Circling the Bases is our Fantasy Baseball expert column, full of insider information, advice and in-depth analysis. Every Wednesday year-round, Tristan H. Cockcroft provides an array of offseason player analysis, preseason draft strategy and regular-season coverage.
It's never too early to get a leg up on next season. Die-hard Fantasy Baseball fans are always ready for more baseball to be played, and many owners who aren't in postseason pools are already thinking ahead four months to when spring training camps open.
To satisfiy those Fantasy owners already preparing for 2004, the following are early player rankings. They are based on a traditional 12-man AL- or NL-only league, standard Rotisserie rosters, and Roto 5x5 scoring. Mixed-league ratings and dollar values will appear later in the offseason.
The rankings include the top 20 catchers; 12 first basemen, second basemen, third basemen and shortstops; 40 outfielders; 20 designated hitters; 40 starting pitchers; and 20 relief pitchers. Final 2003 rankings based on the player's earned Fantasy value, according to CBS SportsLine.com's evaluation system, are listed in parentheses. If a player is listed as "NR," then he did not rank among the top players at his position by the above guidelines.
Players are listed at the position they played the most and with the team with which they finished the 2003 season. But if the player has been recently released or is eligible for free-agency, his team is listed in italics. (Those with options for 2004 have asterisks.)
| Catchers | |||
| American League | National League | ||
| 1. | Jorge Posada, N.Y. Yankees (1) | 1. | Ivan Rodriguez, Florida (2) |
| 2. | Jason Varitek, Boston (3) | 2. | Mike Piazza, N.Y. Mets (8) |
| 3. | A.J. Pierzynski, Minnesota (2) | 3. | Javy Lopez, Atlanta (1) |
| 4. | Ramon Hernandez, Oakland (4) | 4. | Mike Lieberthal, Philadelphia (4) |
| 5. | Victor Martinez, Cleveland (NR) | 5. | Paul Lo Duca, Los Angeles (6) |
| 6. | Toby Hall, Tampa Bay (7) | 6. | Jason Kendall, Pittsburgh (3) |
| 7. | Bengie Molina, Anaheim (6) | 7. | Charles Johnson, Colorado (7) |
| 8. | Miguel Olivo, Chicago White Sox (11) | 8. | Jason LaRue, Cincinnati (9) |
| 9. | Brandon Inge, Detroit (NR) | 9. | Yorvit Torrealba, San Francisco (16) |
| 10. | Einar Diaz, Texas (10) | 10. | Benito Santiago, San Francisco (5) |
| 11. | Ben Davis, Seattle (NR) | 11. | Johnny Estrada, Atlanta (NR) |
| 12. | Brook Fordyce, Baltimore* (8) | 12. | Robbie Hammock, Arizona (11) |
| 13. | Dan Wilson, Seattle (20) | 13. | Damian Miller, Chicago Cubs (18) |
| 14. | Josh Bard, Cleveland (13) | 14. | Chad Moeller, Arizona (13) |
| 15. | Greg Myers, Toronto (5) | 15. | Ramon Castro, Florida (NR) |
| 16. | Brent Mayne, Kansas City* (16) | 16. | Brad Ausmus, Houston (20) |
| 17. | Adam Melhuse, Oakland (14) | 17. | Mike Matheny, St. Louis (12) |
| 18. | Kevin Cash, Toronto (NR) | 18. | David Ross, Los Angeles (14) |
| 19. | Todd Greene, Texas (21) | 19. | Brian Schneider, Montreal (17) |
| 20. | Tom Wilson, Toronto (9) | 20. | Vance Wilson, N.Y. Mets (15) |
| First basemen | |||
| American League | National League | ||
| 1. | Carlos Delgado, Toronto (1) | 1. | Todd Helton, Colorado (1) |
| 2. | Jason Giambi, N.Y. Yankees (2) | 2. | Jim Thome, Philadelphia (3) |
| 3. | Mark Teixeira, Texas (6) | 3. | Richie Sexson, Milwaukee (4) |
| 4. | Nick Johnson, N.Y. Yankees (8) | 4. | Jeff Bagwell, Houston (2) |
| 5. | Kevin Millar, Boston (3) | 5. | Derrek Lee, Florida (5) |
| 6. | Paul Konerko, Chicago White Sox (NR) | 6. | Ryan Klesko, San Diego (NR) |
| 7. | Travis Lee, Tampa Bay* (4) | 7. | Shea Hillenbrand, Arizona (8) |
| 8. | John Olerud, Seattle (9) | 8. | Jeff Conine, Florida (6) |
| 9. | Ben Broussard, Cleveland (11) | 9. | Phil Nevin, San Diego (NR) |
| 10. | Doug Mientkiewicz, Minnesota (5) | 10. | Robert Fick, Atlanta (NR) |
| 11. | Carlos Pena, Detroit (12) | 11. | Sean Casey, Cincinnati (7) |
| 12. | Ken Harvey, Kansas City (10) | 12. | Tino Martinez, St. Louis (10) |
| Second basemen | |||
| American League | National League | ||
| 1. | Alfonso Soriano, N.Y. Yankees (1) | 1. | Jeff Kent, Houston (3) |
| 2. | Bret Boone, Seattle (2) | 2. | Marcus Giles, Atlanta (1) |
| 3. | Michael Young, Texas (3) | 3. | Luis Castillo, Florida (2) |
| 4. | Roberto Alomar, Chicago White Sox (11) | 4. | Ray Durham, San Francisco (11) |
| 5. | Todd Walker, Boston (5) | 5. | Jose Vidro, Montreal (6) |
| 6. | Orlando Hudson, Toronto (10) | 6. | Mark Loretta, San Diego (4) |
| 7. | Jerry Hairston Jr., Baltimore (NR) | 7. | Junior Spivey, Arizona (12) |
| 8. | Adam Kennedy, Anaheim (4) | 8. | Placido Polanco, Philadelphia (5) |
| 9. | Mark Ellis, Oakland (12) | 9. | Keith Ginter, Milwaukee (NR) |
| 10. | Luis Rivas, Minnesota (9) | 10. | Ronnie Belliard, Colorado (10) |
| 11. | Desi Relaford, Kansas City (8) | 11. | D'Angelo Jimenez, Cincinnati (8) |
| 12. | Brian Roberts, Baltimore (7) | 12. | Eric Young, San Francisco* (7) |
| Third basemen | |||
| American League | National League | ||
| 1. | Eric Chavez, Oakland (2) | 1. | Scott Rolen, St. Louis (1) |
| 2. | Hank Blalock, Texas (3) | 2. | Mike Lowell, Florida (2) |
| 3. | Aaron Boone, N.Y. Yankees (1) | 3. | Aramis Ramirez, Chicago Cubs (3) |
| 4. | Troy Glaus, Anaheim (11) | 4. | Sean Burroughs, San Diego (6) |
| 5. | Eric Hinske, Toronto (10) | 5. | Edgardo Alfonzo, San Francisco (9) |
| 6. | Bill Mueller, Boston (4) | 6. | Morgan Ensberg, Houston (4) |
| 7. | Corey Koskie, Minnesota (5) | 7. | Wes Helms, Milwaukee (8) |
| 8. | Joe Crede, Chicago White Sox (9) | 8. | Adrian Beltre, Los Angeles (11) |
| 9. | Tony Batista, Baltimore (8) | 9. | Brandon Larson, Cincinnati (NR) |
| 10. | Joe Randa, Kansas City (6) | 10. | Ty Wigginton, N.Y. Mets (7) |
| 11. | Eric Munson, Detroit (NR) | 11. | Freddy Sanchez, Pittsburgh (NR) |
| 12. | Casey Blake, Cleveland (7) | 12. | Vinny Castilla, Atlanta(5) |
| Shortstops | |||
| American League | National League | ||
| 1. | Alex Rodriguez, Texas (1) | 1. | Edgar Renteria, St. Louis* (1) |
| 2. | Nomar Garciaparra, Boston (2) | 2. | Rafael Furcal, Atlanta (2) |
| 3. | Miguel Tejada, Oakland (3) | 3. | Orlando Cabrera, Montreal (3) |
| 4. | Derek Jeter, N.Y. Yankees (5) | 4. | Jose Reyes, N.Y. Mets (6) |
| 5. | Angel Berroa, Kansas City (4) | 5. | Alex Gonzalez, Florida (8) |
| 6. | Cristian Guzman, Minnesota (8) | 6. | Jimmy Rollins, Philadelphia (5) |
| 7. | David Eckstein, Anaheim (10) | 7. | Rich Aurilia, San Francisco (7) |
| 8. | Jose Valentin, Chicago White Sox* (7) | 8. | Alex Cintron, Arizona (4) |
| 9. | Julio Lugo, Tampa Bay (6) | 9. | Khalil Greene, San Diego (NR) |
| 10. | Bobby Crosby, Oakland (NR) | 10. | Alex Gonzalez, Chicago Cubs (11) |
| 11. | Carlos Guillen, Seattle (9) | 11. | Juan Uribe, Colorado (12) |
| 12. | Omar Vizquel, Cleveland (NR) | 12. | Jack Wilson, Pittsburgh (10) |
| Outfielders | |||
| American League | National League | ||
| 1. | Carlos Beltran, Kansas City (1) | 1. | Albert Pujols, St. Louis (1) |
| 2. | Manny Ramirez, Boston (3) | 2. | Vladimir Guerrero, Montreal (13) |
| 3. | Magglio Ordonez, Chicago White Sox (6) | 3. | Barry Bonds, San Francisco (4) |
| 4. | Ichiro Suzuki, Seattle (4) | 4. | Juan Pierre, Florida (3) |
| 5. | Vernon Wells, Toronto (2) | 5. | Gary Sheffield, Atlanta (2) |
| 6. | Garret Anderson, Anaheim (7) | 6. | Bobby Abreu, Philadelphia (7) |
| 7. | Aubrey Huff, Tampa Bay (8) | 7. | Sammy Sosa, Chicago Cubs (16) |
| 8. | Rocco Baldelli, Tampa Bay (11) | 8. | Preston Wilson, Colorado (6) |
| 9. | Carl Crawford, Tampa Bay (9) | 9. | Andruw Jones, Atlanta (11) |
| 10. | Trot Nixon, Boston (16) | 10. | Brian Giles, San Diego (24) |
| 11. | Carlos Lee, Chicago White Sox (5) | 11. | Chipper Jones, Atlanta (9) |
| 12. | Hideki Matsui, N.Y. Yankees (21) | 12. | Lance Berkman, Houston (17) |
| 13. | Johnny Damon, Boston (15) | 13. | Shawn Green, Los Angeles (26) |
| 14. | Randy Winn, Seattle (10) | 14. | Juan Encarnacion, Florida (22) |
| 15. | Bernie Williams, N.Y. Yankees (34) | 15. | Larry Walker, Colorado (28) |
| 16. | Jay Gibbons, Baltimore (23) | 16. | Corey Patterson, Chicago Cubs (30) |
| 17. | Jacque Jones, Minnesota (18) | 17. | Jim Edmonds, St. Louis (20) |
| 18. | Jose Guillen, Oakland (13) | 18. | Cliff Floyd, N.Y. Mets (32) |
| 19. | Torii Hunter, Minnesota (26) | 19. | Marlon Byrd, Philadelphia (29) |
| 20. | Shannon Stewart, Minnesota (20) | 20. | Luis Gonzalez, Arizona (10) |
| 21. | Milton Bradley, Cleveland (19) | 21. | Scott Podsednik, Milwaukee (5) |
| 22. | Mike Cameron, Seattle (27) | 22. | Brad Wilkerson, Montreal (27) |
| 23. | Tim Salmon, Anaheim (31) | 23. | Miguel Cabrera, Florida (NR) |
| 24. | Eric Byrnes, Oakland (36) | 24. | Austin Kearns, Cincinnati (NR) |
| 25. | Alex Sanchez, Detroit (12) | 25. | Richard Hidalgo, Houston (8) |
| 26. | Carl Everett, Chicago White Sox (14) | 26. | Jay Payton, Colorado (12) |
| 27. | Raul Ibanez, Kansas City (17) | 27. | Reggie Sanders, Pittsburgh (15) |
| 28. | Juan Gonzalez, Texas (30) | 28. | Pat Burrell, Philadelphia (NR) |
| 29. | Larry Bigbie, Baltimore (39) | 29. | Steve Finley, Arizona (21) |
| 30. | Darin Erstad, Anaheim (NR) | 30. | Geoff Jenkins, Milwaukee (23) |
| 31. | Jody Gerut, Cleveland (28) | 31. | Ken Griffey Jr., Cincinnati (NR) |
| 32. | Jermaine Dye, Oakland (NR) | 32. | Marquis Grissom, San Francisco (18) |
| 33. | Luis Matos, Baltimore (22) | 33. | Moises Alou, Chicago Cubs (25) |
| 34. | Laynce Nix, Texas (NR) | 34. | J.D. Drew, St. Louis (37) |
| 35. | Bobby Kielty, Toronto (NR) | 35. | Adam Dunn, Cincinnati (39) |
| 36. | Bobby Higginson, Detroit (NR) | 36. | Mark Kotsay, San Diego (NR) |
| 37. | Rondell White, Kansas City (24) | 37. | Kenny Lofton, Chicago Cubs (14) |
| 38. | Aaron Guiel, Kansas City (35) | 38. | Dave Roberts, Los Angeles (33) |
| 39. | Melvin Mora, Baltimore (25) | 39. | Raul Mondesi, Arizona (19) |
| 40. | Coco Crisp, Cleveland (NR) | 40. | Craig Biggio, Houston (31) |
| Designated hitters | |||
| American League | |||
| 1. | Frank Thomas, Chicago White Sox* (1) | 7. | Josh Phelps, Toronto (8) |
| 2. | Mike Sweeney, Kansas City (6) | 8. | Edgar Martinez, Seattle (5) |
| 3. | David Ortiz, Boston (4) | 9. | Justin Morneau, Minnesota (NR) |
| 4. | Rafael Palmeiro, Texas (3) | 10. | Travis Hafner, Cleveland (12) |
| 5. | Dmitri Young, Detroit (2) | 11. | Brad Fullmer, Anaheim (10) |
| 6. | Erubiel Durazo, Oakland (7) | 12. | Ellis Burks, Cleveland* (NR) |
| Starting pitchers | |||
| American League | National League | ||
| 1. | Pedro Martinez, Boston (3) | 1. | Mark Prior, Chicago Cubs (2) |
| 2. | Roy Halladay, Toronto (1) | 2. | Curt Schilling, Arizona (7) |
| 3. | Tim Hudson, Oakland (4) | 3. | Javier Vazquez, Montreal (4) |
| 4. | Mark Mulder, Oakland (10) | 4. | Kerry Wood, Chicago Cubs (5) |
| 5. | Barry Zito, Oakland (6) | 5. | Randy Johnson, Arizona (NR) |
| 6. | Johan Santana, Minnesota (8) | 6. | Jason Schmidt, San Francisco (1) |
| 7. | Mike Mussina, N.Y. Yankees (5) | 7. | Kevin Brown, Los Angeles (3) |
| 8. | Bartolo Colon, Chicago White Sox (9) | 8. | Roy Oswalt, Houston (22) |
| 9. | Andy Pettitte, N.Y. Yankees (13) | 9. | Kevin Millwood, Philadelphia (18) |
| 10. | C.C. Sabathia, Cleveland (16) | 10. | Josh Beckett, Florida (25) |
| 11. | Mark Buehrle, Chicago White Sox (22) | 11. | Hideo Nomo, Los Angeles* (8) |
| 12. | Joel Pineiro, Seattle (12) | 12. | Matt Morris, St. Louis (23) |
| 13. | Jamie Moyer, Seattle (7) | 13. | Carlos Zambrano, Chicago Cubs (10) |
| 14. | Esteban Loaiza, Chicago White Sox* (2) | 14. | Greg Maddux, Atlanta (12) |
| 15. | Jarrod Washburn, Anaheim (25) | 15. | Matt Clement, Chicago Cubs (19) |
| 16. | Kelvim Escobar, Toronto (29) | 16. | Wade Miller, Houston (28) |
| 17. | Jose Contreras, N.Y. Yankees (35) | 17. | Russ Ortiz, Atlanta (14) |
| 18. | Derek Lowe, Boston* (34) | 18. | Woody Williams, St. Louis (11) |
| 19. | Tim Wakefield, Boston (19) | 19. | Randy Wolf, Philadelphia (21) |
| 20. | David Wells, N.Y. Yankees* (18) | 20. | Jake Peavy, San Diego (31) |
| 21. | Brad Radke, Minnesota (21) | 21. | Mark Redman, Florida (13) |
| 22. | Ted Lilly, Oakland (26) | 22. | Vicente Padilla, Philadelphia (16) |
| 23. | Gil Meche, Seattle (30) | 23. | Brett Myers, Philadelphia (NR) |
| 24. | Kyle Lohse, Minnesota (23) | 24. | Ben Sheets, Milwaukee (30) |
| 25. | Freddy Garcia, Seattle (27) | 25. | Kip Wells, Pittsburgh (17) |
| 26. | Ramon Ortiz, Anaheim (NR) | 26. | Brandon Webb, Arizona (9) |
| 27. | Rich Harden, Oakland (NR) | 27. | Sidney Ponson, San Francisco (15) |
| 28. | Victor Zambrano, Tampa Bay (36) | 28. | Brad Penny, Florida (26) |
| 29. | Eric Milton, Minnesota (NR) | 29. | Al Leiter, N.Y. Mets (NR) |
| 30. | John Lackey, Anaheim (38) | 30. | Dontrelle Willis, Florida (20) |
| 31. | Kenny Rogers, Minnesota (39) | 31. | Mike Hampton, Atlanta (37) |
| 32. | Cliff Lee, Cleveland (NR) | 32. | Odalis Perez, Los Angeles (35) |
| 33. | Pat Hentgen, Baltimore (32) | 33. | Miguel Batista, Arizona (27) |
| 34. | Jon Lieber, N.Y. Yankees (NR) | 34. | Adam Eaton, San Diego (36) |
| 35. | Eric DuBose, Baltimore (NR) | 35. | Livan Hernandez, Montreal* (6) |
| 36. | Jason Johnson, Baltimore (NR) | 36. | Jerome Williams, San Francisco (38) |
| 37. | Brian Anderson, Kansas City (20) | 37. | Tom Glavine, N.Y. Mets (NR) |
| 38. | Kurt Ainsworth, Baltimore (NR) | 38. | Tomo Ohka, Montreal (NR) |
| 39. | Jeff Weaver, N.Y. Yankees (NR) | 39. | Horacio Ramirez, Atlanta (40) |
| 40. | Jon Garland, Chicago White Sox (37) | 40. | Steve Trachsel, N.Y. Mets (24) |
| Relief pitchers | |||
| American League | National League | ||
| 1. | Mariano Rivera, N.Y. Yankees (2) | 1. | Eric Gagne, Los Angeles (1) |
| 2. | Keith Foulke, Oakland (1) | 2. | Billy Wagner, Houston (2) |
| 3. | Troy Percival, Anaheim (5) | 3. | John Smoltz, Atlanta (3) |
| 4. | Eddie Guardado, Minnesota (3) | 4. | Jason Isringhausen, St. Louis (14) |
| 5. | Francisco Cordero, Texas (12) | 5. | Trevor Hoffman, San Diego* (NR) |
| 6. | Francisco Rodriguez, Anaheim (16) | 6. | Ugueth Urbina, Florida (6) |
| 7. | Armando Benitez, Seattle (11) | 7. | Matt Mantei, Arizona (7) |
| 8. | Byung-Hyun Kim, Boston (4) | 8. | Robb Nen, San Francisco* (NR) |
| 9. | Lance Carter, Tampa Bay (6) | 9. | Joe Borowski, Chicago Cubs (5) |
| 10. | Kazuhiro Sasaki, Seattle (NR) | 10. | Octavio Dotel, Houston (11) |
| 11. | Scott Williamson, Boston (18) | 11. | Braden Looper, Florida (8) |
| 12. | Jorge Julio, Baltimore (10) | 12. | Jose Valverde, Arizona (17) |
| 13. | Mike MacDougal, Kansas City (15) | 13. | Danny Kolb, Milwaukee (15) |
| 14. | Rafael Soriano, Seattle (NR) | 14. | Luis Ayala, Montreal (18) |
| 15. | David Riske, Cleveland (13) | 15. | Rod Beck, San Diego (13) |
| 16. | Tom Gordon, Chicago White Sox (14) | 16. | Ryan Wagner, Cincinnati (NR) |
| 17. | LaTroy Hawkins, Minnesota (17) | 17. | Guillermo Mota, Los Angeles (9) |
| 18. | Shigetoshi Hasegawa, Seattle (9) | 18. | Danny Graves, Cincinnati (NR) |
| 19. | Aquilino Lopez, Toronto (20) | 19. | Tim Worrell, San Francisco (4) |
| 20. | Damaso Marte, Chicago White Sox (7) | 20. | Rocky Biddle, Montreal (10) |
You can e-mail your Fantasy Baseball questions to Tristan H. Cockcroft at bleacher@commissioner.com. Be sure to put Attn: Tristan in the subject field, and include your full name and hometown. Please be aware, due to the large volume of submissions received, we cannot guarantee answers to all questions.








