Cleveland at Oakland

W: J. Duchscherer (1-0) L: P. Byrd (0-1)
HR: CLE - R. Garko (1), T. Hafner (1)   OAK - None

Athletics 6, Indians 3 wire reports

OAKLAND, Calif. -- Oakland right-hander Justin Duchscherer couldn't even enjoy his first start in nearly five years. A strained biceps in his pitching arm made sure of that.

Duchscherer allowed one run in five innings to help Oakland to a 6-3 victory over the Cleveland Indians on Friday night, but the celebration of his return to the A's rotation was tempered by how he left the game.

A reliever the past four years before an offseason trade sent staff ace Dan Haren to Arizona and opened a spot in the A's staff, Duchscherer tied his career high with six strikeouts. He also walked two before leaving in the sixth after giving up back-to-back singles to Kelly Shoppach and Grady Sizemore and falling behind in the count to Asdrubal Cabrera.

"I don't know how bad it is," Duchscherer said. "I've never had it before. Hopefully I'll come in tomorrow and won't feel too bad. It's extremely frustrating."

Duchscherer, who had season-ending surgery on his right hip last July, retired the first 11 batters he faced. He threw only 72 pitches before being taken out of the game following a meeting on the mound with Oakland head trainer Steve Sayles.

"It's one of those freak things that seem to happen to me quite frequently," Duchscherer said. "I felt good for the first four innings and I felt like I was cruising. This is the last thing I wanted to happen. All I was thinking about on the mound was, 'Please don't be hurt."'

Duchscherer initially felt a cramp in his right arm in the fifth but shrugged it off following a brief meeting at the mound with Sayles, manager Bob Geren and catcher Kurt Suzuki. He tried loosening up by throwing in the A's indoor batting cage between innings, but felt a pull in his arm when he came out for the sixth.

While there was initial concern that Duchscherer (1-0) might have aggravated his hip, the A's later announced that he was suffering from "slight biceps tendinitis."

"We'll know more in the next day or two how he feels," said Geren, adding that Duchscherer is day-to-day. "He felt like he had a little bit of a cramp and then it went away. I guess it got to the point where he felt it was pretty sore."

It was only the sixth start of Duchscherer's career and his first since Sept. 20, 2003.

Cleveland starter Paul Byrd also had his problems, but they weren't physical.

The Indians' right-hander struggled with his command in the first two innings, walking the second batter he faced and hitting two more in the second. Suzuki, one of the two A's batters hit by Byrd, later scored on a passed ball.

"My control was horrible," said Byrd, who only threw 49 of his 82 pitches for strikes. "The ball was up all night. I got away with a lot of stuff earlier. I just didn't figure out how to get the ball down. You can only throw so many bad pitches before it comes back to haunt you."

The A's, scoreless in their previous 16 innings before Friday, chased Byrd in the fifth when they batted around to make it 5-0. Suzuki and Ryan Sweeney, who went 4-for-4, both had RBI singles for Oakland.

Byrd (0-1) gave up five runs and eight hits while taking the loss.

"We weren't able to make the plays and we made some mistakes, too," Cleveland manager Eric Wedge said. "(Duchscherer) kept us off balance. We never really got anything going against him."

Garko and Travis Hafner both homered for the Indians.


Oakland RHP Chad Gaudin, who had foot and hip surgery in December, will make one more rehab start and is on target to start against the Indians in Cleveland on April 12. ... Garko's home run off Keith Foulke was the first run allowed by the Oakland reliever in 14 1/3 innings. ... Oakland leadoff hitter Travis Buck is 0-for-18 this season. ... Cleveland backup catcher Victor Martinez (hamstring) has missed the last three games but could return to the Indians lineup Saturday, Wedge said. ... Cleveland LHP C.C. Sabathia, the reigning AL Cy Young Award winner, makes his second start of the season Saturday against Oakland's Dana Eveland.

Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Players of the Game

R. Garko
AB 4
R 1
H 2
HR 1

B. Crosby
AB 4
R 2
H 2
HR 0

Related Video

Cleveland Indians
Grady Sizemore, CF4020010 .375
Asdrubal Cabrera, 2B3000101 .200
Jhonny Peralta, SS4010010 .176
Travis Hafner, DH4111022 .267
Ryan Garko, 1B4121000 .333
Franklin Gutierrez, RF4000011 .231
David Dellucci, LF2000110 .000
Casey Blake, 3B3000021 .154
Kelly Shoppach, C3110020 .300
2B - Jhonny Peralta (1, Duchscherer), Ryan Garko (2, Duchscherer)
HR - Travis Hafner (1, Street), Ryan Garko (1, Foulke)
RBI - Travis Hafner (2), Ryan Garko (3)
Team LOB - 3
PB - Kelly Shoppach (2)
E - Jhonny Peralta (1, Misplayed grounder)
Cleveland Indians
Paul Byrd (L,0-1) 4.1853200 6.23
Jorge Julio 2.1111010 5.40
Craig Breslow 1.1100110 0.00
HBP - Suzuki (by Paul Byrd), Buck (by Paul Byrd)
WP - Jorge Julio (1)
Pitches-Strikes - Paul Byrd 81-48, Jorge Julio 34-22, Craig Breslow 19-11
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Paul Byrd 7-8, Jorge Julio 3-3
Batters Faced - Paul Byrd 27, Jorge Julio 8, Craig Breslow 6
Oakland Athletics
Travis Buck, RF4000024 .000
Mark Ellis, 2B3000205 .059
Daric Barton, 1B4120101 .176
Mike Sweeney, DH5100003 .154
Jack Cust, LF5110004 .133
    Chris Denorfia, LF0000000 .250
Bobby Crosby, SS4221000 .333
Jack Hannahan, 3B3001003 .235
Kurt Suzuki, C3111000 .353
Ryan Sweeney, CF4041000 .444
2B - Bobby Crosby (2, Julio)
SF - Jack Hannahan (1)
RBI - Bobby Crosby (2), Jack Hannahan (3), Kurt Suzuki (1), Ryan Sweeney (1)
Team LOB - 11
DP - Crosby-Ellis-Barton, Hannahan-Ellis-Barton, Crosby-Ellis-Barton
Oakland Athletics
Justin Duchscherer (W,1-0) 5411260 1.80
Santiago Casilla (H,2) 1000010 0.00
Keith Foulke 1111021 2.25
Alan Embree 1100010 3.86
Huston Street 1111001 12.27
Pitches-Strikes - Justin Duchscherer 75-49, Santiago Casilla 12-9, Keith Foulke 21-13, Alan Embree 14-9, Huston Street 18-13
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Justin Duchscherer 4-4, Santiago Casilla 1-0, Alan Embree 1-0, Huston Street 3-0
Batters Faced - Justin Duchscherer 20, Santiago Casilla 2, Keith Foulke 4, Alan Embree 3, Huston Street 4
Game Information
Attendance - 13916
Game Time - 2:49
Temperature - 53
Umpires - Home - Tim Timmons, First Base - Gary Cederstrom, Second Base - Field Culbreth, Third Base - Jim Reynolds