Mike Fiers is a conundrum. At various points in his career with the Brewers, Fiers has been the human equivalent of a batting practice machine, or one of the most befuddling pitchers on Earth for opposing batters. When we last saw him in 2014, it was this latter mask he donned, in racking up a 2.13 ERA over 71 2/3 innings down the stretch.
So far in 2015, however, the bad side of Fiers has come to the mound more often than not. After getting shelled yet again Thursday, his ERA now sits at 5.46, while he record fell to 1-4, causing much consternation among his Fantasy owners. This despite a league-leading 12.74 K/9, by far the highest mark of his career.
What makes him more confusing is when you dig into the advanced stats, which attempt to divine a pitcher's true performance level, removed from the distractions of things like defense and luck. In this regard, Fiers actually rates out pretty well, with his xFIP of 3.31 within spitting distance of the 3.15 mark he posted last season. I'll repeat myself: Mike Fiers is a conundrum.
Fiers has had some bad luck with batted balls so far, as a .413 BABIP makes clear. However, it might be fair to wonder how much we can attribute that to luck when he's been getting hit so hard so consistently; opposing hitters have an extra-base hit once every 10 trips to the plate against him, and 50 percent of batted balls against him have been classified as hard-hit. Last season, only 29.8 percent of his batted-balls were hit hard, so there's a clear difference there.
For a fly ball pitcher, that's a very, very bad thing. The home runs he has given up show that trend, as all six have gone at least 416 feet, with an average distance of 424.3 feet; the major-league average is 397.6 this season.
Of course, this doesn't really tell us too much about the "Why?" of Fiers' struggles. Yes, he's getting hit hard, that much is clear; but why is that happening? Is his velocity down? Are his pitches moving less? Is he throwing one pitch way more than he should be?
Looking at the PITCHf/x data from BrooksBaseball.net, it's not hard to see one culprit for Fiers' issues -- his fastball. Fiers is getting his fastball in at right around the same velocity as last season (90.5 miles per hour), but hitters really aren't having any trouble picking it up. Fiers is still picking up a swinging strike around 11 percent of the time with the four-seamer this season, so that hasn't been the issue. The issue is that, when they do make contact with it, they are hitting it a ton.
Fiers gave up just 10 extra-base hits on 649 four-seamers last season, as opposing hitters hit just /127 with a .127 Isolated Slugging percentage against it. This season, he has already given up the same number of XBH, on just 309 pitches. Opposing batters are hitting .308 with a .277 ISO in 65 at-bats ending against the fastball this season, with just four extra-base hits against the rest of his pitches over 63 at-bats.
And, when you look at the zone profiles from Brooks, the same thing shows up:


Batters are hitting .520 on fastballs in the middle and top-thirds of the strike zone; they hit just .147 against him last season on those same pitches. And, while 30.4 percent of his pitches were in that area of the zone, only 26.9 of them have been there this season. So, it's not that he's working up in the zone more often, he's just getting hard exceptionally hard when he does.
So, the fastball seems to be the main culprit, but again, that's an answer to the "What?" question. What it doesn't tell us is the "Why?" And it's hard to find an answer there. The level of movement both horizontally and vertically is nearly identical from last season to this, and he is releasing it from nearly the same point, so it's hard to find a smoking gun here.
The answer to why Mike Fiers is struggling so much this season very well may be, "We can't know." In the past, it's been easier to point to one or two things that made Fiers better or worse -- his cutter usage, or what side of the pitching mound he is throwing from. There may not be an answer that makes sense right now. Maybe he got lucky last season. Maybe he's getting unlucky this season.
That is undoubtedly an unsatisfactory conclusion to draw at the end of a bunch of research and 600-plus words of analysis. It's a long way to go to shrug your shoulders and say, "Dunno." For all we can keep track of and quantify in 2015, sometimes answers are still hard to come by.
The answer might be that Fiers pitches with an exceptionally small margin for error, more so than most pitchers you come across. What that might mean is, the difference between good Fiers and bad Fiers is imperceptible. He can look like the same guy from one start to the next, with wildly different results. That ultimately makes him tough to analyze and impossible to predict.
I am a beaten man. I have no concrete answers for Fiers. I have no idea if he can find the success that he had last season, or if that was even sustainable. I just traded him for Steve Pearce , who can't even find an everyday job with Baltimore just because I don't want to deal with him anymore.
Like I said, Mike Fiers is a conundrum.








