
When asked about Jay Cutler, new Chicago Bears offensive coordinator Adam Gase described his relationship with the contentious signal-caller as "comfortable." He joked about Cutler's weight loss in recent years. He talked about Cutler's maturation now that he's married, a father of two (soon to be three), and has been around the NFL for close to a decade.
Gase was nothing but complimentary towards Cutler as the pair gets set to embark on their first year together as offensive coordinator and starting quarterback.
So, now that Gase has finally had his chance to say his piece on Cutler, it's time to pose the question that is asked before the onset of nearly every NFL season.
Is this the coach who will finally fix Jay Cutler?
Mike Tice, along with many other offensive coordinators, failed when he was given the chance. A month prior to the start of his first and only season as the Bears offensive coordinator in 2012, Tice labeled his relationship with Cutler as "great." By the end of the season, Cutler and Tice weren't even on speaking terms, with the pair communicating through a liaison.
Former Bears offensive coordinator Mike Martz once called working with Cutler a "dream." Martz would fare better than Tice, lasting two years. But let's not forget when Cutler told Martz to "(expletive) off" on national television, or when Cutler hinted that Martz's system didn't hold up against modern defenses.
The list of former coaches is unending, but Martz offers the perfect transition to Gase.
"(Cutler's) worked with a couple different guys, the good thing is, he's heard a few things that I say," Gase said. "He'll look at me and kind of, 'That's a little Martzist,' right there."
Martz served as the Bears offensive coordinator in 2010 and 2011. Under his tutelage, Cutler posted some pretty mediocre stats -- he completed 59 percent of his passes and his quarterback rating averaged out at 86. Sure, his win-loss record was 17-8 under Martz, and sure, he and Martz went to the NFC title game together, but the reason why Gase's quote is so interesting doesn't have anything to do with his win-loss record and his lone playoff appearance, which should both be treated as team statistics -- not quarterback statistics.
The number that's most important to understanding the impact of Martz on Cutler is 2.95 -- Cutler's interception rate while working with Martz. For the sake of comparison, here are Cutler's interception rates playing under coordinators not named Mike Martz in Chicago.
- Under Ron Turner: 4.7 percent
- Under Mike Tice: 3.2 percent
- Under (head coach) Marc Trestman: 3.3 percent
The reason for the lower number under Martz is because Martz took freedom away from Cutler and asserted his control over his quarterback. Under Martz, Cutler couldn't audible at the line of scrimmage and his reads were more limited. In essence, Martz tried to simplify the game for Cutler.
And, well, it worked. Cutler's mistakes were turned down a notch.
That's not to say Cutler wasn't frustrated with the restraints placed upon him. Like all quarterbacks, Cutler wants freedom to operate within the system. But if his nine-year career has proven anything, it's that Cutler doesn't deserve that freedom. He's a very talented quarterback who, if not for his massive contract, would be sought after by more than a few teams that are currently deprived of a proper NFL quarterback.
But Cutler also has a well documented history of turning over the football. He's also never developed into the kind of passer so many people thought he would turn into. For nine years, Cutler has been on the cusp of greatness and for nine years, he's always fallen short of reaching that future.
If Gase taps into the good aspects of a Martz offense and blends together the kind of system that allows Cutler to walk the fine line between reckless and careful, he could be the offensive coordinator that finally allows Cutler to rise above mediocrity. Sure, it'll come down to more than just Gase -- football is still a team game and the Bears defense is still in need of surgery -- but at the end of the season, he'll be the one credited if Cutler rises.
Luckily for him, Martz might have provided him a portion of the blueprint.









