• My Scores
  • NFL
  • MLB
  • NHL
  • NBA

Cincinnati at Pittsburgh

W: P. Maholm (1-1) L: B. Arroyo (0-1)
S: O. Dotel (3)
HR: CIN - J. Bruce (1), J. Bruce (2)   PIT - None

Pirates 5, Reds 3

CBSSports.com wire reports

PITTSBURGH -- The numbers don't seem to mesh. The Pittsburgh Pirates have been outscored 75-53, yet they are 7-5 -- a rare winning record for a club that hasn't finished a season above .500 since 1992.

The secret: They're losing the one-sided games, with each of their five losses coming by at least six runs, but they're 5-0 in games decided by two runs or fewer.

Paul Maholm pitched four-hit ball into the seventh inning, Jason Jaramillo had a three-run double and the Pirates completed a three-game sweep of close games by beating the slumping Cincinnati Reds 5-3 on Sunday.

"That kind of run differential tells us we shouldn't have won a game," Pirates general manager Neal Huntington said. "It's been an odd year. Typically, the more runs you score, the fewer runs you give up, the more games you win. But it doesn't always hold true. ... When our pitchers are giving us a chance to win, we've won."

Jay Bruce hit his first two homers of the season, solo shots in the fifth off Maholm and the ninth off Octavio Dotel, but the Reds lost their fifth in a row. They won 13 of 18 from the Pirates last season, only to be swept for the first time since April 11-13, 2008, in Pittsburgh.

The Pirates won one-run games in their final at-bat by 4-3 on Friday and 5-4 on Saturday.

"The games could have easily gone either way, especially today," Bruce said. "We hit some balls right at people and didn't really catch the breaks when we needed to. I think it just needs to come around, but at the end of the day it's still a sweep."

While losing 99 games last season, the Pirates swept only three series, each lasting three games.

"We could have easily been happy with the series win, but the guys came out and played hard and wanted to sweep," Maholm said. "You could tell that."

Maholm (1-1), supported by some strong defense, struck out five and walked one after permitting seven runs in 11-plus innings against the Dodgers and Giants.

Among the standout plays were shortstop Ronny Cedeno going deep into the hole to throw out Johnny Gomes and left fielder Milledge making a diving catch.

"They made some outstanding defensive plays out there that saved Maholm," Reds manager Dusty Baker said.

Reds right-hander Bronson Arroyo (0-1) ran into problems in the fourth inning for the second straight start, and wound up with his first loss to the Pirates in his last six starts against them. He was perfect over the first three innings, only to allow six of the first seven batters to reach during a five-run inning that put Pittsburgh up 5-0.

Delwyn Young, Lastings Milledge and Ryan Church singled around Garrett Jones' walk, and Bobby Crosby was hit by a pitch with the bases loaded. Jaramillo, the backup catcher and one of four bench players in the lineup, followed by driving in his first three runs of the season with a double to left.

"They're good players, and we still feel we have good players in the lineup when they're in there," manager John Russell said. "It showed again."

On Tuesday, four of the five runs Arroyo allowed against Florida came in the fourth. The Reds came back to win that game 10-8 but haven't won since, scoring only 15 runs during the five consecutive losses. Arroyo gave up one run in 15 innings while beating the Pirates twice last season and had an 0.86 ERA in his last three starts against them.

Dotel got his third save in four opportunities despite allowing Bruce's second homer. Brendan Donnelly pitched a scoreless eighth and Joel Hanrahan got the final out in the seventh.

The game started three minutes past the scheduled 1:35 p.m. EDT start because crew chief Joe West's crew was late arriving on the field. West recently complained about the slow pace of games involving the Red Sox and Yankees.


Maholm is 4-1 in his last seven starts against the Reds in Pittsburgh. ... Pirates 3B Andy LaRoche (back) hasn't played since the second inning Friday. ... Reds 3B Scott Rolen tested his sore back during batting practice, but remained out of the lineup. ... Jones hasn't homered since hitting three in his first five at-bats. ... Pittsburgh started 11-9 last season, but never was two games over .500 again. ... The Pirates are 5-1 at home. They have had only one winning record at home (43-38, 2006) since PNC Park opened in 2001. They hadn't won their first two home series since 1992.

Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Players of the Game

J. Jaramillo
AB 3
R 0
H 2
HR 0

J. Bruce
AB 4
R 2
H 2
HR 2

Related Video

Cincinnati Reds
Drew Stubbs, CF3000110 .167
Orlando Cabrera, SS3010100 .240
Joey Votto, 1B4000013 .283
Brandon Phillips, 2B4000013 .224
Jonny Gomes, LF4110010 .243
Ryan Hanigan, C4000013 .333
Jay Bruce, RF4222001 .178
Paul Janish, 3B3011000 .300
   a- Chris Dickerson, PH1000010 .296
Bronson Arroyo, P2000020 .125
   b- Micah Owings, PH1000011 .000
    Mike Lincoln, P0000000 .000
a-struck out for Janish in the 9th
b-struck out for Arroyo in the 7th
2B - Paul Janish (2, Maholm)
HR - Jay Bruce 2 (2, Maholm, Dotel)
RBI - Jay Bruce 2 (4), Paul Janish (3)
2-OUT RBI - Jay Bruce (2), Paul Janish (3)
Team LOB - 5
E - Ryan Hanigan (1, Throwing)
Cincinnati Reds
Bronson Arroyo (L,0-1) 6555370 4.95
Mike Lincoln 2000010 4.05
HBP - Crosby (by Bronson Arroyo)
Pitches-Strikes - Bronson Arroyo 107-66, Mike Lincoln 21-15
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Bronson Arroyo 2-9, Mike Lincoln 3-2
Batters Faced - Bronson Arroyo 27, Mike Lincoln 6
Pittsburgh Pirates
Delwyn Young, 2B4110010 .316
Andrew McCutchen, CF3000111 .250
Lastings Milledge, LF4110001 .271
Garrett Jones, 1B3100111 .209
Ryan Church, RF4111010 .438
Bobby Crosby, 3B2101110 .231
Jason Jaramillo, C3023000 .375
Paul Maholm, P3000023 .000
    Joel Hanrahan, P0000000 .000
    Brendan Donnelly, P0000000 .000
    Octavio Dotel, P0000000 .000
Ronny Cedeno, SS3000013 .317
2B - Jason Jaramillo (1, Arroyo)
RBI - Ryan Church (4), Bobby Crosby (3), Jason Jaramillo 3 (3)
SB - Andrew McCutchen (7, 3rd base off Arroyo/Hanigan)
Team LOB - 4
E - Ronny Cedeno (1, Throwing)
Pittsburgh Pirates
Paul Maholm (W,1-1) 6.2422151 4.58
Joel Hanrahan (H,2) 0.1000010 3.00
Brendan Donnelly (H,5) 1000100 3.00
Octavio Dotel (S,3) 1111031 6.00
Pitches-Strikes - Paul Maholm 100-62, Joel Hanrahan 5-3, Brendan Donnelly 14-7, Octavio Dotel 15-13
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Paul Maholm 5-11, Brendan Donnelly 1-2
Batters Faced - Paul Maholm 26, Joel Hanrahan 1, Brendan Donnelly 4, Octavio Dotel 4
Game Information
Attendance - 13860
Game Time - 2:29
Temperature - 44
Umpires - Home - Rob Drake, First Base - Joe West, Second Base - Angel Hernandez, Third Base - Paul Schrieber