NHL players had the best reactions to Auston Matthews' historic four-goal debut
The Toronto Maple Leafs' No. 1 pick left the sports world's collective jaw on the floor

In the modern era of the NHL, no player had ever scored four goals in his first game in the league. That was until Auston Matthews set the modern-day record by scoring four in his NHL debut Wednesday night for the Toronto Maple Leafs.
If you missed them, the Maple Leafs put them all in this tidy little video for you:
All four Matthews goals, all right here. #TMLtalk#StandWitnesspic.twitter.com/ZJARlw9RNR
— Toronto Maple Leafs (@MapleLeafs) October 13, 2016
The No. 1 pick of the 2016 NHL Draft stunned not just the hockey world, but the sports world as a whole. He was the No. 1 trending topic worldwide on Twitter, mostly because thousands of people probably tweeted "Auston Matthews scored how many goals? WHAT!?"
Among the many in disbelief were the players in the league Matthews just joined.
It's not often you'll see NHLers tweet about guys on an opposing team, much less compliment them (unless they're a former teammate), but NHL Twitter was afire with veteran players reacting in disbelief as this rookie made what they do look easy.
Here's a sampling of some of the NHLers that weighed in:
I don't even know what to say. Just a treat to watch tonight @AM34
— Tyler Seguin (@tseguinofficial) October 13, 2016
Wow !!! @AM34 welcome to our beer league !!!' Lolll #congrats#easygame
— Kristopher Letang (@Letang_58) October 13, 2016
4ginos? No biggie... I think he'll get 5. #crazy#Matthews
— Marian Gaborik (@MGaborik12) October 13, 2016
I feel like I'm watching one of the 99 overall created player's I used to make in NHL 2002
— Garret Sparks (@GSparks40) October 13, 2016
Most guys would be thrilled to score four in a month.... #easygame
— Viktor Stalberg (@VStalberg) October 13, 2016
Austin Matthews might have more career NHL goals than me before the night is over .....
— Tom Sestito (@TomSestito23) October 12, 2016
What's the big deal I scored 4 goals.....In my career. #matthews#bust
— Frazer Mclaren (@Frazermclaren68) October 13, 2016
Feels like I'm watching mite hockey where there's that one kid who's just way better than everyone else. Congrats @AM34#easygame
— Martin St Louis (@mstlouis_26) October 13, 2016
Congrats @AM34 on an already impressive NHL career!
— Keith Kinkaid (@Blockaid1) October 13, 2016
Wow 👏👏👏 Welcome to the NHL @AM34 ....Incredible young man! Keep it going 👍
— Teemu Selanne (@TeemuSel8nne) October 13, 2016
Even Columbus Blue Jackets rookie Zach Werenski, one of the NHL players that knows Matthews better than most as a former Team USA teammate, couldn't believe what he saw.
You're joking @AM34
— Zach Werenski (@ZachWerenski) October 13, 2016
Meanwhile, Roberto Luongo has already decided that he'll leave the goaltending to backup James Reimer against the Florida Panthers' Atlantic Division foe.
I've just decided that Reims will play ALL of the games versus the leafs this year...... #Matthews
— Strombone (@strombone1) October 13, 2016
Arizona Coyotes co-owner Anthony LeBlanc also made sure to note the performance of Matthews' performance as well. The youngster fell for the sport while watching the Coyotes as he grew up in Scottsdale. Perhaps he's only the beginning for hockey talent coming out of the desert.
So happy for @AM34 & his family. Tonight's other winner...AZ hockey. Let's keep growing the game. Another rink (or 2) being announced soon!
— Anthony LeBlanc (@anthonydleblanc) October 13, 2016
Poor Stephen Amell, a noted hockey fan, knows that the Canadian TV ratings for Arrow are going to be terrible:
After Auston Matthews fourth goal, I'm just going to accept that the only person in Toronto watching Arrow is my Mom.
— Stephen Amell (@StephenAmell) October 13, 2016
Matthews' favorite reaction might end up belonging to his mom, Ema, though. This was only after three goals. What a moment.
Awesome reaction from Auston Matthews' mom after his 3rd goal pic.twitter.com/c0zI823zzi
— Pete Blackburn (@PeteBlackburn) October 13, 2016
Unfortunately for Matthews and the Maple Leafs, they lost to the Ottawa Senators in overtime. The rookie even took the blame for missing his man on the Sens' OT winner. So it wasn't all gravy for the 19-year-old, but if it's any consolation, the result isn't going to be the thing people remember about this night.
Welcome to the NHL, Auston Matthews. Try not to hurt anyone, will ya?
















