• My Scores
  • NFL
  • MLB
  • NHL
  • NBA

Detroit at Cleveland

W: R. Perez (4-3) L: F. Dolsi (1-5)
HR: DET - M. Cabrera (35), M. Cabrera (36)   CLE - S. Choo (12), G. Sizemore (33), S. Choo (13)

Indians win with walk-off hit as Carmona, Sheffield brawl

CBSSports.com wire reports

CLEVELAND -- Gary Sheffield was still plenty angry -- though much more in control after the Detroit Tigers endured a ninth-inning loss.

Sheffield was one of two players from both teams ejected during a seventh-inning brawl before Jamey Carroll hit a game-winning single with one out in the ninth to give the Cleveland Indians a 6-5 win over the Tigers on Friday night.

Detroit's Miguel Cabrera hit two two-run homers to tie Carlos Quentin of the Chicago White Sox for the AL lead with 36.

Cabrera's second homer gave Detroit a 4-2 lead in the seventh. One out later, Indians starter Fausto Carmona hit Sheffield in the left elbow with a pitch. Detroit's designated hitter walked slowly to first base, carrying his bat, glaring at Carmona and exchanging words with the right-hander.

"Just because he's upset somebody else hit a home run, don't take it out on me," Sheffield said. "Anytime you do that, we're going to have problems, before the game, after the game, whatever you want to do."

Carmona threw to first on a pickoff attempt. Sheffield motioned, yelled, then charged at him.

"He gestured and I was like, 'Throw the ball to home plate,' "Sheffield said. "He called me out. He gestured come on, and I'm coming."

Both threw punches. Carmona got Sheffield in a headlock and landed more punches as both dugouts and bullpens emptied. No other punches appeared to be thrown -- though Indians catcher Victor Martinez and Detroit second baseman Placido Polanco also were ejected.

"I'm always going to protect my pitcher," said Martinez, who had advice for Sheffield: "Just shut your mouth and keep playing the game. You don't do anything after getting hit, then you do it at first base? Are you trying to get attention?

"I can't stand that."

Sheffield sat calmly at his locker as he spoke, but seemed most irritated at Martinez.

"His act is tired," Sheffield said of Martinez. "All that macho, throwing your equipment off. All this stuff. Trust me. He doesn't want any of this. Trust me. If he does, just let me know, man to man and I guarantee he wouldn't want any more."

Neither Carmona nor Indians manager Eric Wedge would discuss the incident.

"If I answer one question, there will be more," Wedge said. "I thought the umpires did a good job. We've got a couple more games with them and it is best not to talk at all."

On April 17, Carmona hit Sheffield with a pitch in a game that included five hit batters.

"Everybody in the league knows Fausto's ball moves so much," Martinez said. "Everybody knows Fausto pitches inside. You don't like that, well ... he's not trying to hit people."

Sheffield claimed Carmona has hit him three times this year.

"Three strikes and you're out," Sheffield said. "And if it's number four, it gets more violent. Trust me."

Kelly Shoppach was hit by a pitch from Freddy Dolsi (1-5) to start the ninth. Pinch-runner Josh Barfield went to third on pinch-hitter Ryan Garko's one-out single off Gary Glover.

Carroll hit the first pitch over the head of right fielder Magglio Ordonez. Barfield jogged home and Carroll was mobbed by teammates.

"It was better to be under that pile than the other one," Carroll said. "They got me with some jabs and I said, 'You guys should've used those earlier.' But they were fun jabs."

Cleveland's Shin-Soo Choo hit two homers, including a three-run shot in the eighth that tied it at 5. He has seven homers in his last 18 games and 13 overall after missing the first two months while recovering from elbow surgery.

It was Cabrera's 13th career multihomer game and fourth this season.

Perez (4-3) struck out the only batter he faced for the win.

Choo's two-out homer in the first put Cleveland ahead 1-0.

Cabrera made it 2-1 in the fourth. Curtis Granderson snapped an 0-for-15 streak with a double. Two outs later, Cabrera hit a 1-1 pitch from Carmona 428 feet into the stands in left.

After Choo's homer, Tigers starter Armando Galarraga retired 14 of the next 15 until Grady Sizemore hit his 33rd homer in the sixth to tie it at 2.

Only Travis Hafner, hit in the foot with a pitch with one out in the second, reached base during that span. It was the 93rd time a Cleveland batter was hit, breaking the AL record set by Toronto in 1996. Shoppach's plunking got the Indians within six of the major league record of 100 by the Houston Astros in 1997.

Ordonez singled to start the Tigers' seventh and Cabrera followed with a 424-foot shot to center for a 4-2 lead.

Galarraga remained winless in five starts, allowing four hits and three runs over 7 2-3 innings.


  • Hitting coach Lloyd McClendon managed the Tigers in place of Jim Leyland, who began serving a three-game suspension. "I know it was probably tough on skip to have to sit and watch this," McClendon said.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Fausto Carmona wails on Gary Sheffield as fireworks erupt for two teams out of the playoff hunt.  (AP)
Fausto Carmona wails on Gary Sheffield as fireworks erupt for two teams out of the playoff hunt. (AP)

Players of the Game

S. Choo
AB 4
R 2
H 3
HR 2

M. Cabrera
AB 4
R 2
H 2
HR 2

Related Video

Detroit Tigers
Curtis Granderson, CF4110020 .290
Placido Polanco, 2B3000011 .306
    Edgar Renteria, SS1000010 .269
Magglio Ordonez, RF4110011 .326
Miguel Cabrera, 1B4224000 .298
Matt Joyce, LF4010010 .267
Gary Sheffield, DH2000001 .220
    Jeff Larish, PR-DH0000000 .226
Brandon Inge, 3B3000021 .211
Ramon Santiago, SS-2B3110000 .280
Dusty Ryan, C2001020 .364
2B - Curtis Granderson (25, Carmona)
3B - Ramon Santiago (2, Mujica)
HR - Miguel Cabrera 2 (36, Carmona, Carmona)
SF - Dusty Ryan (1)
RBI - Miguel Cabrera 4 (125), Dusty Ryan (6)
2-OUT RBI - Miguel Cabrera 2 (48)
CS - Jeff Larish (2, 2nd base by Mujica/Shoppach)
Detroit Tigers
Armando Galarraga 7.2433052 3.58
Casey Fossum (BS,1)0122101 5.40
Freddy Dolsi (L,1-5) 0.1011000 4.09
Bobby Seay 0.1000010 4.03
Gary Glover0200000 5.55
HBP - Hafner (by Armando Galarraga), Shoppach (by Freddy Dolsi)
Pitches-Strikes - Armando Galarraga 110-67, Casey Fossum 6-1, Freddy Dolsi 3-1, Bobby Seay 3-3, Gary Glover 2-2
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Armando Galarraga 10-8
Batters Faced - Armando Galarraga 28, Casey Fossum 2, Freddy Dolsi 2, Bobby Seay 1, Gary Glover 2
Cleveland Indians
Grady Sizemore, CF4221000 .274
David Dellucci, LF3000010 .239
   a- Ben Francisco, PH-LF0100100 .267
Shin-Soo Choo, RF4234000 .307
Jhonny Peralta, SS4000021 .274
Victor Martinez, C2000000 .273
    Kelly Shoppach, C1000010 .269
    Josh Barfield, PR0100000 .077
Travis Hafner, DH3000011 .211
Michael Aubrey, 1B3000001 .200
   b- Ryan Garko, PH1010000 .259
Andy Marte, 3B2000001 .217
   c- Jamey Carroll, PH-3B2011000 .274
Asdrubal Cabrera, 2B3000010 .245
a-walked for Dellucci in the 8th
b-singled for Aubrey in the 9th
c-grounded out for Marte in the 8th
2B - Grady Sizemore (37, Galarraga)
HR - Grady Sizemore (33, Galarraga), Shin-Soo Choo 2 (13, Galarraga, Fossum)
RBI - Grady Sizemore (89), Shin-Soo Choo 4 (57), Jamey Carroll (31)
2-OUT RBI - Shin-Soo Choo 4 (25)
Team LOB - 4
DP - Marte-A. Cabrera-Aubrey, Shoppach-A. Cabrera
Cleveland Indians
Fausto Carmona 6.1544052 5.19
Edward Mujica 1.2111030 6.94
Rafael Betancourt 0.2000010 5.16
Rafael Perez (W,4-3) 0.1000010 3.15
HBP - Sheffield (by Fausto Carmona)
Pitches-Strikes - Fausto Carmona 82-54, Edward Mujica 18-14, Rafael Betancourt 9-7, Rafael Perez 8-6
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Fausto Carmona 9-4, Rafael Betancourt 1-0
Batters Faced - Fausto Carmona 24, Edward Mujica 5, Rafael Betancourt 2, Rafael Perez 1
Game Information
Attendance - 33733
Game Time - 2:52
Temperature - 70
Umpires - Home - Phil Cuzzi, First Base - Jim Wolf, Second Base - Jerry Layne, Third Base - Brian Knight