• My Scores
  • NFL
  • MLB
  • NHL
  • NBA

Pittsburgh at Chicago

Chi. Cubs
W: P. Maholm (7-10) L: C. Zambrano (14-6)
S: S. Torres (2)
HR: PIT - None   CHC - None

Pirates 5, Cubs 4

CBS SportsLine.com wire reports

CHICAGO -- Carlos Zambrano has been the ace of the Chicago Cubs' beleagured pitching staff all season. Now his back is paying the price.

Xavier Nady's three-run double capped a four-run first inning against an injured Zambrano and the Pittsburgh Pirates held off the Chicago Cubs 5-4 on Monday.

Zambrano left the game in the second with lower back stiffness and will get an MRI Tuesday. The 25-year-old has had problems with his lower back in the past but this is the first such instance this season.

"I couldn't throw today," said Zambrano. "I couldn't bend today, and as a pitcher, you have to bend as much as possible to get the strike zone and to get your command. If you throw straight, you let your pitches go high and that's what happened today."

It was the shortest outing of his career. After a meeting with the trainer on the mound, Zambrano (14-6) left the game trailing 5-0. He gave up four earned runs, four hits and four walks and lost for the first time in five starts. Zambrano hasn't missed a start and has thrown 193 innings this season and has been the only constant in the rotation.

Zambrano said he requested the MRI but he didn't feel anything more serious that muscle tightness and spasms. If he were to go on the DL, he would join teammates Mark Prior and Kerry Wood, who have missed most of the season with injuries.

"There are certain things that we look for," Cubs trainer Mark O'Neal said. "It seems like it's all muscular. He's not having some of the other symptoms you would be worried about with significant disc injuries."

The Pirates have won four straight against the Cubs in a battle of the NL's two worst teams, and are just a half-game back of the Cubs for fifth place in the NL Central.

After Pittsburgh reliever Salomon Torres got the last out in the ninth, he jumped off the mound in celebration. Other Pirates celebrated the win.

"I don't want to finish in last place, we don't want to finish in last place," Cubs first baseman Derrek Lee said. "But those are bad goals to have. For them to be getting excited about getting out of last place, I don't know how much difference it really makes. But I don't want to finish in last place."

Paul Maholm (7-10) gave up four runs, three hits and three walks in five innings, retiring 10 of the last 11 hitters he faced. He has won three straight decisions.

"We want to get out of the cellar," Maholm said.

John Grabow, Damaso Marte and Matt Capps kept the Cubs scoreless in the next three innings and Torres got his second save in the last three days. He previously hadn't picked up a save since Oct. 2, 2005. The Pirates bullpen has allowed just one run over its last four games, a span of 12 innings.

"That group of guys was terrific, to keep them from scoring for the remainder of the game," Pirates manager Jim Tracy said.

Zambrano struggled with his control from the beginning, walking the first two batters before missing a tag on Freddy Sanchez after his bunt. Jason Bay followed with an RBI bloop single and Nady cleared the bases with a double to right-center.

"Everyone knew he wans't throwing as hard as he normally does," Bay said. "We thought he wasn't as loose as he usually was and he was kind of laboring through that first inning."

Zambrano walked Maholm on five pitches to start the second and gave up a single to Chris Duffy. One out later, Sanchez grounded to Ronny Cedeno and his throw home was wide, allowing Maholm to score.

"I feel like my back locked," Zambrano said.

Ryan Theriot had a three-run double in the second as the Cubs cut the lead to one. Maholm loaded the bases when he hit rookie Scott Moore in his first major league at-bat. Juan Pierre had an RBI single to start the four-run inning.

No one scored after that as the bullpens took over.


The Cubs activated RHP Carlos Marmol from the 15-day DL and recalled INF Moore from Triple-A. Marmol, who had been starting before going down with shoulder fatigue, will be used out of the bullpen. ... Cubs C Michael Barrett was still in the hospital Monday morning for a follow-up procedure after having surgery Saturday night to stop bleeding in his scrotum. He is on the 15-day DL after getting hit in the groin area by a foul tip on Saturday. ... Pirates SS Jack Wilson missed his 10th straight game with symptoms from an inner ear infection.

Copyright 2016 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Players of the Game

P. Maholm
IP 5.0
H 3
ER 4
BB 3
K 4

X. Nady
AB 4
R 0
H 2
HR 0

Related Video

Pittsburgh Pirates
Chris Duffy, CF3120200 .213
Joe Randa, 3B-1B3110113 .268
Freddy Sanchez, SS5120001 .346
Jason Bay, LF5111012 .287
Xavier Nady, RF4023100 .289
Ryan Doumit, 1B2000104 .198
    John Grabow, P0000000 .000
    Damaso Marte, P0000000 .000
    Matt Capps, P0000000 .000
   a- Jeromy Burnitz, PH1000000 .235
    Salomon Torres, P0000000 .250
Ronny Paulino, C4010122 .316
Jose Castillo, 2B4000014 .270
Paul Maholm, P2100123 .120
    Jose Bautista, 3B1000010 .248
a-grounded out for Capps in the 9th
2B - Xavier Nady (24, Zambrano)
SH - Joe Randa (2)
RBI - Jason Bay (94), Xavier Nady 3 (55)
Team LOB - 11
DP - F. Sanchez-Doumit
E - Joe Randa (5, )
Pittsburgh Pirates
Paul Maholm (W,7-10) 5344340 4.91
John Grabow (H,9) 1000100 3.86
Damaso Marte (H,13) 0.1100010 4.07
Matt Capps (H,10) 1.2100000 3.33
Salomon Torres (S,2) 1100010 3.56
HBP - Moore (by Paul Maholm)
Pitches-Strikes - Paul Maholm 105-64, John Grabow 21-13, Damaso Marte 5-5, Matt Capps 25-19, Salomon Torres 10-8
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Paul Maholm 6-5, John Grabow 2-1, Matt Capps 2-3, Salomon Torres 1-1
Batters Faced - Paul Maholm 22, John Grabow 4, Damaso Marte 2, Matt Capps 6, Salomon Torres 4
Chicago Cubs
Juan Pierre, CF3121201 .288
Ryan Theriot, 2B3013002 .323
   a- John Mabry, PH1000011 .217
Aramis Ramirez, 3B4000013 .284
Derrek Lee, 1B4000012 .280
Matt Murton, LF4010000 .290
Angel Pagan, RF2100201 .269
Henry Blanco, C4110002 .248
Ronny Cedeno, SS3000013 .240
   b- Jacque Jones, PH1010000 .289
Carlos Zambrano, P0000000 .143
    Roberto Novoa, P0000000 .200
   c- Scott Moore, PH0100000 .000
    Glendon Rusch, P1000010 .200
    David Aardsma, P0000000 .000
   d- Freddie Bynum, PH1000010 .248
    Bob Howry, P00000001.000
    Michael Wuertz, P0000000 .000
   e- Buck Coats, PH1000001 .000
a-struck out for Theriot in the 9th
b-singled for Cedeno in the 9th
c-hit by pitch for Novoa in the 4th
d-struck out for Aardsma in the 7th
e-hit into fielder's choice-bunting for Wuertz in the 9th
2B - Ryan Theriot (7, Maholm)
SH - Ryan Theriot (4)
RBI - Juan Pierre (32), Ryan Theriot 3 (9)
2-OUT RBI - Juan Pierre (18), Ryan Theriot 3 (4)
SB - Juan Pierre 2 (47, 3rd base off Maholm/Paulino, 3rd base off Maholm/Paulino)
Team LOB - 7
DP - Theriot-Cedeno-Lee, Ramirez-Theriot-Lee
E - Ronny Cedeno (23, )
Chicago Cubs
Carlos Zambrano (L,14-6) 1.1454410 3.50
Roberto Novoa 0.2000000 4.46
Glendon Rusch 2200210 7.46
David Aardsma 3200150 4.57
Bob Howry 1100000 3.46
Michael Wuertz 1000010 3.14
IBB - Nady by Glendon Rusch
HBP - Doumit (by Glendon Rusch)
Pitches-Strikes - Carlos Zambrano 43-23, Roberto Novoa 2-1, Glendon Rusch 34-17, David Aardsma 49-31, Bob Howry 13-10, Michael Wuertz 12-9
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Carlos Zambrano 3-0, Roberto Novoa 1-0, Glendon Rusch 2-3, David Aardsma 2-2, Bob Howry 1-2, Michael Wuertz 2-0
Batters Faced - Carlos Zambrano 12, Roberto Novoa 1, Glendon Rusch 11, David Aardsma 12, Bob Howry 4, Michael Wuertz 3
Game Information
Attendance - 37994
Game Time - 3:03
Temperature - 67
Umpires - Home - Alfonso Marquez, First Base - Larry Young, Second Base - Tom Hallion, Third Base - James Hoye