Pittsburgh at Atlanta

Final 12th
W: F. Osoria (1-0) L: B. Boyer (0-1)
HR: PIT - X. Nady (1), N. McLouth (1), X. Nady (2)   ATL - B. McCann (1), J. Francoeur (1)

Pirates blow lead to Braves in ninth but Nady saves day in 12th

CBSSports.com wire reports

ATLANTA -- Tom Glavine's homecoming was an afterthought by the time a routine fly ball finally ended a game that was anything but routine.

"That," Braves catcher Brian McCann said, "was probably the craziest game I've ever been a part of."

Xavier Nady hit two home runs -- including a three-run shot in the 12th inning -- and the Pittsburgh Pirates overcame a horrific ninth and another potential collapse for a 12-11 victory Monday night, which ruined Atlanta's home opener.

The Braves took advantage of four walks and a huge defensive blunder to erase the Pirates' 9-4 lead. But Nady, who led off the eighth with a home run, lined a 2-0 pitch from Blaine Boyer (0-1) into the right-field seats with two outs and two aboard in the 12th.

Franquelis Osoria (1-0) pitched three innings for his first major league victory. It was in doubt right to the end: Jeff Francoeur hit a home run, Matt Diaz had an RBI single and the Braves had the potential tying run on base when Corky Miller flied out to center, ending the 4-hour, 28-minute marathon.

"I'm glad for him to get his first win," Nady said. "But I'm sure that wasn't the way it was drawn up."

Glavine returned to Atlanta after five years with the New York Mets. He left after the fifth, having surrendered one earned run, and turned over a 4-2 lead to the bullpen. The relievers were downright awful, giving up 10 runs (nine earned) in seven innings.

Atlanta's defense wasn't better, making three costly errors.

Most of the crowd of 45,269 headed for home on a cool night when Pittsburgh went ahead with a four-run eighth off Manny Acosta. They missed quite a finish.

The Pirates had a five-run cushion with Atlanta down to its last three outs, but no lead is safe for a franchise that hasn't had a winning season since 1992.

Damaso Marte walked two, then closer Matt Capps walked two more, which brought home a run. Chipper Jones followed with a two-run single, making it 9-7, then it looked as though Pittsburgh would escape. Mark Teixeira popped out, slapping his helmet in disgust.

McCann, who hit a home run in the fourth, followed with a soft fly to left.

Game over?

Not so fast.

Jason Bay inexplicably ran by the ball, apparently thinking Nate McLouth had called him off. It fell between them, allowing two runs to score.

"It was one of those things," McLouth said. "He thought I was going to get it, and I thought he was going to get it."

John Russell watched stoically from the Pirates dugout in his first game as a big league manager, perhaps wondering what he had gotten himself into. At the end, though, his record was 1-0.

Glavine was the big story at the start of the night, returning to the team where he spent the first 16 seasons of his 303-win career. He had long since showered and dressed by the time it was over.

"I was a little anxious in the first inning," Glavine said. "After that, I felt pretty comfortable."

The 42-year-old left-hander has clearly lost a bit of the stuff that carried him to five 20-win seasons and two NL Cy Young Awards during his first stint with the Braves. Working from behind to all but five of 22 hitters, Glavine surrendered seven hits, walked two and threw 97 pitches -- only 52 for strikes.

But at least it was better than his last outing with the Mets. Glavine was charged with seven runs and got only one out in the second-shortest start of his career, a loss to the Florida Marlins on the final day of the season to complete New York's historic collapse in the NL East race.

With the game tied at 4, the Pirates teed off on Acosta in the eighth. He gave up the home run to Nady after getting two quick strikes. McLouth lined another one over the right-field wall in nearly the same spot for a three-run homer, equaling his career best with four RBI on the night.

Yunel Escobar, taking over a shortstop for Edgar Renteria, went 3-for-4 with three RBI but made a costly throwing error that allowed the tying run to score in the seventh.

After beginning the season with a ninth-inning loss in the opener for Washington's new stadium, the Braves returned home on a night filled with nostalgia from those years when Atlanta always made the playoffs.

Longtime Braves catcher Javy Lopez, who retired after a failed comeback attempt in spring training, threw out the ceremonial first pitch. Then it was Glavine's turn to throw pitches that counted, cheered by the same fans who booed him lustily after a bitter contract dispute with Atlanta management led him to sign with the Mets.

Glavine was helped out by new Braves center fielder Mark Kotsay, who made a play reminiscent of the guy he replaced. Kotsay threw out Jack Wilson at home to end the fourth, making a good first impression on a town that watched Andruw Jones, a 10-time Gold Glove winner, do those sort of things for more than a decade before he signed with the Dodgers.

The Braves had more troubles than highlights on defense, however.

Kelly Johnson bobbled away an easy grounder in the second that should have been the third out, allowing an unearned run to score off Glavine. When the Braves had a chance to get out of a seventh-inning jam without the tying run scoring, Escobar one-hopped a throw to first that Teixeira couldn't scoop.

"We showed a lot of character," Glavine said. "If you're going to beat us, you've got to battle us to the last out. But there's no question that other parts of the game were pretty ugly. We need to shore that up."


  • Johnson left in the fourth with an ailing right knee that bothered him most of the spring. The second baseman was day to day.
  • Pittsburgh RHP Tyler Yates, acquired from Atlanta last week, pitched a scoreless inning against his former team.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Xavier Nady has a huge night, hitting two homers, including this three-run shot in the 12th.  (AP)
Xavier Nady has a huge night, hitting two homers, including this three-run shot in the 12th. (AP)

Players of the Game

X. Nady
AB 7
R 4
H 4
HR 2

Y. Escobar
AB 4
R 2
H 3
HR 0

Related Video

Pittsburgh Pirates
Nate McLouth, CF5234112 .600
Freddy Sanchez, 2B5030101 .600
Jason Bay, LF6100113 .000
Adam LaRoche, 1B6120126 .333
Xavier Nady, RF7444025 .571
Ryan Doumit, C7130013 .429
Jose Bautista, 3B5112033 .200
Jack Wilson, SS4100201 .000
Ian Snell, P1000002 .000
   a- Nyjer Morgan, PH11100001.000
    Tyler Yates, P0000000 .000
   b- Doug Mientkiewicz, PH1000001 .000
    John Grabow, P0000000 .000
   c- Chris Gomez, PH0000100 .000
    Damaso Marte, P0000000 .000
    Matt Capps, P0000000 .000
    Franquelis Osoria, P1000010 .000
a-doubled for Snell in the 7th
b-flied out for Yates in the 8th
c-walked for Grabow in the 9th
2B - Freddy Sanchez (1, Soriano), Adam LaRoche (1, Glavine), Xavier Nady (1, Resop), Jose Bautista (1, Glavine), Nyjer Morgan (1, Ohman)
HR - Nate McLouth (1, Acosta), Xavier Nady 2 (2, Acosta, Boyer)
SH - Nate McLouth (1), Freddy Sanchez (1), Jose Bautista (1), Ian Snell (1)
RBI - Nate McLouth 4 (4), Xavier Nady 4 (4), Jose Bautista 2 (2)
2-OUT RBI - Nate McLouth 4 (4), Xavier Nady 3 (3)
PK - Nate McLouth (1, Glavine)
Team LOB - 12
DP - J. Wilson-F. Sanchez-LaRoche, F. Sanchez-J. Wilson
Pittsburgh Pirates
Ian Snell 6744231 6.00
Tyler Yates 1000110 0.00
John Grabow 1000010 0.00
Damaso Marte 0.1022210 54.00
Matt Capps 0.2233200 40.50
Franquelis Osoria (W,1-0) 3322111 6.00
WP - Ian Snell (1)
Pitches-Strikes - Ian Snell 90-54, Tyler Yates 14-6, John Grabow 13-9, Damaso Marte 19-10, Matt Capps 21-8, Franquelis Osoria 38-24
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Ian Snell 8-6, Tyler Yates 1-1, John Grabow 1-1, Franquelis Osoria 4-3
Batters Faced - Ian Snell 26, Tyler Yates 4, John Grabow 3, Damaso Marte 3, Matt Capps 6, Franquelis Osoria 12
Atlanta Braves
Kelly Johnson, 2B2110000 .333
    Martin Prado, 2B3100100 .000
Yunel Escobar, SS4233210 .429
Chipper Jones, 3B6123011 .300
Mark Teixeira, 1B6000014 .100
Brian McCann, C6123000 .300
Jeff Francoeur, RF5111121 .222
Mark Kotsay, CF4220201 .286
Matt Diaz, LF6011013 .111
Tom Glavine, P1100111 .000
    Chris Resop, P0000000 .000
    Will Ohman, P0000000 .000
    Peter Moylan, P0000000 .000
    Royce Ring, P0000000 .000
   a- Gregor Blanco, PH1000000 .000
    Manny Acosta, P0000000 .000
    Jeff Bennett, P0000000 .000
   b- Ruben Gotay, PH0100100 .000
    Rafael Soriano, P0000000 .000
   c- Brayan Pena, PH1000001 .000
    Blaine Boyer, P0000000 .000
   d- Corky Miller, PH1000001 .000
a-grounded out for Ring in the 7th
b-walked for J. Bennett in the 9th
c-lined out for Soriano in the 10th
d-flied out for Boyer in the 12th
2B - Mark Kotsay (1, Osoria)
3B - Yunel Escobar (1, Snell)
HR - Brian McCann (1, Snell), Jeff Francoeur (1, Osoria)
RBI - Yunel Escobar 3 (3), Chipper Jones 3 (4), Brian McCann 3 (3), Jeff Francoeur (1), Matt Diaz (1)
2-OUT RBI - Brian McCann 2 (2), Jeff Francoeur (1), Matt Diaz (1)
Team LOB - 7
Outfield Assists - Mark Kotsay 1
DP - Escobar-Teixeira
E - Yunel Escobar (1, Throwing), Kelly Johnson (1, Misplayed grounder), Chipper Jones (1, Throwing)
Atlanta Braves
Tom Glavine 5721230 1.80
Chris Resop (H,1) 1111000 9.00
Will Ohman (H,1) 0.1110000 0.00
Peter Moylan (BS,1) 0.1000000 5.40
Royce Ring 0.1000010 0.00
Manny Acosta 0.2344112 54.00
Jeff Bennett 1.1211220 6.75
Rafael Soriano 1100110 0.00
Blaine Boyer (L,0-1) 2233131 13.50
IBB - LaRoche by Rafael Soriano
WP - Manny Acosta (1), Jeff Bennett (1)
Pitches-Strikes - Tom Glavine 97-52, Chris Resop 15-11, Will Ohman 6-4, Peter Moylan 6-4, Royce Ring 4-3, Manny Acosta 27-12, Jeff Bennett 32-16, Rafael Soriano 18-8, Blaine Boyer 37-21
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Tom Glavine 7-3, Chris Resop 3-0, Will Ohman 1-0, Peter Moylan 2-0, Jeff Bennett 3-0, Blaine Boyer 1-2
Batters Faced - Tom Glavine 22, Chris Resop 4, Will Ohman 2, Peter Moylan 2, Royce Ring 1, Manny Acosta 6, Jeff Bennett 9, Rafael Soriano 5, Blaine Boyer 9
Game Information
Attendance - 45269
Game Time - 4:28
Temperature - 56
Umpires - Home - Joe West, First Base - Ed Rapuano, Second Base - Ed Hickox, Third Base - C.B. Bucknor