Check your local newsstands for the second annual CBS SportsLine.com Fantasy Baseball 2005 Owners Manual and Draft Guide. We provide draft strategies, position rankings, cheat sheets and over 850 Fantasy player profiles in this blockbuster issue.
Please e-mail your questions to bleacher@commissioner.com. Be sure to put Attn: Bleacher Banter in the subject field, and include your full name, hometown and state. Please be aware, due to the large volume of submissions received, we cannot guarantee personal responses or answers to all questions.
Each spring, our staff gets inundated with keeper inquiries, draft concerns and league setup questions from CBS SportsLine.com readers. We try to answer them in a timely manner, but the quantity is sometimes too great. Instead of adding one or two to our weekly columns, we've decided to add one to our daily spring notebook. This week, we thought we'd plow through a large number of them in a blockbuster edition of Bleacher Banter.
Seamus, Green Ridge, Penn.: In a 5x5 league, I am keeping two stud hitters and two stud starting pitchers, but I have to choose two more players from J.D. Drew, Joe Nathan, Corey Patterson, Carl Pavano and Aaron Rowand. I am leaning toward Patterson and Nathan.
B.B.: Patterson and Nathan are the correct choices here. Rowand had a breakout season, but Patterson should do more in three of the five hitting categories.
Joe Gorder, Kirkland, Wash.: When there is an interleague trade in our NL-only league involving players from two different Fantasy teams, the owner who had the "key player" who was traded gets the rights to the new NL player. One owner owned Charles Thomas and another owner had Juan Cruz. The stakes are Tim Hudson. Which of the former Braves mentioned is more a "key" to the deal than the other?
B.B.: Cruz has potential as a closer in the future, but the Athletics are so deep in the bullpen with Octavio Dotel, Huston Street and Kiko Calero that it might be awhile before Cruz gets a chance. Thomas has more Fantasy value now, since he has a good chance of starting in Oakland's outfield this year.
Zachary Weidner, Philadelphia: With Josh Beckett and Mark Prior having thrown minimal innings last year, do you expect nice rebound years from them? I am wary of guys who have thrown 200-plus innings for multiple years in a row since I had Javier Vazquez last year. Should I worry about guys like Livan Hernandez and maybe Carlos Zambrano?
B.B.: Huge seasons should be expected out of both young flamethrowers. Injuries derailed them last season, but both are healthy and young enough to still have tremendous upside. Don't be surprised if each pitches 200 innings, strikes out 200 batters and wins 15-plus games. Hernandez is an innings-eater, but since he pitches for the Nationals, he will likely cost you less than many with his ability. More risk is assumed with Zambrano, especially when you consider how the Cubs always seem to overthrow their young pitchers. But then again, more reward comes with Zambrano as well. If the tired-arm theory worries you, go with the cheaper Hernandez and back him up with a solid starter in the Greg Maddux mold later on.
Eric Klein, Edmonton, Alberta: I'm in a 12-team, Head-to-Head keeper league where we can protect five players. I've decided on Eric Gagne and Miguel Tejada but can't decide on the other three between Hank Blalock, Johnny Damon, Tim Hudson, Victor Martinez, David Ortiz and Oliver Perez.
B.B.: The best three left for Head-to-Head play are Martinez, Ortiz and Hudson. You've got a nice squad to start 2005.
Matt Kennedy, Sandusky, Ohio: I am in a mixed Head-to-Head keeper league. Stat categories are hits, runs, home runs, RBI, stolen bases, and errors for hitters. Pitching stats are wins, saves, WHIP, ERA and strikeouts. I must trim my roster to 25, so I need to cut three players. What three should I release: Ben Broussard, Paul Byrd, Vinny Castilla, Ryan Drese, Eric Hinske, Rob Mackowiak, Horacio Ramirez, Nate Robertson, Bob Wickman and Woody Williams?
B.B.: Toss back Broussard, Byrd and Mackowiak for now. Robertson and Hinske were also decent dump options, but Robertson should do well as the Tigers' fourth starter and Hinske might rebound now that he is the designated hitter without defensive worries.
Bill Headley, Chicago: I play in an eight-team Head-to-Head league and can only keep one of the following: Keith Foulke, Derrek Lee and Justin Morneau. I know that first base is not a hard position to fill, but closers don't seem to be as valuable.
B.B.: In an eight-team league, there are just too many first baseman to choose from. Granted Lee and Morneau should have big seasons, but both could be drafted as corner infielders in such a shallow league. Go with Foulke, who should notch another 30-plus save season.
Ozzie Vazquez, Jacksonville, Fla.: In a 5x5 Rotisserie league, I must protect six of the following players: Bobby Abreu, Adrian Beltre, Eric Chavez, Hideki Matsui, Kevin Millwood, Richie Sexson, Sammy Sosa, Javier Vazquez, Jose Vidro and Kerry Wood. I'm leaning toward protecting Abreu, Beltre, Matsui, Sexson, Vazquez and Wood.
B.B.: Abreu, Beltre, Chavez, Matsui, Sexson and Wood are your best choices. Sosa just misses the cut, though he could pound 45 homers at Camden Yards. We recommend throwing him back only because Sexson is younger and has better potential as a keeper over the next several years. Chavez is a definite keeper over Vazquez.
Anthony Bagdasarian, Dearborn, Mich.: I have to keep three of the following: Adam Dunn, Todd Helton, Johan Santana, Jason Schmidt and Mark Teixeira. Santana is a given, and maybe Helton, then it gets really tough.
B.B.: Keep Helton, Santana and Schmidt and don't look back. You have an excellent chance of owning the strikeouts category.
Ryan Roussel, Smyrna, Ga.: I'm in a 12-team Head-to-Head league that recently switched to a keeper format. I have to choose five out of the following 11 players: Orlando Hernandez, Tim Hudson, Jason Isringhausen, Chipper Jones, Hideki Matsui, Carl Pavano, Edgar Renteria, Francisco Rodriguez, Alfonso Soriano, Kerry Wood and Carlos Zambrano.
B.B.: Keep Hudson, Matsui, K-Rod, Soriano and Zambrano. You can't really go wrong with many of those, since all are in or very near our top 100.
John Dortmouth, Chicago: I have the No. 1 selection in a 10-team Head-to-Head keeper league. I am already protecting Victor Martinez, Jake Peavy and Michael Young. We use individual positions in the outfield. My question is do I select CF Carlos Beltran or 3B Alex Rodriguez with my pick?
B.B.: By using individual positions in the outfield, center field just got very shallow. Grab Beltran with your first pick. A-Rod is still a stud, but you can make up the difference later in the draft with a David Wright type pick, whereas you would struggle to find a center fielder like Beltran after the first few rounds.
Justin Teng, San Jose, Calif.: I just traded away Manny Ramirez and Juan Uribe for Carlos Lee and Brad Lidge. I'm wondering who got the better end of the deal. I was in desperate need of a closer, I had only an unproven Ryan Dempster and Danny Kolb. The rest of my lineup consists of guys like Hank Blalock, Pat Burrell, Jim Edmonds, Paul Konerko, Kevin Mench and Richie Sexson.
B.B.: Assuming this is a 5x5 league, I'd have to say both teams did well. You have enough power at other positions to make up for the departure of Ramirez, although Uribe's steals will need to be replaced. Lidge is a top-five closer who will help you tremendously in strikeouts as well as saves, ERA and WHIP.
Scott Stolper, Forest Hills, N.Y.: What do you think about punting saves? I have been unsuccessful in 12 years in obtaining a dominant closer. It just doesn't work for me. I'm thinking of just scrapping the closer position. Why waste the money when it could be put to good use elsewhere?
B.B.: Punting saves is not recommended, beacuse too many things have to go right for you to win a championship. Consider spending big money on one top closer (Lidge, K-Rod, Mariano Rivera) and then toss a dollar or two later in the draft on potential closers (like Lidge was last year). Think about Street, Juan Rincon, Mike Gonzalez and Yhency Brazoban. At worst, you hang among the middle of the saves group while you boost your ERA and WHIP numbers, and at best, you own the saves category if one or two come through. Either way, it will cost you less than spending average dollars on players like Jose Mesa, Danys Baez and Bob Wickman. That's as close as you should get to punting saves.
Bruce May, Cleveland: I am in a seven-team 5x5 Rotisserie league. I have to choose one keeper among: Barry Bonds, Miguel Tejada, Jason Schmidt or Jim Thome. I'm leaning more toward Tejada or Schmidt.
B.B.: Tejada will vie for his second AL MVP this season in that lineup. Schmidt and Bonds are awesome, but age makes them less valuable keepers, and Thome is at a relatively deep position.
Bernie Brown, Muskegon, Mich.: I'm in a 12-team, Head-to-Head league, in which we can keep 10 players. I am already keeping Bobby Abreu, Todd Helton, Tim Hudson, Derek Jeter, Roy Oswalt and Albert Pujols. For my last four spots, I have to choose from Mark Buehrle, Chris Carpenter, Keith Foulke, Kevin Millwood, Magglio Ordonez, Edgar Renteria and David Wright.
B.B.: Hold over Buehrle, Foulke, Renteria and Wright. Ordonez is a solid pick also, but his knee injury made enough general managers tentative that Fantasy owners should also be leery, especially when you are considering giving up a decent shortstop like Renteria.
Scott Greene, Nashua, N.H.: I'm in a 5x5, 10-team, 50-percent Head-to-Head, 50-percent Rotisserie keeper league. How's that for a mouthful? I can keep one more player along with Vladimir Guerrero, Randy Johnson and Johan Santana. I must choose between Victor Martinez, Aramis Ramirez or Javier Vazquez. Two expansion draft owners get to draft from players not protected and those of us that don't protect four players can draft from players not selected in the expansion draft. Do I keep Martinez (a four-category catcher) or take a chance and fill my fourth keeper slot with someone who has been left unprotected, like Nomar Garciaparra, Ben Sheets, Roy Oswalt, Jim Thome, Jake Peavy and Oliver Perez.
B.B.: Don't overthink this one: Keep Victor Martinez and enjoy solid stats from your catcher spot all year. Between Martinez, Vlad, Santana and Randy Johnson, you should be set for a huge year.
Ryan Patrick, Cleveland: I am in a Head-to-Head league in which we can keep three players from the following: Eric Chavez, Francisco Cordero, Nomar Garciaparra, Oliver Perez, Johan Santana, Curt Schilling, Jason Schmidt, Gary Sheffield, Alfonso Soriano and Jim Thome. I am leaning toward Santana, Schmidt and Soriano.
B.B.: You're like the tower of Pisa: You're leaning right. Despite that being one of the lamest things ever written in this column, go with Santana, Schmidt and Soriano.
Shane Besler, Dubuque, Iowa: I am in a 10-team Head-to-Head league. I will have the ninth pick in Round 1 and 12th pick in Round 2. I have been doing a lot of research trying to figure out who will be available for me to pick from in each round. I believe I am going to miss out on the offensive studs, so I was considering drafting two top-five pitchers, which should be available. If I do, that could put me behind with the big offensive producers, but give me a tremendous head start on my pitching staff. First, is this a good strategy? If so, what should I do the next two rounds?
B.B.: Don't cut off your options. You never know what will fall to you later in the draft. In most cases though, good starting pitching falls later than good power hitting. If two solid hitters fall to you at those spots, don't be afraid to pull the trigger. Decent starters will be available later.
Thomas Dean, Kansas City: I am in a league that rewards the worst performers instead of the best. In pitching, for instance, we earn Fantasy points for singles allowed (1 pt), doubles allowed (2), triples allowed (3), home runs allowed (4), losses (10) and appearances (2). Who were some of the top pitchers in these categories last year?
B.B.: Bizarro leagues are a great way to supplement your regular Fantasy Baseball play. Bizarro football leagues are great, too. Imagine cheering for a running back because he got only 1.3 yards per carry in a game. Usually, as is in this reader's case, the league rewards playing time combined with poor stats. You want a bad pitcher who gets sent out every fifth day, although if he pitches too poorly, he gets pulled and you get nothing. Pitchers on ugly staffs like Kansas City and Tampa Bay should be considered. And Coors Field finally turns pitchers into heroes in this type of league. Eric Milton gave up 43 homers last season (more than everyone but Jamie Moyer), and he now calls the heavy-hitting stadium of Citizens Bank Park home. Kenny Rogers and Kirk Rueter are also solid starters for you because of their penchant for allowing doubles -- both were top-10 with 50-plus last year. And Buehrle, Sidney Ponson and Carlos Silva led the league in hits allowed.
Derek van Dam, Atlanta: This is my Head-to-Head league's first year with keepers. I can keep four players from the following group: Johnny Damon, Nomar Garciaparra, Travis Hafner, Todd Helton, Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez, Gary Sheffield or Alfonso Soriano? I was thinking of the Big Unit, Helton and Soriano but I'm not sure whom I would take with my fourth pick.
B.B.: Along with the three you mentioned, toss in Gary Sheffield. His shoulder injury will worry you all year, but what he does when he is in the lineup -- an incredible lineup at that -- should be enough to help your team more than the others.
Paul Spence, Toronto: I am completely stumped on who to protect for my last spot. I am in a 5x5 AL-only keeper league and have to choose between Joey Gathright ($1) and Nick Swisher ($11). My other protected hitters have some pop: Jay Gibbons, Travis Hafner, Torii Hunter, Raul Ibanez Manny Ramirez and Ivan Rodriguez among others. Speed might be tough to find on Draft Day. I'm leaning toward Gathright on that basis (plus the extra $10 saved) but Swisher's potential in a keeper league is tough to ignore.
B.B.: Gathright is competing for the fourth outfielder's spot at this point, but you are correct: His speed could be a huge asset to your Fantasy team if he gets at-bats. Consider tossing back Gibbons and holding onto Swisher. Or if that has you skittish, release Gathright and try to draft him in the middle rounds. Swisher will compete with Dallas McPherson for the AL rookie of the year award this season.
You can e-mail your Fantasy Baseball questions to bleacher@commissioner.com. Be sure to put Attn: Bleacher Banter in the subject field. Please include your full name, hometown and state. Please be aware, due to the large volume of submissions received, we cannot guarantee personal responses or answers to all questions.







