Cleveland at Kansas City

Final 10th
W: J. Asencio (1-1) L: G. Holland (0-1)
S: C. Perez (2)
HR: CLE - C. Kotchman (1),J. Kipnis (2)   KC - Y. Betancourt (1)

Tempers flare as Indians edge Royals wire reports

KANSAS CITY, Mo. -- Shin-Soo Choo sat at his locker in the Indians clubhouse, the bruise on the outside of his right knee just larger than a baseball and turning every shade of red and blue imaginable.

"It's nothing," he said with a smile.

Driving in the winning runs must have made the pain go away in a hurry.

After getting hit by a pitch early in the game, Choo delivered a two-out double in the 10th inning Saturday night that sent Cleveland to an 11-9 victory over Kansas City -- despite blowing a seven-run lead in a testy affair marked by three ejections and a pair of bench-clearings.

"What a crazy kind of emotional game," said Indians manager Manny Acta, who was among those thrown out during an eventful third inning. "Just glad we came out on top."

More on Indians-Royals
Related links
More MLB coverage

Light-hitting Yuniesky Betancourt helped force extras when he homered in the eighth inning for the Royals, completing their bit-by-bit comeback from a 9-2 hole.

With two outs in the 10th, Choo pounded a pitch from Greg Holland (0-1) to center field that Jarrod Dyson tracked down at the wall. He appeared to have the ball in his glove before it popped loose, and Jason Kipnis and Michael Brantley came around with the go-ahead runs.

Jairo Asencio (1-1) earned his first major-league win by pitching a clean ninth inning, while Chris Perez set the Royals down in order for his second save of the season.

"Always you try to win games," Choo said, "but especially tonight."

Choo was plunked by Jonathan Sanchez in the third inning, sending both teams streaming onto the infield. Sanchez and Choo have some history: The left-hander broke Choo's thumb last season by hitting him with a pitch. Choo wound up on the disabled list for nearly two months.

"I know it's not on purpose. The catcher set up inside," Choo said. "But I still have the memory from last year. Maybe I was a little sensitive."

Tempers were still simmering in the bottom half when Cleveland starter Jeanmar Gomez hit Mike Moustakas leading off the inning. Plate umpire Gary Darling immediately tossed Gomez along with Acta and third baseman Jack Hannahan, who rushed into the middle of the fray.

Royals manager Ned Yost was also in the middle of the scrap, losing his hat as he got into Hannahan's face between the mound and first base.

"I don't really know what they were thinking," Yost said. "They had to go to their pen early. We had to go to our pen early. It's one of those things."

Carlos Santana, Jose Lopez and Kipnis each drove in a pair of runs for the Indians, who have come alive after a miserable five-game stretch to start the season. They scored seven times in the first inning while taking the series opener, and piled up 14 hits on Saturday night.

Things soured for Sanchez early in the third, when Brantley ripped a one-out triple to the wall. Asdrubal Cabrera followed with an RBI single, and Sanchez plunked Choo on the right knee.

Choo started jawing at Sanchez as he headed toward first base, and the Royals starter dished the trash talk right back at him. Hannahan rushed at Sanchez before the umpires and coaches from both teams intervened, restoring order before tempers boiled over.

"I hit him twice. I have nothing against him," Sanchez said. "I just wanted to come in with those pitches. But if you're going to miss, miss in. I'm not going to miss over the plate."

The Indians immediately pounced on the rattled Sanchez, piling up five runs before he was finally lifted from his Kauffman Stadium debut after 2 2/3 innings.

The Royals got a pair of runs back in the third, but Cleveland scored another run in the fourth and added three more in the fifth -- Kotchman went deep leading off the inning, and Kipnis followed a base hit by Jason Donald with his own homer to make it 9-2.

Then Royals' rally started in the most innocuous of ways.

Betancourt singled to lead off the fifth inning, and an RBI double by Moustakas and an RBI by Escobar on a double-play groundout made it 9-4.

Kansas City added two more runs in the sixth. Billy Butler ripped a one-out double to left field, and an error on Kipnis at second base allowed Betancourt to reach first and keep the inning alive for Moustakas, whose RBI double pulled the Royals within three runs.

Hosmer's run-scoring double and Butler's RBI single made it a one-run game in the seventh, and Betancourt finally tied it on a 2-2 pitch from Vinnie Pestano leading off the eighth.

Choo made all the hard work coming back moot.

"We were down seven and you want to hold the fort, so you can chip your way back into," Yost said. "We did tonight, but we just couldn't get that one extra run to close the game out."


  • Indians RHP Ubaldo Jimenez pitches the series finale against Royals RHP Luis Mendoza.
  • The Indians have homered each of their first seven games, the fourth-best season-opening stretch since at least 1918.
  • Royals starters allowed seven runs in 34 innings over their first six games. They've allowed 12 in 6 2/3 innings against Cleveland.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
The Indians lose three to ejections in a tense game, but they find a way to prevail in 10 innings.  (Getty Images)
The Indians lose three to ejections in a tense game, but they find a way to prevail in 10 innings. (Getty Images)

Related Video

Cleveland Indians
Michael Brantley, CF6210006 .143
Asdrubal Cabrera, SS6231002 .294
Shin-Soo Choo, RF5112011 .222
Carlos Santana, C4122210 .250
Shelley Duncan, LF3110111 .304
    Aaron Cunningham, LF2000012 .111
Jose Lopez, DH5012013 .222
Casey Kotchman, 1B3111202 .143
Jason Donald, 2B-3B4121003 .200
Jack Hannahan, 3B1000110 .300
    Jason Kipnis, 2B3222001 .179
2B - Asdrubal Cabrera (3, Collins), Shin-Soo Choo (1, Holland), Carlos Santana (1, Sanchez), Jose Lopez (1, Sanchez)
3B - Michael Brantley (1, Sanchez)
HR - Casey Kotchman (1, Collins), Jason Kipnis (2, Collins)
SF - Jason Donald (1)
RBI - Asdrubal Cabrera (3), Shin-Soo Choo 2 (4), Carlos Santana 2 (6), Jose Lopez 2 (3), Casey Kotchman (2), Jason Donald (1), Jason Kipnis 2 (6)
2-OUT RBI - Shin-Soo Choo 2 (2)
SB - Casey Kotchman (1, 2nd base off Mijares/Quintero)
CS - Asdrubal Cabrera (1, 2nd base by Sanchez/Quintero)
Team LOB - 9
DP - Donald-A. Cabrera-Kotchman, Kipnis-A. Cabrera-Kotchman
E - Jason Donald (1, Throwing), Jack Hannahan (3, Misplayed grounder)
Cleveland Indians
Jeanmar Gomez 2011000 2.25
Josh Tomlin 3.2654000 8.31
Rafael Perez0100000 6.00
Joe Smith (H,2) 1111000 3.60
Tony Sipp (H,2) 0.1211000 19.29
Vinnie Pestano (BS,1) 1111011 3.86
Jairo Asencio (W,1-1) 1000120 3.86
Chris Perez (S,2) 1000010 7.36
HBP - Moustakas (by Jeanmar Gomez)
WP - Josh Tomlin (1)
Pitches-Strikes - Jeanmar Gomez 20-14, Josh Tomlin 62-43, Rafael Perez 5-3, Joe Smith 11-8, Tony Sipp 17-10, Vinnie Pestano 15-11, Jairo Asencio 11-7, Chris Perez 14-10
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Jeanmar Gomez 5-1, Josh Tomlin 5-6, Joe Smith 3-0, Tony Sipp 1-0, Vinnie Pestano 1-1, Chris Perez 1-1
Batters Faced - Jeanmar Gomez 7, Josh Tomlin 17, Rafael Perez 1, Joe Smith 4, Tony Sipp 3, Vinnie Pestano 4, Jairo Asencio 3, Chris Perez 3
Kansas City Royals
Jarrod Dyson, CF3111100 .250
Jeff Francoeur, RF5110012 .333
Eric Hosmer, 1B5111010 .206
Billy Butler, DH5122000 .303
Alex Gordon, LF5000012 .133
Yuniesky Betancourt, 2B4221001 .389
    Chris Getz, 2B1000000 .250
Mike Moustakas, 3B3222000 .231
Humberto Quintero, C4010012 .333
Alcides Escobar, SS4111000 .258
2B - Jarrod Dyson (1, Smith), Eric Hosmer (1, Sipp), Billy Butler (5, Tomlin), Mike Moustakas 2 (4, Tomlin, R. Perez)
3B - Alcides Escobar (1, Tomlin)
HR - Yuniesky Betancourt (1, Pestano)
SF - Jarrod Dyson (1)
RBI - Jarrod Dyson (1), Eric Hosmer (6), Billy Butler 2 (7), Yuniesky Betancourt (1), Mike Moustakas 2 (5), Alcides Escobar (1)
2-OUT RBI - Eric Hosmer (3), Billy Butler (2), Mike Moustakas (2)
CS - Jarrod Dyson (1, 2nd base by Asencio/Santana)
Team LOB - 3
Kansas City Royals
Jonathan Sanchez 2.2655410 8.22
Tim Collins 2.1544032 5.68
Kelvin Herrera 1000010 4.15
Jose Mijares 1000100 0.00
Aaron Crow 1000000 6.75
Jonathan Broxton 1000000 2.45
Greg Holland (L,0-1) 1322110 7.71
IBB - Duncan by Jonathan Sanchez, Santana by Greg Holland
HBP - Choo (by Jonathan Sanchez)
Pitches-Strikes - Jonathan Sanchez 75-38, Tim Collins 38-27, Kelvin Herrera 11-9, Jose Mijares 21-12, Aaron Crow 10-7, Jonathan Broxton 10-8, Greg Holland 27-14
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Jonathan Sanchez 2-4, Tim Collins 3-1, Jose Mijares 1-2, Aaron Crow 1-2, Jonathan Broxton 3-0, Greg Holland 1-1
Batters Faced - Jonathan Sanchez 18, Tim Collins 12, Kelvin Herrera 3, Jose Mijares 4, Aaron Crow 3, Jonathan Broxton 3, Greg Holland 7
Game Information
Attendance - 21788
Game Time - 3:44
Temperature - 72
Umpires - Home - Gary Darling, First Base - Jerry Meals, Second Base - Lance Barrett, Third Base - Paul Emmel