• My Scores
  • MLB
  • NHL
  • NBA

Oakland at Minnesota

W: D. Haren (14-11) L: M. Garza (1-5)
S: H. Street (32)
HR: OAK - None   MIN - None

Twins take double hit; lose to A's, lose Liriano

CBS SportsLine.com wire reports

MINNEAPOLIS -- The Minnesota Twins will have to make their playoff push without Francisco Liriano.

Sobering Liriano injury rocks AL Central race
by Scott Miller
What's Your Take?
Tell Scott your opinion!

A strong Rookie of the Year candidate, Liriano walked off the mound because of elbow trouble Wednesday in his highly anticipated return to the Minnesota rotation. After a 1-0 loss to Oakland, manager Ron Gardenhire said Liriano was done for the year.

"Obviously he won't be pitching again," Gardenhire said. "Something is in there bothering and continuing to stop him. ... Obviously when he gets in a game and puts a little extra torque in there, something is not right. We have to make sure we stop it and do what we have to do."

The Twins' lead in the AL wild-card race was cut to 1½ games by Chicago, which beat Los Angeles 9-0.

Liriano slumped off the mound in the third inning. Trainers and Gardenhire immediately rushed out to attend to the All-Star lefty and a hush fell over the crowd that had been so excited to see him back in action.

"The last two pitches I threw, I felt a pop and it really hurts," Liriano said.

Liriano walked slowly toward the dugout and fans gave him a standing ovation -- clearly, they were wondering whether they had seen the last of him this year.

The Twins later said he had pain in his left elbow.

He had an MRI exam after the game, and thoughts immediately turned to Tommy John surgery, a ligament-replacement procedure that typically keeps pitchers out for more than a year.

Liriano said he was waiting to hear from team doctors about the next move.

"I don't even want to think about that," Twins pitching coach Rick Anderson said when asked about Tommy John surgery.

Liriano was 12-3 with a 2.19 ERA before leaving a start against Detroit on Aug. 8 with a strained ligament in his arm.

The Twins were determined to be extra cautious with his recovery, but the 22-year-old Liriano showed no signs of problems during a rehab start for Triple-A Rochester last Saturday.

Everything seemed to be going so well on Wednesday.

Liriano breezed through the first two innings against the A's, striking out two. But after giving up a bloop single to Nick Swisher to start the third inning, Liriano threw ball one to Bobby Kielty and that was it.

"This guy has a bright future," center fielder Torii Hunter said. "Maybe we just need to let him heal for the offseason and have him back for spring training. ... Hopefully he can get it taken care of and come back next year or the year after next."

Matt Garza (1-5) pitched well in emergency relief, but he was outdueled by Dan Haren (14-11), who pitched eight shutout innings.

Haren struck out seven and allowed three hits and Huston Street picked up his 32nd save to help the Athletics avoid their first three-game losing streak since July 23-25.

"Throughout this road trip, our starting pitching hasn't been too good," Oakland manager Ken Macha said. "Danny really answered the call."

The AL West-leading Athletics scored in the sixth.

Milton Bradley singled and stole second base. Replays showed that Twins second baseman Luis Castillo tagged Bradley before he hit the bag, and Gardenhire argued with umpire Randy Marsh.

The call proved costly when Bradley scored on Jay Payton's ground-rule double to give Oakland a 1-0 lead.

Losing Liriano puts an even greater strain on an already rickety Twins rotation. Veteran Brad Radke has a stress fracture in his right shoulder and may not return this season. Carlos Silva has been wildly inconsistent and Scott Baker has pitched poorly.

By default, rookie Boof Bonser could be the team's No. 2 starter behind ace Johan Santana.

"I can't make any decision right now," a subdued Liriano said. "This was disappointing. I wanted to pitch. Nobody wants to be hurt. There's nothing I can do about it. I just have to wait and see."

Despite Liriano's injury, the Twins exhibited a quiet confidence in the clubhouse after the game. When the lefty first was injured on Aug. 7, the Twins were 10½ games behind the Tigers. They responded by shaving nine games off the lead between his starts.

"It's not devastating. It's not earth-shattering," Michael Cuddyer said. "It's very disappointing for him on a personal level. But we've been here before."


  • After his six-game homer streak ended on Tuesday, A's DH Frank Thomas went 1-for-4 with a double on Wednesday.
  • Twins C Joe Mauer, the majors' leading hitter, did not start as usual on a day game after a night game. He lined out to left in a pinch-hit appearance in the eighth inning.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Rookie of the Year candidate Francisco Liriano yields just one hit before leaving in the third inning.  (AP)
Rookie of the Year candidate Francisco Liriano yields just one hit before leaving in the third inning. (AP)

Players of the Game

D. Haren
IP 8.0
H 3
ER 0
BB 1
K 7

M. Bradley
AB 4
R 1
H 2
HR 0

Related Video

Oakland Athletics
Jason Kendall, C4020012 .296
Mark Ellis, 2B4000024 .244
Milton Bradley, RF4120000 .275
Frank Thomas, DH4010012 .280
Jay Payton, CF4011011 .300
Eric Chavez, 3B4000002 .243
Nick Swisher, 1B-LF3010110 .255
Bobby Kielty, LF1000011 .272
    Dan Johnson, 1B3010010 .235
Marco Scutaro, SS4010002 .247
2B - Frank Thomas (9, Garza), Jay Payton (27, Garza)
RBI - Jay Payton (54)
2-OUT RBI - Jay Payton (18)
SB - Milton Bradley (7, 2nd base off Garza/Redmond)
Team LOB - 8
Outfield Assists - Milton Bradley 1
Oakland Athletics
Dan Haren (W,14-11) 8300170 3.79
Huston Street (S,32) 1000000 3.06
Pitches-Strikes - Dan Haren 101-74, Huston Street 14-8
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Dan Haren 6-10, Huston Street 1-2
Batters Faced - Dan Haren 27, Huston Street 3
Minnesota Twins
Luis Castillo, 2B4000000 .291
Nick Punto, 3B4000020 .296
Mike Redmond, C4010000 .331
Michael Cuddyer, RF3010011 .277
Justin Morneau, 1B2010101 .325
Torii Hunter, CF3000022 .272
Josh Rabe, LF2000011 .286
   a- Joe Mauer, PH1000000 .348
    Lew Ford, LF0000000 .220
Jason Tyner, DH3000000 .314
Jason Bartlett, SS3000010 .327
a-lined out for Rabe in the 8th
DP - Bartlett-Castillo-Morneau
E - Nick Punto (12, )
Minnesota Twins
Francisco Liriano 2100020 2.16
Matt Garza (L,1-5) 5.2811140 5.50
Dennys Reyes 1000020 0.99
Juan Rincon 0.1000000 2.96
Pitches-Strikes - Francisco Liriano 27-20, Matt Garza 94-63, Dennys Reyes 15-10, Juan Rincon 2-2
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Francisco Liriano 3-1, Matt Garza 6-6, Dennys Reyes 1-0
Batters Faced - Francisco Liriano 7, Matt Garza 25, Dennys Reyes 3, Juan Rincon 1
Game Information
Attendance - 18902
Game Time - 2:38
Temperature - 69
Umpires - Home - Mike Everitt, First Base - Tom Hallion, Second Base - Randy Marsh, Third Base - Alfonso Marquez