When familiar faces go to new places, we like to make comparisons to what used to be. LeBron James leaves the Miami Heat to return home to the Cleveland Cavaliers, and in the process we see Kevin Love acquired to complete the Big Three formation pretty quickly. That leads us to wondering if Kyrie Irving can be the new Dwyane Wade, and Kevin Love can become the new Chris Bosh. What LeBron did in Miami has to be replicated in Cleveland.

It's not all that different when coaches change teams. Scott Brooks was recently hired in Washington and we're already talking about how he can do with John Wall and Bradley Beal what he did with Kevin Durant and Russell Westbrook. We forget that it's a new team. New players. Things don't happen in a vacuum. 

When the Detroit Pistons signed Stan Van Gundy to take over as both front-office shot-caller and coach, we immediately thought of his old Orlando Magic teams and asked how he could shape the Pistons in the same way. We wanted to know, specifically, how he'd turn Andre Drummond into his new Dwight Howard. It was asking a lot. Howard is a four-time Defensive Player of the Year and an eight-time All-NBA big man. We forget how truly dominant he once was, especially in Orlando, and yet we so casually expected to Drummond to replicate that level of impact.

SVG's system in Orlando, built around a dominant big man, wasn't exactly rocket science. Howard demands attention, usually in the form of a double team, thus creating open looks on the perimeter. And vice versa. Once the guards get going, particularly from 3-point range, the defense reacts accordingly and Howard goes to work in the post and on the glass. 

Never mind that the Pistons don't have the shooters to make this sort of attack consistently viable in the first place. Asking Drummond to anchor an offense in the way Howard once did is simply more convenient than fair. Yes, Drummond is capable of controlling the boards on both ends of the floor as well as anybody in the NBA, and he stinks at free throws. But really, that's where the comparisons between the two end. 

Dwight's second year with Orlando under Van Gundy (2008-09) was complete destruction for the rest of the league. Drummond's second year under Van Gundy hasn't been as fruitful, though Drummond was named an All-Star by the coaches. The learning curve has been slower than a lot of people expected, but again, that's not on Drummond so much as it is the people framing the expectations.

To be fair, this is just Drummond's fourth year in the NBA, and he's a year younger than Dwight was during that second season with SVG. Howard, who came straight out of high school, was also in his fifth season in the NBA at that point, and even that one extra year of experience can mean a world of difference in a young big man's development.

Take a look at the tale of the tape.

Howard was just a better player at that stage than Drummond is now, and it's not even as close as these numbers might indicate. Drummond is a superior rebounder (he led the league in double-doubles this year) and he doesn't turn the ball over nearly as much, but he's also not asked to play-make in the same way Howard was in Orlando. And Howard was about twice the rim protector Drummond is capable of being right now. It's those areas around the basket on both ends of the floor that show such a stark contrast in the two.

Comparing Andre Drummond to Dwight Howard
Season Post-up Freq Post-up PPP Post-up FG% PnR Freq PnR PPP PnR FG% Off. Reb. Freq Off. Reb. PPP Off. Reb. FG%
Andre Drummond
15-16 27.5% 0.776 40.4% 13.2% 1.103 62.3% 23.3% 1.079 58.9%
Dwight Howard
08-09 57.8% 0.933 48.0% 4.5% 1.361 72.5% 15.6% 1.248 65.9%

The difference between posting up Drummond vs. posting up Howard is staggering. We've often thought of Dwight as a guy who can't post up, but that's not necessarily the case. Orlando did it a lot during that title run, and he was pretty effective at it considering how ineffective post play has become under the help defense rules of the past 11 years. The Magic were the 11th ranked offense in the NBA in 2008-09, and improved to fourth the next season as Dwight's frequency of posting up increased to over 60 percent of his possessions.

Drummond, on the other hand, is an apocalyptic wasteland when he posts up. He doesn't convert a high percentage of those shots, and he's not exactly making up for it at the free throw line. While Dwight flirting with 60 percent during that time is not a good free throw percentage, he looks like Chauncey Billups next to Drummond's barely 35 percent from the line.

Also, Drummond isn't nearly as effective in the pick-and-roll as Howard was, though the frequency in which he runs these sets is incredibly impactful. Drummond is in the 72nd percentile in the NBA in pick and rolls, in fact, which is pretty good considering the Pistons struggle to make shots around him, which would open the floor up even more.

Defensively, Drummond struggles as a rim protector now, and that can greatly hurt the system in which Van Gundy wants to run teams off the 3-point line and use the threat of the giant at the rim as a deterrent into forcing up less efficient mid-range shots. This season, Synergy Sports has Drummond allowing 54 percent of shots to go in around the basket. During the 08-09 season, Howard was an absolute monster in protecting the rim -- not just blocking shots but consistently altering them. He allowed 41.5 percent around the basket.

Again, Howard was just better. 

That said, the team around him was better, too. 

In Orlando, Van Gundy inherited a 40-win team with a pretty solid roster. In Detroit, Van Gundy inherited a team that looked nothing like what his ideal team would have. He's changed nearly everything surrounding Drummond in a short amount of time and it's all still a work in progress. That's what makes these convenient comparisons so tricky across the board. You have to remember that the context of the player, team and league all greatly impact what we want to be an apples-to-apples comparison.

None of this is to say, "Hey, Andre Drummond stinks! He's nothing like Dwight Howard!" Andre Drummond does not stink. Andre Drummond is very good. An All-Star. And he's getting better all the time. He's just not what Howard once was. And the Pistons aren't that Magic team. They've been scrappy and unafraid against the Cleveland Cavaliers so far in this first-round, and that's a great start. But the talent disparity keeps them from being truly competitive.

Van Gundy has had good success against LeBron in his career, but he also the necessary level of talent to combat such an overpowering opponent. After Game 1, it looked like that success could be replicated, and that while an upset wasn't likely, we'd still see the Cavaliers pushed beyond comfort in closing out a series against an SVG team. In Game 2, we saw just how thin that thinking is. Detroit just doesn't have the firepower. 

Without that firepower, you need the giant in the middle to raise the level of everyone around him. And Drummond just isn't that guy. He's still so young and has plenty of time to become a version of the player we're so inclined to compare him to, but he's got a long way to go. That's not a knock on him (at least not yet). It's just a reminder of how special Howard was under SVG before the back injury, and how hard prior success can be to mimic in a new setting.

Making the Drummond-Howard comparison is hard to do.  (USATSI)
Making the Drummond-Howard comparison is unfair. (USATSI)