those kinds of umpires -- a rookie umpire in here to do this series."

Steinbrenner indicated either he or someone else from the Yankees' front office would discuss the situation at baseball's main offices Monday. Baseball spokesman Pat Courtney told the newspaper he had no comment when told of Steinbrenner's plan.

Torre was ejected for the first time since last June 8 in Milwaukee. He was tossed only twice last year.

"We felt we had some calls that didn't go our way. Our manager got thrown out first," New York's Alex Rodriguez said. "He didn't say anything. There were 14 people in the dugout yelling at the umpire. I guess he just picked out the manager. I thought Joe handled himself with a lot of class, and all of a sudden he gets thrown out of the game."

But the ejection woke up the crowd of 52,954 and seemed to spark the Yankees.

Toronto went ahead in the third on Frank Catalanotto's RBI double. With a runner on third, Mussina struck out cleanup batter Troy Glaus and retired Lyle Overbay to escape further damage.

Phillips connected in the fifth. Damon doubled with two outs and Chacin walked three straight, giving the Yankees a 2-1 lead.

Chacin and the Blue Jays thought his 2-2 pitch to Rodriguez with the bases loaded caught the inside corner. Ball four also looked close, and the frustrated lefty turned his back to the plate and walked nearly all the way to third base as Gibbons popped out of the dugout to argue.

"They were both close. The timing of it all, after the top of the inning," Gibbons said, "tough place to play for us."

Wells had a similar take.

"Obviously, it was a good day to have pinstripes on," he said. "We had opportunities, we just didn't play well enough to win."

Derek Jeter doubled off Pete Walker with two outs in the seventh, and Giambi followed with a drive off the facing of the right-field upper deck to make it 4-1.

Giambi came out for a curtain call after his ninth homer and second in two days. He has 27 RBI -- a total he didn't reach last year until July 5.


  • The Yankees activated RHP Aaron Small from the DL after the game and optioned LHP Matt Smith to Triple-A Columbus.
  • Yankees RF Gary Sheffield sat out with a bruised left hand following a collision with Hillenbrand at 1B the previous day. Sheffield is day-to-day.
  • Toronto bench coach Ernie Whitt argued with second base umpire Larry Poncino in the seventh after Alex Rios was caught stealing. He appeared to be safe. "Maybe somebody blinked. I don't know," Gibbons said.
  • Dowdy also ejected Yankees RHP Orlando Hernandez and pitching coach Mel Stottlemyre in a September 2004 game against Tampa Bay.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Jason Giambi rounds the bases after hitting his ninth homer of the season in the seventh inning.  (AP)
Jason Giambi rounds the bases after hitting his ninth homer of the season in the seventh inning. (AP)

Players of the Game
New York

J. Giambi
AB 3
R 1
H 1
HR 1

F. Catalanotto
AB 3
R 0
H 2
HR 0

Related Video

Toronto Blue Jays
Alex Rios, RF5120010 .362
Frank Catalanotto, LF3021010 .413
Vernon Wells, CF4020011 .396
Troy Glaus, 3B4000024 .259
Lyle Overbay, 1B3010111 .275
Shea Hillenbrand, DH4000034 .329
Gregg Zaun, C3000101 .258
Aaron Hill, 2B3020010 .195
   a- Eric Hinske, PH1000000 .323
Russ Adams, SS4000003 .225
a-grounded out for Hill in the 9th
2B - Frank Catalanotto (6, Mussina), Lyle Overbay (2, Farnsworth)
RBI - Frank Catalanotto (10)
CS - Alex Rios (1, 2nd base by Farnsworth/Posada)
Team LOB - 9
DP - Hill-R. Adams-Overbay
Toronto Blue Jays
Gustavo Chacin (L,4-1) 6622361 4.70
Pete Walker 1222001 5.40
Brian Tallet 1100100 7.71
Pitches-Strikes - Gustavo Chacin 110-59, Pete Walker 19-10, Brian Tallet 15-8
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Gustavo Chacin 3-8, Pete Walker 2-1, Brian Tallet 1-1
Batters Faced - Gustavo Chacin 26, Pete Walker 5, Brian Tallet 4
New York Yankees
Johnny Damon, CF4130000 .312
Derek Jeter, SS3120101 .398
Jason Giambi, DH3112123 .344
Alex Rodriguez, 3B3001111 .267
Hideki Matsui, LF4010013 .258
Jorge Posada, C3010110 .288
Bernie Williams, RF3000001 .217
    Bubba Crosby, RF1000001 .200
Andy Phillips, 1B4111012 .154
Miguel Cairo, 2B3000000 .300
2B - Johnny Damon (9, Chacin), Derek Jeter (9, Walker), Hideki Matsui (6, Tallet)
HR - Jason Giambi (9, Walker), Andy Phillips (1, Chacin)
RBI - Jason Giambi 2 (27), Alex Rodriguez (16), Andy Phillips (2)
2-OUT RBI - Jason Giambi 2 (10), Alex Rodriguez (4)
SB - Johnny Damon (7, 3rd base off Chacin/Zaun)
PK - Hideki Matsui (1, Tallet)
Team LOB - 7
DP - Rodriguez-Cairo-Phillips
New York Yankees
Mike Mussina (W,4-1) 6711270 2.31
Kyle Farnsworth (H,4) 1.2200030 2.89
Mariano Rivera (S,4) 1.1000000 3.72
HBP - Catalanotto (by Mike Mussina)
Pitches-Strikes - Mike Mussina 95-64, Kyle Farnsworth 25-16, Mariano Rivera 12-10
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Mike Mussina 2-8, Mariano Rivera 3-1
Batters Faced - Mike Mussina 27, Kyle Farnsworth 6, Mariano Rivera 4
Game Information
Attendance - 52954
Game Time - 2:56
Temperature - 63
Umpires - Home - Adam Dowdy, First Base - Gary Darling, Second Base - Larry Poncino, Third Base - Bruce Dreckman