Philadelphia at Milwaukee

W: D. Turnbow (1-1) L: R. Franklin (1-3)
HR: PHI - None   MIL - None

Brewers' Hall scores winning run on throwing error

CBS wire reports

MILWAUKEE -- Bill Hall made a defensive play to save a run in the ninth, and scored the winning run moments later. In between, he even promised he'd end the game.

The versatile Hall made good on his word after a throwing error by Ryan Franklin in the ninth gave the Milwaukee Brewers a 3-2 victory over Philadelphia on Tuesday night.

Waiting for his turn to bat, Hall whispered his thoughts to pitcher Dave Bush.

"I actually promised Bush in the dugout that I was going to do something in the ninth inning, that we were going to have a walk-off win," Hall said.

Damian Miller bunted to the third-base side of the mound and Franklin (1-3) fired wildly to David Bell at third, allowing Hall, who led off the inning with a double, to coast home on the error.

How close was Franklin to getting Hall?

"If he makes a good throw right there, I'm out," Hall said. "But that's what happens when you rush things."

Franklin agreed.

"I just messed up," he said. "I would have had him if I made a good throw."

It was just the second loss in 15 games for the Phillies, while the Brewers improved to 3-1 on their nine-game homestand.

Milwaukee again came from behind to win -- the 12th time in 14 home victories and 13th overall.

After starting the game in center field, Hall made a brilliant play at shortstop in the top of the ninth after J.J. Hardy left the inning before without putting any weight on his right ankle.

Hall fielded David Dellucci's grounder to his left, jumped and fired to first for the final out with Shane Victorino running home after he reached third on a two-out triple off Derrick Turnbow (1-1), who got the win.

Hardy hurt himself on another terrific play.

Carlos Lee, who drove in Milwaukee's first run with a sacrifice fly, hit a flare single to left. Philadelphia's Pat Burrell barehanded the ball and fired home, where Sal Fasano perfectly blocked the plate with Hardy sliding in. Hardy had to be helped off the field and will undergo an MRI on Wednesday of what the team called a sprain.

"J.J. just hesitated just enough to get thrown out at the plate," Brewers manager Ned Yost said after the game. "But that's definitely the way you block the plate. That's textbook right there."

The starting matchup was between two of the more prolific strikeout artists in baseball, with Philadelphia's Cory Lidle averaging 8.8 K's per nine innings and Milwaukee's Chris Capuano just behind at 8.2.

But both needed their bullpens to come through because runs were hard to come after a myriad of bad baserunning.

First, Chase Utley was nearly picked off by the lefty Capuano in the first before later coming around to score on Ryan Howard's single. Capuano picked Fasano off first the next inning.

The Brewers weren't much better -- Koskie was easily thrown out trying to steal second and Capuano got in the act too, doubling to the wall in the fourth but getting hung up on the next at-bat by Rickie Weeks' grounder.

Geoff Jenkins' RBI single in the third gave Milwaukee a 2-1 lead.

Victorino and Bell hit back-to-back doubles with one out in the seventh inning to tie the game two-all. Hall got a bad jump on Bell's double, which took one hop and went over the wall to score Victorino.

Capuano finished giving up six hits and two runs while striking out seven in seven innings.

Lidle, who struck out four on his own, left after six innings, giving up five hits, two walks and two runs.

"What it boils down to is that we had a couple of chances to win the game late and we didn't do it," Phillies manager Charlie Manuel said. "They executed by bunting the ball, we threw it away and they won the game. There is no sense is us getting down."


  • Weeks committed his 13th error in his 35 games this season in the third.
  • Phillies SS Jimmy Rollins is hitting just 1-of-19 on the road trip. But manager Charlie Manuel wasn't worried. "Jimmy's been getting into some bad luck lately," he said.
  • The Brewers designated right-handed pitcher Jared Fernandez for assignment, giving them 10 days to trade or release him if he refuses.
  • Yost has not selected a Saturday starter against the Minnesota Twins, making it appear that the team may not use Ben Hendrickson, who has gone 0-1 with a 7.50 ERA in three starts.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
J.J. Hardy is helped off the field after his collision with Phils catcher Sal Fasano.  (AP)
J.J. Hardy is helped off the field after his collision with Phils catcher Sal Fasano. (AP)

Players of the Game

G. Jenkins
AB 3
R 0
H 2
HR 0

D. Bell
AB 3
R 0
H 1
HR 0

Related Video

Philadelphia Phillies
Jimmy Rollins, SS4000000 .242
Chase Utley, 2B3110100 .303
Bobby Abreu, RF4010022 .257
Pat Burrell, LF4000034 .276
Ryan Howard, 1B4011000 .301
Shane Victorino, CF3120012 .413
David Bell, 3B3011101 .261
Sal Fasano, C3010021 .245
   a- David Dellucci, PH1000002 .233
    Carlos Ruiz, C0000000 .105
Cory Lidle, P2000010 .091
   b- Abraham Nunez, PH1000001 .214
    Ryan Madson, P0000000 .400
    Ryan Franklin, P0000000 .000
a-grounded out for Fasano in the 9th
b-flied out for Lidle in the 7th
2B - Shane Victorino (6, Capuano), David Bell (9, Capuano)
3B - Shane Victorino (2, Turnbow)
RBI - Ryan Howard (28), David Bell (12)
2-OUT RBI - Ryan Howard (10)
CS - Sal Fasano (1, 2nd base by Capuano/D. Miller)
Team LOB - 6
Outfield Assists - Pat Burrell 1
E - Ryan Franklin (1, )
Philadelphia Phillies
Cory Lidle 6522240 4.84
Ryan Madson 1000000 6.96
Ryan Franklin (L,1-3) 1310200 3.72
IBB - Jenkins by Ryan Franklin, by Koskie
Pitches-Strikes - Cory Lidle 83-53, Ryan Madson 7-4, Ryan Franklin 24-12
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Cory Lidle 8-5, Ryan Madson 1-2, Ryan Franklin 2-1
Batters Faced - Cory Lidle 24, Ryan Madson 3, Ryan Franklin 8
Milwaukee Brewers
Rickie Weeks, 2B4110000 .286
J.J. Hardy, SS3110102 .242
    Brady Clark, CF0000000 .224
Geoff Jenkins, RF3021110 .268
Carlos Lee, LF3011003 .297
Prince Fielder, 1B4010023 .319
Bill Hall, CF-SS4110001 .291
Corey Koskie, 3B2000200 .287
Damian Miller, C4000000 .324
Chris Capuano, P2010010 .105
   a- Gabe Gross, PH1000000 .255
    Brian Shouse, P0000000 .000
    Derrick Turnbow, P0000000 .000
a-flied out for Capuano in the 7th
2B - Rickie Weeks (4, Lidle), J.J. Hardy (5, Franklin), Geoff Jenkins (10, Lidle), Prince Fielder (9, Lidle), Bill Hall (10, Franklin), Chris Capuano (1, Lidle)
SF - Carlos Lee (2)
RBI - Geoff Jenkins (22), Carlos Lee (33)
2-OUT RBI - Geoff Jenkins (9)
CS - Corey Koskie (1, 2nd base by Lidle/Fasano)
Team LOB - 6
DP - Hardy-Weeks-Fielder, Koskie-Weeks-Fielder
E - Rickie Weeks (13, throwing error)
Milwaukee Brewers
Chris Capuano 7622170 2.80
Brian Shouse 1000010 3.38
Derrick Turnbow (W,1-1) 1100110 2.20
HBP - Victorino (by Chris Capuano)
Pitches-Strikes - Chris Capuano 95-67, Brian Shouse 7-5, Derrick Turnbow 23-14
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Chris Capuano 6-6, Derrick Turnbow 2-0
Batters Faced - Chris Capuano 27, Brian Shouse 3, Derrick Turnbow 5
Game Information
Attendance - 14592
Game Time - 2:34
Temperature - 66
Umpires - Home - Bob Davidson, First Base - Ron Kulpa, Second Base - Dale Scott, Third Base - Dan Iassogna