Initial 2009 rankings: Third basemen
Our position-by-position initial rankings for 2009 continues at third base, where the losses of Ryan Braun and Miguel Cabrera to other positions really hits this spot hard. David Wright has closed the gap on Alex Rodriguez at No. 1 -- and might have even overtaken him.
In preparation for our early mock draft, we go position-by-position with some preliminary rankings for Draft Day 2009. Our rankings are based on position eligibility for next season, which requires 20 games at a position to be eligible. If a player has not played 20 games, his primary position will be defined as what position he has played the most games at -- unless it is a current AL player that will be classified as DH-only.
|
|
|||
| RK | Player | TM | The thinking is as follows … |
| 1 | Alex Rodriguez | NYY | Not bad for a "down" year, but his New York counterpart is in the conversation now. |
| 2 | David Wright | NYM | Steady year start to finish this time gives him a great case to be No. 1 here in '09. |
| 3 |
Evan Longoria
|
TB | Likely AL ROY had great numbers despite a two-week late start and a month on DL. |
| 4 |
Kevin Youkilis
|
BOS | Lowell's injury gives Youkilis his 3B eligibility back and he returns as an elite one. |
| 5 | Aramis Ramirez | CHC | He gets the nod over Chipper because of his steadiness and lack of injury risk. |
| 6 |
Aubrey Huff
|
BAL | Renaissance had him produce at a top-five level, but he needs to do it back-to-back. |
| 7 |
Chipper Jones
|
ATL | No third baseman was as productive with their at-bats, but you just cannot rely on him. |
| 8 |
Garrett Atkins
|
COL | He has slipped the past few years -- and look out below if he leaves Coors Field. |
| 9 |
Chris Davis
|
TEX | Rookie masher can reach 30 homers and 100 RBI -- but also 160 strikeouts? |
| 10 |
Ryan Zimmerman
|
WAS | Shoulder woes are devastating on power numbers but he did some some late life. |
| 11 |
Mark DeRosa
|
CHC | Versatility and good pop are valuable, so he is high here even without a regular spot. |
| 12 |
Jorge Cantu
|
FLA | If he hadn't run so hot and cold in past years, we could rank him a lot higher here. |
| 13 |
Troy Glaus
|
STL | He had a healthy and productive first season in the NL, but you cannot ignore the risk. |
| 14 |
Mark Reynolds
|
ARI | If Fantasy was just about homers and run production, this masher would be higher. |
| 15 |
Edwin Encarnacion
|
CIN | He will never hit .300, but in that ballpark he could break through for 30-100 at age 26. |
| 16 |
Mike Lowell
|
BOS | If you could guarantee a full season he has to be in the top 10. You certainly cannot. |
| 17 |
Carlos Guillen
|
DET | Another injury-risk sleeper. Might he have played more if the team was in the race? |
| 18 |
Alex Gordon
|
KC | He was supposed to be Braun and Longoria before them. Will he ever be? |
| 19 |
Chone Figgins
|
ANA | He really needs complete health to be where his once lofty standards had him before. |
| 20 | Adrian Beltre | SEA | It is apparent he will never be his pre-contract self, but he is good for 25 HRs a year. |
| 21 |
Melvin Mora
|
BAL | Another veteran renaissance but there are no guarantees at his age next year. |
| 22 |
Ian Stewart
|
COL | Breakthrough could lead to a deal of Atkins or Helton, so move Stewart up if he starts. |
| 23 |
Hank Blalock
|
TEX | Another great September finish, but we have been tricked by this from him before. |
| 24 | Casey Blake | LA | One of the most underrated, albeit streaky, bats in Fantasy -- where will he call home? |
| 25 | Kevin Kouzmanoff | SD | He won't ever be elite, or consistent in-season, but he can do this year to year now. |
| 26 | Ty Wigginton | HOU | Power and versatility are there, but so is the injury risk and the questions about at-bats. |
| 27 |
Joe Crede
|
CHW | Back injuries have claimed players before, so you cannot be sure what you will get. |
| 28 |
Bill Hall
|
MIL | He regains infield eligibility, but his hot streak never came and future is less certain. |
| 29 |
Jed Lowrie
|
BOS | The versatility is nice, but he should be starting at shortstop in all '09 Fantasy lineups. |
| 30 |
Pedro Feliz
|
PHI | Power and ballpark work in his favor, but he needs to earn his at-bats due low OBP. |
| 31 |
Brandon Wood
|
ANA | His bat might not look like much, but one of these years he is going to put it together. |
| 32 |
Andy LaRoche
|
PIT | Continued struggles are really surprising, considering his talent, so look out above. |
| 33 | Jose A. Bautista | TOR | Blue Jays stole him from the Pirates, but he still needs to earn his playing time. |
| 34 |
Scott Rolen
|
TOR | Shoulder has never been the same and has sapped his power and made him day-to-day. |
| 35 |
Eric Chavez
|
OAK | Speaking of injury-risks sleepers. Chavez has come to define that term in Fantasy. |
| 36 |
Brandon Inge
|
DET | Like Lowrie above, Inge should be starting only at catcher in Fantasy lineups next year. |
| 37 |
Brian Buscher
|
MIN | He won't impress you with much power or any speed, but he has a job and room to grow. |
| 38 |
Josh Fields
|
CHW | Mysterious year after he already proved big league and Fantasy worthy. Watch him. |
| 39 |
Greg Dobbs
|
PHI | Fewer part-time players were more clutch down the stretch, so he could earn a job. |
| 40 | Andy Marte | CLE | Where has this talent gone, besides downhill in a hurry? He is still just 25, though. |
You can e-mail Emack your Fantasy Baseball ranking questions to DMFantasyBaseball@cbs.com. Be sure to put Attn: Third base rankings in the subject field. Please include your full name, hometown and state. Be aware, due to the large volume of submissions received, we cannot guarantee personal responses to all questions.














