
The Pittsburgh Penguins and their medical staff are under fire after it was discovered that Sidney Crosby does indeed have the mumps. The Penguins star showed up to the team’s morning skate Friday after missing Thursday’s practice due to feeling ill. That Friday, Crosby’s face was clearly swollen, a tell-tale symptom of the mumps, but he completed the full morning skate and addressed the media that morning.
With the NHL dealing with a mumps scare that had hit four teams already, how could a team allow the game’s most visible player to participate in practice while showing the most well-known symptom of the mumps?
Penguins GM Jim Rutherford and the team's head physician, Dr. Dharmesh Vyas faced the media Sunday to fill in some of the blanks as to why Crosby was allowed to participate in the practice despite the fact that he looked to be stashing a grapefruit in his right cheek.
According to Vyas, the team had reason to believe that a neck injury Crosby sustained in a game against the Carolina Hurricanes two weeks prior and a series of negative tests for the mumps made diagnosis more difficult.
"At the Carolina game, Sidney sustained an injury to the right side of his neck. At that time, he injured the submandibular, or salivary gland, on his neck," Vyas explained. "We came back to Pittsburgh, we tested him, including a CT scan, which showed the injury. Also, just to be safe, we tested him for mumps at that time and all the blood tests came as negative. We continued to follow that. He was on medications to bring the swelling down to let the injury resolve and once the medications were stopped, he developed swelling just next to that area."
Vyas said that the prior injury "confuses the picture" since Crosby had already dealt with swelling. Additionally, Crosby had shown no other symptoms of the disease like a fever or chills.
The team sent bloodwork to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Friday afternoon for a more sophisticated test and held Crosby out of Friday and Saturday's games while awaiting the results, which ended up coming back positive. Crosby has since been in isolation.
Crosby was confirmed to have been vaccinated before leaving for the Olympics last year, which is why Penguins doctors were surprised by his contracting the mumps.
However, according to Dr. Greg Wallace of the CDC, a two-dose vaccination for the mumps comes with only and 85-88 percent effectiveness. That means mumps can spread even within highly-vaccinated communities, and has, including the NHL now.
Other players in the league that have contracted mumps have previously been vaccinated including Corey Perry of the Anaheim Ducks and Ryan Suter of the Minnesota Wild who also participated in the Olympics.
Now that Crosby has participated in a practice while having a confirmed case of the mumps, his teammates and others around the Penguins including media and team personnel could have been exposed to the virus.
"Well, it’s obvious we’re concerned about it," Rutherford said of the disease possibly spreading through the team. "It’s a disease that’s going throughout the league and you just don’t know how far it can spread. So like Dr. Vyas said, we’re watching this on a regular basis."
Individuals who contract the mumps can be contagious before ever showing any symptoms, meaning that regardless of Crosby’s presence Friday, they were likely already exposed and even those vaccinated remain at risk.
"Mumps is spread by droplets of saliva or mucus from the mouth, nose, or throat of an infected person, usually when the person coughs, sneezes, or talks," according to the CDC's notification on how mumps is transmitted. "Items used by an infected person, such as soft drink cans or eating utensils, can also be contaminated with the virus, which may spread to others if those items are shared. In addition, the virus may spread when someone with mumps touches items or surfaces without washing their hands and someone else then touches the same surface and rubs their mouth or nose."
Even though Crosby may have already been contagious without knowing it, the fact that he was in the locker room, presumably drinking from water bottles and possibly touching items after touching his nose or mouth makes the disease’s spread through the Penguins seem almost inevitable.
That said, Tanner Glass of the New York Rangers contracted the mumps and there have been no further confirmed cases on that team since Glass’ diagnosis. It’s just a very unpredictable disease.
Given the sensitivity surrounding mumps currently, the Penguins will continue to face criticism for Crosby's presence with the team Friday.
"We can only go by the recommendation from the medical people," Rutherford said when discussing if the team made a mistake by letting him practice. "We’re not going to overrule them on anything. And quite frankly, that decision was approved that he could be here and his condition worsened after the skate."
The team may have to have a very stern discussion with their medical staff as this is beyond embarassing for the organization when any armchair doctor that saw the picture on Twitter probably could have put two and two together here. Even with the glandular injury Crosby suffered, heightened concern over mumps throughout the NHL should have made practicing with his face that swollen that much a non-starter. Beyond the embarassment, though, it's actually quite dangerous as now people inside and outside of the team may be exposed.
Crosby is expected to miss at least Monday’s game against the Tampa Bay Lightning, but could return later in the week. Questions and criticisms may persist well beyond his return, however.









