Cincinnati at Florida

Final 14th
W: B. Badenhop (2-1) L: D. Herrera (0-1)
HR: CIN - None   FLA - H. Ramirez (3)

Reds' throwing error in 14th inning keeps Marlins in first wire reports

MIAMI -- Regis Philbin's ceremonial first pitch bounced in front of the plate. The game ended 4½ hours later with the same kind of throw by Cincinnati shortstop Paul Janish.

His error on a double-play relay sent home the winning run in the 14th inning, and the Florida Marlins retained the NL East lead by beating Cincinnati 3-2 on Monday night.

With runners at first and second and no outs, Jorge Cantu grounded to first baseman Joey Votto, who threw to second for a forceout. Janish's relay bounced past pitcher Daniel Herrera, who was covering first, and Ronny Paulino scored without a play.

"It was my fault being late getting over there," Herrera said. "It was a tough double play to turn. I should have just knocked it down instead of trying to make the play."

Hanley Ramirez hit his third home run for the Marlins, who ended a three-game losing streak. The shortstop also made a leaping catch of Brandon Phillips' line drive with two on to end the eighth and keep the score 2-2.

The Marlins, who have been in first place since opening day, lead Philadelphia by a half-game. Florida won despite leaving the bases loaded in the sixth, ninth and 12th innings.

"If you're going to play a ballgame that long, you definitely want to make sure you do everything you can to win it," Marlins second baseman Dan Uggla said. "You don't want to play 14 innings and come out on the other end of it."

Paulino walked against Herrera (0-1) to start the 14th, and Ramirez singled. Then came the error by Janish.

"That was the toughest loss so far," Reds manager Dusty Baker said. "You hate to lose on a mistake and in extra innings."

Janish entered in the 11th when Alex Gonzalez strained his left oblique. Gonzalez is to be examined in Cincinnati on Tuesday.

Philbin, a Marlins fan, started the long night by bouncing the first pitch to Florida's Cody Ross.

"I was disappointed in my pitch," Philbin said jokingly. "I wanted to knock Ross down."

Florida's Josh Johnson and Cincinnati's Aaron Harang then settled into a pitcher's duel, and both left with the game tied at 2. Johnson went 7 1/3 innings, and Harang left for a pinch hitter after seven innings.

The Marlins extended a club-record streak of 17 consecutive games without a victory by a starting pitcher. During that span the starters are 0-6.

Cincinnati has scored 15 runs in Harang's six starts.

The loss ended the Reds' streak of four consecutive road series won to start the season. The best they can do in Miami is 1-1.

The Marlins loaded the bases in the ninth, but Nick Masset retired Cantu on a fly to end the threat. Cincinnati's Mike Lincoln loaded the bases in the 12th before Ross grounded out on a 3-2 pitch.

The Reds left two on in the 11th against Renyel Pinto. Burke Badenhop (2-1) allowed two hits in three innings.

"You just want it to be over, be over," Badenhop said. "Finally it was."

When Ramirez hit a solo home run with two outs in the first, the ball was caught by a fan sitting in a section with only two other spectators. The crowd of 10,824 was the smallest for a Marlins home game since last May 20, and by the end only a couple thousand fans remained.

Ramirez has four home runs in 20 career at-bats against Harang.

The Marlins had gone hitless in 21 consecutive at-bats with runners in scoring position before Jeremy Hermida hit a two-out RBI single in the sixth for a 2-0 lead.

The Reds tied it in the seventh, when Phillips, Jay Bruce and Ramon Hernandez hit back-to-back singles to start the inning. Hernandez's hit drove in Cincinnati's first run, and another scored on a double play.


  • Marlins LHP Andrew Miller (oblique strain) threw a bullpen session and will make a rehabilitation start Wednesday for Class A Jupiter. If it goes well, he'll likely make a start for Double-A Jacksonville next week.
  • Florida RHP Scott Proctor (elbow) also threw a bullpen session.
  • Gem of the night: 2B Phillips made a backhanded stop of a grounder and used his glove to shovel the ball to Gonzalez for a forceout in the third inning.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Florida's welcoming committee pounces on Ronny Paulino after he lumbers home in the 14th inning.  (AP)
Florida's welcoming committee pounces on Ronny Paulino after he lumbers home in the 14th inning. (AP)

Players of the Game

H. Ramirez
AB 5
R 2
H 3
HR 1

A. Harang
IP 7.0
H 7
ER 2
BB 3
K 9

Related Video

Cincinnati Reds
Willy Taveras, CF6010020 .262
Chris Dickerson, LF6020020 .218
Joey Votto, 1B5020112 .365
Brandon Phillips, 2B6110016 .205
Jay Bruce, RF4110203 .253
Ramon Hernandez, C5011012 .257
Adam Rosales, 3B6010013 .333
Alex Gonzalez, SS4000002 .176
    Paul Janish, SS2020000 .412
Aaron Harang, P2000011 .000
   a- Laynce Nix, PH1000000 .323
    David Weathers, P0000000 .000
    Arthur Rhodes, P0000000 .000
    Nick Masset, P0000000 .000
   b- Jerry Hairston Jr., PH1000000 .156
    Jared Burton, P0000000 .000
   c- Darnell McDonald, PH1000001 .250
    Mike Lincoln, P0000000 .000
   d- Ryan Hanigan, PH1000001 .389
    Danny Herrera, P0000000 .000
a-fouled out for Harang in the 8th
b-lined out for Masset in the 10th
c-grounded into a double play for Burton in the 12th
d-lined out for Lincoln in the 14th
SH - Ramon Hernandez (2)
RBI - Ramon Hernandez (8)
CS - Chris Dickerson (2, 2nd base by Johnson/Baker)
Team LOB - 10
E - Paul Janish (1, Throwing)
Cincinnati Reds
Aaron Harang 7722391 3.00
David Weathers 1000010 0.00
Arthur Rhodes 0.2200020 0.00
Nick Masset 0.1000100 1.80
Jared Burton 2100020 6.23
Mike Lincoln 2300110 12.19
Danny Herrera (L,0-1) 0.1110100 3.12
IBB - Maybin by Aaron Harang, Uggla by Mike Lincoln
Pitches-Strikes - Aaron Harang 117-70, David Weathers 12-7, Arthur Rhodes 16-11, Nick Masset 7-2, Jared Burton 21-15, Mike Lincoln 35-22, Danny Herrera 9-4
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Aaron Harang 7-5, Jared Burton 1-2, Mike Lincoln 2-2, Danny Herrera 1-0
Batters Faced - Aaron Harang 31, David Weathers 3, Arthur Rhodes 4, Nick Masset 2, Jared Burton 6, Mike Lincoln 9, Danny Herrera 3
Florida Marlins
Emilio Bonifacio, 3B7030010 .268
John Baker, C4010021 .299
   a- Ronny Paulino, PH-C2100112 .297
Hanley Ramirez, SS5231211 .299
Jorge Cantu, 1B7010017 .317
Dan Uggla, 2B4000210 .202
Jeremy Hermida, LF4011020 .235
    Brett Carroll, LF2010000 .125
Cody Ross, RF6020014 .229
Cameron Maybin, CF3000132 .208
    Matt Lindstrom, P0000000 .000
    Renyel Pinto, P0000000 .000
   b- Ross Gload, PH1000000 .200
    Burke Badenhop, P1000000 .000
Josh Johnson, P3000023 .071
    Dan Meyer, P0000000 .000
    Leo Nunez, P0000000 .000
   c- Wes Helms, PH1010000 .281
    Alfredo Amezaga, PR-CF2010000 .244
a-struck out for Baker in the 9th
b-grounded out for Pinto in the 11th
c-singled for Nunez in the 9th
2B - Jorge Cantu (6, Lincoln), Cody Ross (4, Harang)
HR - Hanley Ramirez (3, Harang)
RBI - Hanley Ramirez (13), Jeremy Hermida (11)
2-OUT RBI - Hanley Ramirez (7), Jeremy Hermida (6)
CS - Emilio Bonifacio (1, 2nd base by Lincoln/Hernandez)
PK - Alfredo Amezaga (1, Burton)
Team LOB - 15
DP - Uggla-H. Ramirez-Cantu, H. Ramirez-Cantu
E - Hanley Ramirez (1, Misplayed grounder)
Florida Marlins
Josh Johnson 7.1822060 2.57
Dan Meyer 0.1000000 2.61
Leo Nunez 1.1000100 2.84
Matt Lindstrom 1000010 7.20
Renyel Pinto 1100110 1.54
Burke Badenhop (W,2-1) 3200110 5.14
Pitches-Strikes - Josh Johnson 103-75, Dan Meyer 2-1, Leo Nunez 22-13, Matt Lindstrom 12-9, Renyel Pinto 20-12, Burke Badenhop 42-25
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Josh Johnson 7-8, Leo Nunez 1-3, Matt Lindstrom 1-1, Renyel Pinto 1-1, Burke Badenhop 6-1
Batters Faced - Josh Johnson 29, Dan Meyer 1, Leo Nunez 5, Matt Lindstrom 3, Renyel Pinto 5, Burke Badenhop 11
Game Information
Attendance - 10825
Game Time - 4:31
Temperature - 78
Umpires - Home - Chuck Meriwether, First Base - Eric Cooper, Second Base - Mike Reilly, Third Base - Laz Diaz