2017 Super Bowl: How Falcons, Patriots starters rated as high school recruits

Long before the Atlanta Falcons' Matt Ryan became "Matty Ice" and reached the Super Bowl as the likely NFL MVP, he was a three-star quarterback running the triple option at William Penn Charter in Pennsylvania.

Rivals rated Ryan as the 25th-best quarterback in the 2003 class. Based on composite rankings from multiple services, 247Sports later ranked Ryan 34th, behind signal callers such as a future No. 1 NFL Draft pick bust (JaMarcus Russell), a future major-league pitcher (Clayton Richard) and a future plaintiff against the NCAA over video games (Sam Keller).

The top three quarterbacks in the 2003 recruiting class -- Kyle Wright, Chris Leak and Tommy Grady -- never threw a pass in an NFL regular-season game. Ryan, who starred at Boston College, has more NFL pass attempts than 32 of the 33 QB recruits combined who were ranked ahead of him. Only No. 28 Joe Flacco joined Ryan with a real NFL career out of the Class of 2003.

One of the cool parts leading up to each Super Bowl is tracing the players' journey. I've done this for several years. Though I don't have the data, this Patriots-Falcons matchup seems like a Super Bowl with some of the longest odds given where many starters were ranked in high school.

Sixty-one percent of the projected Super Bowl LI starters were not ranked in the top 500 overall in their recruiting class, according to 247Sports Composite rankings. This statistic counts only starters whose past recruiting rankings could be found, though that's most of them.

While it's true that three stars are handed out far more to recruits than any other rating, 61 percent not in the top 500 feels like a very high number. To put that in perspective, the No. 500 recruit in 2017 is dual-threat quarterback Jason Shelley, who is committed to Utah and also has offers from Clemson, New Mexico, North Texas, SMU, Southern Miss, Utah State and Virginia, according to 247Sports.

Sure, the Falcons and Patriots have one-time elite recruits in Julio Jones, Jake Matthews, Martellus Bennett, LeGarrette Blount and Malcom Brown. (Tom Brady, who was famously a sixth-round NFL Draft pick, had a mixed bag with his recruitment. He was overlooked for a while and got labeled as the No. 6 pro-style quarterback by recruiting analyst Tom Lemming in 1995, which came before recruiting rankings blew up into a major industry.)

Still, the Falcons and Patriots have far more players who were under the radar. Thirty-seven percent of this year's Super Bowl starters weren't even in the top 1,000 of their recruiting class.

Malcolm Butler, the Patriots' star of Super Bowl XLIX, was unranked out of high school. He went to junior college, took a job at Popeyes and later went to Division II West Alabama.

Falcons defensive end Vic Beasley, the NFL's leader in sacks, was the No. 23 tight end and No. 487 player overall when he signed with Clemson.

Alex Mack, the Falcons' four-time Pro Bowl center, was a two-star recruit by Cal and rated the 79th-best guard.

Chris Hogan, who caught nine passes for 180 yards and two touchdowns in the AFC Championship Game, played three years of lacrosse at Penn State before taking up football at Monmouth for one season.

If the Falcons beat the Patriots, Ryan would become the fourth three-star quarterback to win the Super Bowl in the past seven years. Aaron Rodgers, Russell Wilson and Flacco also had three stars out of high school.

Different paths lead players to the Super Bowl, as this season can attest. Recruiting rankings are only the starting point, not the finish line.

Super Bowl LI projected starters as recruits

Falcons player Stars Overall Position
WR Julio Jones 5 No. 3 No. 1 WR
LT Jake Matthews 4 No. 38 No. 5 OT
LG Andy Levitre 2 No. 1,420 No. 130 G
C Alex Mack 2 No. 987 No. 79 G
RG Chris Chester* 3 Not available No. 8 TE
RT Ryan Schraeder 0 Not ranked Not ranked
TE Austin Hooper 3 No. 394 No. 25 strong-side DE
WR Mohamded Sanu 3 No. 693 No. 51 S
QB Matt Ryan 3 No. 698 No. 34 pro-style QB
RB Devonta Freeman 4 No. 102 No. 7 RB
FB Patrick DiMarco 2 Not ranked No. 89 TE
DE Brooks Reed 3 No. 556 No. 37 strong-side DE
DT Jonathan Babineaux NA Not available Not available
DT Grady Jarrett 3 No. 1,140 No. 81 DT
DE Tyson Jackson 3 No. 569 No. 35 strong-side DE
LB Vic Beasley 3 No. 487 No. 23 TE
LB Deion Jones 3 No. 377 No. 37 OLB
LB De'Vondre Campbell 3 No. 76 No. 8 OLB
CB Robert Alford 0 Not ranked Not ranked
CB Jalen Collins 3 No. 369 No. 33 CB
S Ricardo Allen 3 No. 594 No. 43 CB
S Keanu Neal 4 No. 109 No. 13 S
K Matt Bryant NA Not available Not available
P Matt Bosher* 3 Not ranked No. 6 K
KR/PR Eric Weems 0 Not ranked Not ranked
Patriots player Stars Overall Position
WR Chris Hogan 0 Not ranked Not ranked
LT Nate Solder 3 No. 884 No. 51 TE
LG Joe Thuney 2 Not ranked No. 142 OT
C David Andrews 3 No. 523 No. 9 C
RG Shaq Mason 3 No. 1,151 No. 74 G
RT Marcus Cannon 3 No. 1,003 No. 79 G
TE Martellus Bennett 5 No. 16 No. 1 TE
WR Julian Edelman 3 No. 103 No. 4 dual-threat QB
QB Tom Brady^ NA Not available No. 6 pro-style QB
RB James White 3 No. 551 No. 46 RB
RB LeGarrette Blount 4 No. 12 No. 1 RB
DE Chris Long 3 No. 199 No. 16 strong-side DE
DT Alan Branch 3 No. 249 No. 19 strong-side DE
DT Malcom Brown 5 No. 9 No. 2 DT
DE Trey Flowers 3 No. 1,335 No. 62 weak-side DE
LB Shea McClellin 2 No. 1,511 No. 86 strong-side DE
LB Don't'a Hightower 4 No. 257 No. 23 OLB
LB Rob Ninkovich 3 No. 89 No. 10 strong-side DE
CB Logan Ryan 3 No. 355 No. 37 CB
CB Malcolm Butler 0 Not ranked Not ranked
S Patrick Chung 2 No. 1,300 No. 95 S
S Devin McCourty 3 No. 906 No. 55 S
K Stephen Gostkowski 0 Not ranked Not ranked
P Ryan Allen 0 Not ranked Not ranked
PR Danny Amendola 3 No. 546 No. 64 WR
KR Cyrus Jones 4 No. 43 No. 6 Athlete
All rankings are from 247Sports Composite data unless otherwise noted.
* Rivals ranking | ^ Tom Lemming ranking

247Sports was created in 2010. The 247Sports Composite is a proprietary algorithm that compiles prospect "rankings" and "ratings" listed in the public domain by the major media recruiting services. As such, it is the industry's most comprehensive and unbiased prospect ranking. For rankings prior to 2010, the 247Sports Composite includes only rankings from the major media recruiting services and not its own rankings.

CBS Sports Senior Writer

Jon Solomon is CBS Sports's national college football writer. A former Alabama resident, he now lives in Maryland and also writes extensively on NCAA topics. Jon previously worked at The Birmingham News,... Full Bio

Our Latest Stories