It's time to check in on the Cleveland Cavaliers, as one of their harshest critics declared that they are not ready for the playoffs. The statement was made after the Cavaliers lost 106-103 to the injury-riddled Memphis Grizzlies on Monday. The critic in question is rather familiar with the team. His name is LeBron James.
Cleveland has won 71 percent of its games, and it is in first place in the East. It has also been inconsistent, and the joylessness of watching this team is as confusing as its franchise player's social media activity. With five weeks left in the season, what are we to make of these Cavs? Our NBA experts weigh in on the situation in Cleveland in our latest 3-Man Weave.
Is LeBron doing more harm than good with all his Cavs criticism?
Ken Berger: Honestly, what's more alarming than his criticism is that it doesn't seem to be doing any good. And while he's been appropriately critical of everything from turnovers to the team's fragility to their obvious state of not being playoff-ready, something else stood out to me after Monday night's loss to the undermanned Grizzlies. James trotted out the old "we've only been together for a year and still have things to learn" excuse. Maybe "excuse" is too strong a word, because technically, what he said was true. But he's forgetting that his 2010-11 Miami team went to the Finals in its first year together, and so did this Cleveland team. When a team goes through a long playoff run together, the learning curve is supposed to speed up. Instead, the Cavs have regressed.
James Herbert: Probably. It's OK to call out your teammates, but you can only do that so many times publicly. We're at the point where, after every Cavs loss, you could conduct a fun game of what-will-LeBron-say. Will he mention their mental toughness? Maturity? Focus? After a recent loss in Toronto, he dramatically tore up the stat sheet while reporters waited for him to take questions. I'm sure he's frustrated, and he clearly has the clout to say whatever he wants. I'm just not sure this approach is going to work.
Zach Harper: I don't think so. I think he's doing far more good than harm. Granted, the passive aggressive social media stuff is weird and posting yourself as a cartoon Batman is an odd, almost corny way to go about it. However, what he's doing should help them weed out the players who aren't capable of truly helping them make a title push. Everybody has to buy in 100 percent to the cause and sacrifice the individual stuff. For LeBron, it's a selfish venture because to keep losing NBA Finals doesn't exactly bolster the résumé. But you also have a star who will be working on a relatively unprecedented run of six straight Finals appearances. He should have criticism and the players should be able to take it.
If they can't take it, then why are they there? The Cavs have a title or bust expectation during this second LeBron era. Whether you believe LeBron to be a great leader or not, he's leading the players into a level of expectation that so few teams truly get a chance at experiencing. If Kevin Love or Kyrie Irving or J.R. Smith or Timofey Mozgov or anybody else can't take the criticism, I'm not sure why he'd trust them to do the proper sacrifice to help everybody attain their goal.
Why has it been so hard for LeBron, Kyrie and Love to get on the same page?
Berger: They've had times when it's just James and Irving, and times when it's just James and Love. The habits and working conditions, so to speak, under those circumstances are vastly different than when all three have to find a way to play together. And when they are together, it seems that they expend more energy taking turns letting one of the Big Three carry the load, as opposed to everyone giving up a little something for the greater good. Usually the person whose job it is to sort that out is the coach, but Tyronn Lue is new to the job -- and James' presence is so strong that it overwhelms everyone around him, including the coach.
Herbert: Part of it is that LeBron and Love are both best when playing power forward. A lot of it is that Irving and Love are both vulnerable in pick-and-roll situations defensively. Most of all, it's the simple fact that sacrifice is difficult. Love looked a lot more comfortable earlier in the season when Irving was out and he and James could play off each other. The Cavs do not exactly have an egalitarian offense, and even Chris Bosh -- the poster child when it comes to sacrificing individual numbers in the prime of your career -- sometimes had trouble finding his rhythm as the third wheel. James' presence means Irving and Love will get open looks, but it also means they will be under an immense amount of pressure. It seems like they've all struggled to handle it.
Harper: There seems to be discomfort. LeBron doesn't seem comfortable with the level of focus and sacrifice his teammates are exhibiting. Love doesn't appear to be comfortable with his role on the floor as the third option. Kyrie doesn't seem comfortable with being enough of a team presence on offense to sacrifice his incredible scoring opportunities. If nobody is comfortable then you're not going to get trust. If you don't get trust, you're not on the same page. We saw it take a while for that comfort to exist when LeBron was with Dwyane Wade and Chris Bosh. Those guys were much better suited for eventually accepting what it takes to get on the same page and win a title. So far, Kyrie and Love aren't there. Maybe they'll get there but the hard part for them is the only true test can come from being back in the Finals. Before that point, you simply have to guess as to whether or not they have achieved that focus and comfort.
Is LeBron right? Are the Cavs not a true championship threat at this point?
Berger: On one hand, you can look at the Eastern Conference and say the Cavs have been on top all season, and in all likelihood will finish the regular season on top. Talent-wise and health-wise, they should be able to navigate through three playoff series and get back to the Finals. That's the glass-half-full approach if you're a Cavs fan. If you're not a Cavs fan -- or, if you're just objective -- you look at how Toronto has come on and how the Heat have kept winning without Chris Bosh and ask yourself, is it inconceivable that one of those teams could beat Cleveland four times in seven games? With the sometimes disjointed, always joyless brand of basketball the Cavs are playing, it's hardly inconceivable. So in that respect, James' analysis is dead on.
Herbert: Yes, he's right. At this point, it looks like Cleveland is easily the most talented team and marginally the best team in the East. Once the playoffs come, opposing coaches will be just about as terrified of LeBron as usual. No one, though, has much reason to pick the Cavs in a series against the Warriors or Spurs. They're just not clicking like they should be in March, and they somehow still seem to be searching for an identity. Cleveland remains a contender on paper, I guess, but something will have to change for it to be anything more than that.
Harper: I don't think LeBron is technically right. It's not like this is the 2007 Finals team in any way. The Cavs found a way to scrap together a 2-1 lead in the Finals last year when they were down so many weapons. Being able to win games and put pressure on the Warriors or Spurs (or someone else?) in the Finals will happen. Being able to threaten their eventual Finals opponent (assuming the Raptors don't break through) seems inevitable. There's too much talent and potential on the roster to not force that threat. However, the Cavs aren't exhibiting the mentality you want to see. And they're not currently building toward their best play as they enter the postseason (at least not yet). Until that happens, LeBron should keep telling them how far they are from being a true championship threat. You have to motivate that focus and sacrifice somehow.









