
Coach Killers is your weekly look around the league at those performances, decisions and "Wait, what did he just do?!" moments that put the guy in charge squarely on the ol' hot seat. Questions, comments, casserole ideas? Hit us up on Twitter at @ryanwilson_07.
Jay Cutler, QB, Bears
Fifty weeks ago we wrote that Jay Cutler finally looked like a legit franchise quarterback. The reasoning went something like this: Cutler wasn't at the mercy of Mike Martz or Mike Tice, but was in the capable hands of Marc Trestman, widely considered to be something of a quarterback guru.
Trestman's so good, in fact, that he made journeyman Josh McCown, who replaced an injured Cutler for five games last season, into a very good quarterback. (To the point that there were questions about whether McCown should keep the job when Cutler was healthy. He didn't but it came up.) Cutler, meanwhile, ranked 13th in total QB value, according to Football Outsiders, which earned him a seven-year, $126 million contract in January.
With a year in Trestman's offense, and playing alongside Alshon Jeffery, Brandon Marshall and Matt Forte, it was reasonable to expect Cutler to be even better in 2014. As in: This group might be able to match the Packers' firepower and give them a run for the NFC North title.
Well, if the Packers looked uninspired in their Thursday loss in Seattle, the Bears -- and Cutler in particular -- were worse in Sunday's home loss to a Bills team that many had finishing last in the AFC East.
Cutler finished 34 of 49 for 349 yards with 2 touchdowns and 2 interceptions. On its face, not horrible numbers, but his timing couldn't have been worse. There were all the hallmarks of the pre-Trestman Bears offense: The poor decision-making, iffy play-calling and piss-poor pass-blocking.
Cutler's first interception came with 5:50 left in the second quarter and the Bears trailing 10-7. Corey Graham took a pass intended for tight end Martellus Bennett and returned it 45 yards. It set up an EJ Manuel touchdown pass a play later.
In the fourth quarter, Cutler was again looking for Bennett. This time defensive tackle Kyle Williams had to do little more than put his hands out for the interception.
Plays like this typically lead the announcer to proclaim, "The quarterback just didn't see the defender on that play!" Except that Williams is generously listed at 303 pounds and he was standing no more than 10 yards away from Cutler, who stared in his general direction before throwing the ball right into his ample gut.
Too bad Bennett wasn't calling the game.
Martellus Bennett on Cutler's second pick: "I don't know what happened on that s--- . The fat guy got a pick."
— Michael C. Wright (@mikecwright) September 7, 2014
Cutler took full responsibility Monday for his shoddy performance.
"The guys know, we're not idiots," he said during his weekly appearance on ESPN 1000. "We all take accountability. Whenever we did mess up, we seemed to mess up pretty big. That last interception was a tough one. I've got to throw the ball away or run."
Bears fans are familiar with this Jay Cutler. The question is whether this was a one-time thing or a preview of what the next four months might look like. Are the Bills are better than anybody figured? Sure, anything's possible. But it's more likely that Cutler's carelessness, if not corralled by Trestman, could be this team's downfall.
"I've seen Jay in my time here do a lot of the right things with the football," Trestman said. "I can't speak for anything else. I'm disappointed for the team, and I see how hard he works and what he puts into it. He lost himself for a minute and made a decision that I know we've seen other great quarterbacks make, and he certainly made it there. As I said today he's taken accountability for that and responsibility for that decision."
Alex Smith, QB, Chiefs
This isn't Alex Smith's fault. We're not completely convinced the Chiefs should have given Smith that four-year, $68 million extension just before the season, but that has less to do with him and more to do with what the contract signifies: By keeping him around for the foreseeable future, the Chiefs are delaying the search for their next young franchise quarterback.

You could make that argument about the Broncos, too. But having a 38-year-old Peyton Manning under center is a slightly different proposition than trotting Smith out there. One's a first-ballot Hall of Famer. The other personifies the game-managing quarterback. And "game manager" isn't a pejorative. Smith had a lot to do with taking the two-win Chiefs to 11-5 and the playoffs. But he's not a long-term solution, which is why devoting money toward a guy who isn't bringing a championship to Kansas City in the near term doesn't seem especially forward-thinking.
In the Chiefs' loss to the Titans on Sunday, Smith threw three interceptions -- two on deep throws -- a consequence of asking him to do too much. Kansas City was without wide receiver Dwayne Bowe and De'Anthony Thomas (not to mention the the defense lost Derrick Johnson and Mike DeVito to season-ending injuries).
"He was trying to make something happen, and things didn’t work," coach Andy Reid said of Smith. "Those are calls down there, opportunities for shots. They had him covered."
"Those are the little things, and they add up," Smith added. "All of a sudden you look up and the scoreboard looks like that."
This will be a recurring theme for Smith and the Chiefs throughout the season. But without a defense that can keep games close, Smith will spend a lot Sundays trying to mount comebacks, something he's not particularly adept at. Again, this isn't all on him but it's not like there's a young, viable alternative currently on the roster.
Ravens offense, 'featuring' Joe Flacco, QB
Before there was Andy Dalton there was Joe Flacco. Likable enough but uninspiring, inconsistent and ultimately overpaid. But Flacco quieted the gum-flappers when he caught fire during the 2012 postseason and led the Ravens to a championship. Last year, Baltimore slipped to 8-8, but that had less to do with Flacco's pedestrian numbers than a horrible offensive line, a suspect running game and no deep threat after Torrey Smith.
But this season was going to be different; the O-line would be better, tight end Dennis Pitta would be healthy, and Steve Smith would reprise the role of cagey veteran that Derrick Mason perfected during a six-year run in Baltimore. Instead, the Ravens were down two touchdowns to the Bengals on Sunday before mounting a half-hearted comeback that eventually came up short.
If one moment embodied Flacco's afternoon, it was the final play of the first half. Trailing 15-0, with eight seconds left in the second quarter and in field-goal range, Flacco inexplicably did this:
"That was probably the stupidest play I've ever made in football," Flacco said.
But it's not all on the quarterback. The Ravens have a new offensive coordinator, Gary Kubiak, who was fired as the Texans' coach after going 2-14 last season. TheMMQB.com's Andy Benoit tweeted that it was "evident that the Ravens' wide receivers and tight ends aren't yet comfortable with the timing or spacing of Kubiak’s offense," adding that the "receivers were horrendous in the first half -- drops, stumbles and bad routes."
Also not helping: The defense was all but invisible.
Ravens have no sacks, zero quarterback hits
— Aaron Wilson (@RavensInsider) September 7, 2014
Offensively, there are no easy fixes; new coordinators take time to gel with new players and this is part of the process. Fans are a notoriously fickle bunch not known for their patience. If there's reason for optimism, at least for Thursday night's matchup with the Steelers, it's that Pittsburgh's defense was thoroughly outclassed in the second half of Sunday's opener ... by the Browns.

Steelers defense
"You're old and slow." That was the knock on the Steelers' D in recent years but not now. In fact, the unit might be too young. That's likely a short-term problem until first-round linebackers Ryan Shazier (2014) and Jarvis Jones (2013) get comfortable in Dick LeBeau's scheme. The same holds for free-agent acquisition Mike Mitchell, who replaces Ryan Clark at safety. But this group was shredded by the Eagles' no-huddle, up-tempo attack in the third preseason game, and the Browns replicated that success in the second half of the regular-season opener.
Cleveland's offensive line made gaping holes for rookie backs Terrance West and Isaiah Crowell, including this 15-yard waltz into the end zone:
Steelers coach Mike Tomlin said the no-huddle made sideline-to-player and player-to-player communication difficult for the defense, which means we'll keep seeing offenses do this until the Steelers show they can stop it. It could be the jump-start the Ravens' offense needs Thursday.
Of course, that works both ways: the Steelers offense was unstoppable in the first 30 minutes against the Browns, racking up 27 points. Then again, preconceived notions of what may happen when these two teams get together usually mean nothing because inevitably the game will be decided by a field goal.
Giants, all of them
The Giants are terrible. Apparently, a new offensive coordinator calling for Eli Manning to complete 70 percent of his passes doesn't magically make it true.
"We don't have a lot to be proud of," coach Tom Coughlin said after the Giants were humiliated on national television 35-14 by the Lions. "It was a nightmare performance. I don't think there's anyone in that locker room that doesn't realize that the bubble's been burst."
Manning completed 55 percent of his passes, though that number jumps to 61 percent if you include his two interceptions.
Luckily, no one's overreacting:
Just got off the plane. Sense I'm getting from everyone: Sign Incognito, Winston. Fire McAdoo, Fewell, trade Randle + sign Donnell long term
— Conor Orr (@ConorTOrr) September 9, 2014
Meanwhile, save this Vine:
Get used to that face because that's the face of the 2014 Giants.
We're one of Tony Romo's biggest supporters. We think he's a top-10 quarterback and generally undeserving of the much of the criticism that comes his way. Well, on Sunday, he was terrible, throwing three interceptions against the 49ers in a game that was over by halftime.
There is good news, however: According to coach Jason Garrett, who probably won't make it to Jan. 1, rust wasn't the reason Romo stunk -- it was a bunch of stuff.
"So he needs to get in there and play just like everybody else does," Garrett said. "When players come back off of an injury, you have to have a plan for them to get themselves healthy. We thought it was important to do the things we did to give him an opportunity to play [Sunday].
"Sure you want more reps. You want more reps for everybody. That’s the nature of it. At the same time, you've got to go play given what the situation is. Was he as sharp as he's been in his life? No. He made some bad decisions in this game that really hurt us. There were some other throws that weren't perfect. But there were some good throws, too. He'll learn from this. He'll watch the tape, just like he's done in the past and move forward."

This never would've happened if Jerry Jones had drafted Johnny Manziel.









