Daily leaguers staring down Wednesday night's Eric Stults start for the Padres have a series of conflicting factors to consider. Stults was great in his first start (five shutout innings and seven strikeouts against the Mets), he was pretty awesome last year (2.91 ERA in 99 innings pitched), and he has that mysterious air of returning from Japan as, possibly, a different pitcher than he was before, much like Ryan Vogelsong. Stults pitched in Japan in 2010.
However, Stults does have a career ERA of 4.07 and profiled as a pretty unexciting pitcher in the minors (with the counter to that being that he spent a lot of time in the homer-happy PCL). Additionally, while he did pitch in Japan (in 2010), he didn't pitch especially well -- in his one season, Stults produced a 5.07 ERA and 1.57 WHIP.
So what does a daily gamer do? Well, the game is at PETCO, which is still somewhat pitcher-friendly. And his opponent, the Dodgers, have scored the third-fewest runs in the majors. Over a full season, Stults is probably end-of the rotation fodder for NL-only, but based on what he did last year and in his first start, he has momentum, and gets the official "sure, why not" stamp for Wednesday's game.
If you have better options, leave him. If your plan is to stream as many pitchers as possible ... he has a start. It's unexciting and frustratingly unpredictable, but Stults has enough factors stacked in his favor to give a half-hearted thumbs kind-of up.