Texas at Cleveland

Final 10th
W: J. Wright (3-1) L: M. Kobayashi (2-2)
S: C. Wilson (10)
HR: TEX - I. Kinsler (6)   CLE - None

Error in outfield costs Indians dearly in 10th inning

CBSSports.com wire reports

CLEVELAND -- Ben Francisco sat motionless for minutes, staring at the floor -- a stark contrast to the music blaring over in the Texas Rangers' happy clubhouse.

Francisco misplayed a simple single to right field into a costly error in the 10th inning, enabling Jarrod Saltalamacchia to score from first base and give Texas a 2-1 win over the Cleveland Indians on Sunday.

"It's not a good feeling at all," Francisco said softly.

Saltalamacchia reached on a two-out walk on the 10th pitch he saw from Masahide Kobayashi (2-2).

"A great at-bat by Salty," Texas manager Ron Washington said. "He kept fighting, then we got a break."

Former Indians utility infielder Ramon Vazquez, who struck out as a pinch-hitter in the eighth against Rafael Betancourt, followed the walk with a routine single to right. Francisco knelt down to play it safely, but the ball bounced between his legs and rolled all the way to the wall. Saltalamacchia scored easily and Vazquez reached third on the error.

"I just got it in between hops," Francisco said. "It can't go through your legs. That's the last place it can go."

Jamey Wright (3-1) worked two scoreless innings for the win and C.J. Wilson pitched the 10th for his 10th save in 12 chances as Texas took two of three in the weekend series. Cleveland has lost eight of nine.

Texas outfielder Josh Hamilton was ejected for arguing a third strike in the sixth. He went 1-for-3, ending his streak of multihit games at eight, one shy of Rusty Greer's team record set in 2000.

Hamilton thought he checked his swing on a 2-2 pitch from Indians starter C.C. Sabathia, but third-base umpire Dale Scott ruled otherwise. Hamilton returned to the batter's box and showed where he had stopped the bat, then waved at Scott, who waved back -- as plate umpire Bill Hohn tossed the .333 hitter whose 53 RBI lead the majors.

"I probably shouldn't have put my bat back over the plate," Hamilton said. "I didn't go off or anything, though the wave probably didn't help. I didn't say a word.

"I said a little more than 'Why?' after I was tossed, though."

Sabathia gave up one run over seven innings -- Ian Kinsler's sixth homer to open the sixth that tied the score at 1. The 2007 AL Cy Young Award winner allowed seven hits, two walks and struck out five but again got little offensive support. Cleveland has scored two or fewer runs in eight of the left-hander's 11 starts.

"I'm tired of talking about it," manager Eric Wedge said, emphasizing that stranding 11 baserunners and hitting into three double plays was more responsible for the loss than Francisco's misplay. "We have to get tough, have the courage to stick with the game plan and get better. There's nothing more I can say."

Texas starter Doug Mathis gave up one run over six innings. The right-hander, filling a rotation spot while Kevin Millwood is on the disabled list with a strained groin, gave up seven hits and three walks, striking out one.

"The kid pitched his butt off," Washington said. "It was huge to beat C.C., who was dealing."

Francisco doubled with one out in the first, took third on a single to left by Travis Hafner and scored on a single to center by Victor Martinez, who was back after missing two games with a torn nail on the middle finger of his left hand.

The Indians loaded the bases with one out in the second, but didn't score as Francisco tapped into a force at home and Hafner popped out.

"If you don't get angry, there's something wrong," said Hafner, hitting only .217. "It's on the players. Nobody can give us a magic potion. We have to do it ourselves."

Poor baserunning by the Rangers twice helped Sabathia out of trouble.

In the third, Francisco caught a short fly ball hit by Kinsler. German Duran, on first after a single, was halfway to second and easily doubled off for an inning-ending double play.

The next inning, with Rangers on second and third, David Murphy hit a looper that was caught on the outfield grass by second baseman Asdrubal Cabrera. Milton Bradley was easily doubled off second to end that threat.

David Dellucci twice grounded into double plays for Cleveland. Martinez also grounded into one and was robbed of extra bases by Murphy's over-the-shoulder catch at the warning track in right with two on to end the seventh.

Martinez, homerless in 145 at-bats this year, slammed his batting helmet to the ground. Thursday, he got his foot stuck in a bucket that he kicked after lining out in Chicago.

Is the frustration getting to Cleveland's all-star catcher?

"If I say no, I'm going to be lying to you," Martinez said.


  • The Indians expect RHP Fausto Carmona to be sidelined four weeks with a strained left hip. He was hurt trying to cover first base Friday night.
  • Sabathia, 0-3 with a 13.50 ERA in his first four starts, has a 1.61 ERA over his last seven starts.
  • Hamilton is expected to play at Tropicana Field for the first time Monday night when the Rangers visit Tampa Bay. He was the No. 1 overall pick in 1999, but never played for the Rays.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Indians' outfielder Ben Francisco wants to go home after making a costly error in the 10th inning.  (AP)
Indians' outfielder Ben Francisco wants to go home after making a costly error in the 10th inning. (AP)

Players of the Game

I. Kinsler
AB 5
R 1
H 1
HR 1

C. Sabathia
IP 7.0
H 5
ER 1
BB 2
K 5

Related Video

Texas Rangers
Ian Kinsler, 2B5111002 .292
Michael Young, SS4010000 .281
Josh Hamilton, CF2000111 .333
    Brandon Boggs, LF1000000 .253
Milton Bradley, DH4020001 .333
David Murphy, LF-RF4000013 .291
Chris Shelton, 1B4010010 .241
Marlon Byrd, RF-CF3000101 .207
Jarrod Saltalamacchia, C3100121 .216
German Duran, 3B2010011 .193
   a- Ramon Vazquez, PH-3B2010010 .356
a-struck out for Duran in the 8th
2B - Milton Bradley (16, Sabathia)
HR - Ian Kinsler (6, Sabathia)
RBI - Ian Kinsler (28)
Team LOB - 5
DP - Kinsler-Young-Shelton, Kinsler-Young-Shelton, Kinsler-Young-Shelton
E - Jarrod Saltalamacchia (3, Throwing)
Texas Rangers
Doug Mathis 6711310 5.56
Frank Francisco 1100100 3.06
Jamey Wright (W,3-1) 2100120 3.23
C.J. Wilson (S,10) 1000120 4.57
IBB - Sizemore by Doug Mathis
WP - Doug Mathis (1), Jamey Wright (2)
Pitches-Strikes - Doug Mathis 108-69, Frank Francisco 18-8, Jamey Wright 26-15, C.J. Wilson 13-7
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Doug Mathis 9-6, Frank Francisco 1-2, Jamey Wright 1-2, C.J. Wilson 1-0
Batters Faced - Doug Mathis 26, Frank Francisco 5, Jamey Wright 7, C.J. Wilson 4
Cleveland Indians
Grady Sizemore, CF4020111 .262
Ben Francisco, RF5110006 .353
Travis Hafner, DH3010213 .217
Victor Martinez, C5011003 .297
Michael Aubrey, 1B3010102 .250
    Jamey Carroll, PR-3B0000000 .203
   a- Ryan Garko, PH0000100 .236
    Franklin Gutierrez, PR0000000 .235
Jhonny Peralta, SS5010025 .219
David Dellucci, LF3000113 .217
Casey Blake, 3B-1B4010000 .214
Asdrubal Cabrera, 2B3010000 .179
a-walked for Carroll in the 10th
2B - Grady Sizemore (10, Mathis), Ben Francisco (11, Mathis)
SH - Asdrubal Cabrera (4)
RBI - Victor Martinez (16)
SB - Grady Sizemore (11, 3rd base off Francisco/Saltalamacchia)
Team LOB - 11
Outfield Assists - Ben Francisco 1
DP - Francisco-Aubrey, A. Cabrera-Peralta, A. Cabrera-Peralta-Blake
E - Ben Francisco (1, Misplayed grounder)
Cleveland Indians
C.C. Sabathia 7511251 4.74
Rafael Betancourt 1000010 6.27
Masahide Kobayashi (L,2-2) 2210110 3.09
Pitches-Strikes - C.C. Sabathia 98-69, Rafael Betancourt 13-9, Masahide Kobayashi 33-20
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - C.C. Sabathia 8-6, Rafael Betancourt 1-1, Masahide Kobayashi 3-1
Batters Faced - C.C. Sabathia 26, Rafael Betancourt 3, Masahide Kobayashi 8
Game Information
Attendance - 35464
Game Time - 3:11
Temperature - 63
Umpires - Home - Bill Hohn, First Base - Damien Beal, Second Base - Dan Iassogna, Third Base - Dale Scott